11 Best Sandwich Shops in Fayetteville

Hammontree's Grilled Cheese Sandwich Shop • $
326 N West Ave #8, Fayetteville

Customers` Favorites

Panco Fried Artichoke Hearts with Roasted Garlic Dippin Sauce
Sweet Potato Fries with Avocado Ranch Dippin' Sauce
Bacon Gouda Sweet Potato Fries
Where the Wild Things Are
The Italian Stallion
Ozark Monte Cristo
Gouda-Bacon Fries
Bacon Gouda Fries
The Beatnik
Parmageddon

“I’ve visited Hammontree’s Grilled Cheese several times! It is my go-to place to take my friends and family that are visiting from my hometown in Indiana when we’re in NWA. My coworkers and I visited Hammontree’s at the beginning of March! My typical order is either The Beatnik or Where the Wild Things Are. On this particular day, I decided to try the Parmageddon for the first time! It was so good!! The burgundy sauce just took it to the next level. They had updated the menu since I had been there, and you can get basically all their grilled cheese with chips and pickle for $12. I actually really enjoy this update! I highly recommend the sweet potato fries or gouda bacon fries as an appetizer. The atmosphere is unlike any other! It’s fun and eclectic!! The Hammontree’s Team is always kind and professional. Thank you for what you contribute to the NWA and Arkansas food scene!Vegetarian options: The Caprese Melt, Parmageddon, The Beatnik, Where the Wild Things Are, Jack to the Future, and Brie’s Company are all vegetarian grilled cheese options. They have a few vegetarian appetizers and soups too! Any hotdog can be made a veggie dog, FOR NO CHARGE!“

4.6 Superb113 Reviews
Chicken Salad Chick Southern • $
352 E Joyce Blvd #5, Fayetteville

Customers` Favorites

The Chick a Scoop of Dillicious Diva a Scoop of Lauryn's Lemon Basil and Tomato Bisque Soup
Loaded Potato Soup Scoop of Sassy Scotty Scoop of Pimento Cheese
Turkey Club on a Croissant with Lettuce & Tomato
Fruity Fran Mac and Cheese and Tomato Bisque
Chicken Salad with a Side of Fresh Fruit
Dixie Chick with a Scoop of Sassy Scotty
Kickin' Kay Lynn and Broccoli Salad
Chicken Salad blt Sandwich
Slice of Pina Colada Pie
Turkey Club Sandwich

“First time for my wife and I to try a delicious chicken salad on your choice of bread or bed of lettuce , we got the trio lunch, which consisted of loaded potato soup, fruit bowl, and croissant loaded with Chicken Salad, this chicken salad is best lip smacking we have ever eaten , the loaded potato soup is fantastic my taste buds was doing backflips for this tasty delight . Folks, you need to stop in and visit Chicken Salad Chick in Fayetteville, Arkansas. You want be disappointed.“

4.4 Superb60 Reviews
Jersey Mike's Subs Sandwich Shop • $
160 E Joyce Blvd #101, Fayetteville

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Philly
Cheesesteak

“This a fabulous place to get sandwiches. They are so fresh and delicious. They don’t spare the filling. No matter what you order it is a lot of food. Bread is great. I get the Asiago roll and it is so tasty. I highly recommend this place.“

4.3 Superb61 Reviews
TJ's Sandwich Shop & Hugs Ice Cream Sandwich Shop • $
2992 N College Ave, Fayetteville

Customers` Favorites

Mediterranean Pasta Salad
Chef TJ's Cheese Steak
Spicy Bird Sandwich
French Dip Sandwich
Brooklyn Bad Boy
Italian Stallion
Grilled Cheese
Caveman Club
Tomato Basil
Tomato Soup

“The food was beyond my expectations. My 9 year old is a very picky eater especially when it comes to grill cheese. She told me when eating that it deserved 5 stars ?. Service was extremely helpful giving it was our first time. The guy at the counter, Maddox, gave quick clear suggestions and was patience with my questions. After ordering I heard the cook double checking with Maddox who double checked with me to ensure our order was right. Great communication with the team. Good job everyone ?“

4.2 Good76 Reviews
Stone Mill Bread Co Bakery • $
2600 N Gregg Ave, Fayetteville

Customers` Favorites

Breakfast Sandwich
West Coast Special
Cinnamon Roll
Reuben

“The remodeling is beautiful! Plenty of room and seating options. Lots of menu features and the wait staff are friendly and very helpful. Had a delightful lunch with a friend. NOTE: This is a very POPULAR place to meet/eat in the Fayetteville community, families, co-workers, etc. Lunch fills up quickly. We met up for a late lunch (1:30ish), worked out perfectly. Recommendations: chicken salad ??, BLT with avocado ???. For the soup crowd: potato soup, ? ?, but a different soup each day.“

4.2 Good32 Reviews
McAlister's Deli Sandwich Shop • $
4055 N Steele Blvd, Fayetteville

Customers` Favorites

Jalapeño Turkey Crunch Sandwiche with Tomatoe Bisque
Chicken Sandwich on a Croissant
Baked Potato with Veggies
Chicken Tortilla
McAlister's Club
The McAlister
Chicken Salad
Nacho Basket
Potato Salad
Cheese Dip

“Awesome place for a salad or sandwich! I first tried them using DoorDash, and the food was so fresh that I wanted to go in person. Great, kind service and great food! I recommend it if you're looking for a light, fresh meal.Vegetarian options: You can actively choose to supplement things or to get one of their salads sans meat.Dietary restrictions: I have cheese removed from my salads due to being lactose intolerant.“

3.8 Good73 Reviews
Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe Sandwich Shop • $
410 W Dickson St, Fayetteville

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza

“3/5 cookie 5/5 Turkey Bacon, with avocado: good toasting, fresh produces and excellent bacon. Busy because bc of a well populated college. The music matches the vibes but there was just a lot of people. The decorations fit well. The service wasn't too bad despite being busy.“

3.8 Good49 Reviews

8
Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
2000 N Crossover Rd, Fayetteville

Customers` Favorites

Sweet Onion Chicken Teriyaki
Meatball Marinara

“Subway pricing has gotten out of hand. What happened to $5 footlongs? I mean, I'd be ok with a price increase but we are at $9 now for a cold-cut sub? Please! Give me a break. Best we can afford is splitting a sub these days between 2 people. It's gotten sad. And the portions have not changed, it's still like 8 slices of meat and that's $9?? Please, explain. I'd assume their profit margin is about 7,000% on a tuna sub. Jokes aside, I go to Subway about 80% less than I used to because of this garbage.This location - nothing special. Guy serving was nice, but then again, we were literally the only people there. We stayed and ate, the atmosphere is dull (to be expected), but no one else even came in the whole time we were there. It was dinner. It was a friday.“

4 Good14 Reviews

9
Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
1100-1250 M.L.K. Jr Blvd, Fayetteville

Customers` Favorites

Rotisserie-Style Chicken
Miss Vickie's Chips
Black Forest Ham
Steak & Cheese
Spicy Italian
Cookies

“5/19/2023 @ 9:30pmThis young lady working by herself ( by herself ) probably not the safest thing by herself! Anywho she did a absolutely fantastic job on me & my wife’s subs. This very young lady preformed her job without error and to our satisfaction indeed. Bravo to her credit, thank you young lady and thank you subway“

3.6 Good29 Reviews
Firehouse Subs Fayetteville Sandwich Shop • $
1364 E Augustine Ln Ste 2, Fayetteville

Customers` Favorites

Italian Grilled Chicken Salad
Firehouse Steak Cheese Small
Tuna Salad Sub Large
Smoked Turkey Breast
Submarine Sandwich
Hook Ladder Large
Veggie Medium
Pastrami
Chips

“Went to Firehouse in Fayetteville this evening..great subs as always BUT y’all had 1 poor kid working. That’s it. He was taking orders and making the sandwiches with no help…and he was busting his butt too!! He should get double pay for his hours tonight!!“

3.5 Good35 Reviews
Schlotzsky's Sandwich Shop • $
2548 N College Ave, Fayetteville

Customers` Favorites

BBQ Chicken & Jalapeno Pizza
Schlotzsky's Potato Chips
French Dip Sandwich
The Original
Cheese Pizza

“Both the food and the service were great at this location! I liked that the order taker made me aware of the price difference between ordering a sandwich and drink a la carte and ordering a meal so I got the best deal for what I wanted.The absolute best part of any Schlotsky's sandwich in my opinion is the delicious bun! I recommend trying their sandwiches just for the bun if nothing else!“

3.5 Good42 Reviews
Loading...
map Map