facebook instagram facebook instagram

New York Pizza

CLOSED
$$ •

1010 Oxmoor Rd, Birmingham

New York Pizza Reviews

I love calzone, but too often they're dry, with a bland tomato sauce on the side. The feta, cheddar, and mozzarella calzone at New York Pizza was moist, flavorful, had a crunchy crust, and was served with a side of tangy marinara with just a touch of spice. I liked the sauce enough I got another little cup of it with my to-go.

Ok, I'm biased, let's get that out of the way. I've been eating at NYP since I was 3. I used to sit on the counter behind the plastic barrier and watch them make our pizza 30 years ago when it was in the corner spot on that strip. Their sauce is incredible and really not like anything else you'll find. Pro tip: get garlic bread and ask for a side of sauce. And get extra sauce on your pizza as well.

Why does every pizza place that wants to advertise that they are the shite have to say they serve "NY Pizza". But then when you try it, it's nothing like NY Pizza. Don't get me wrong the pizza is adequate, you won't pick up and move to Alabama because of this place, but if you are craving pizza this place will do a decent job in filling that hole. This is a no-frills kind of place. If you are looking to impress a date, keep looking for a place. The area has a small-town feel,...read full review

More Reviews(147)

Ratings

View all photos
Updated on: