20 Best American Restaurants in Eureka

Golden Harvest Cafe American • $
1707 Allard Ave, Eureka

Customers` Favorites

SM Biscuits and Gravy with Mushrooms Added
Eggs Benedict with Bacon and Ham
Chicken Fried Steak & Eggs
Side of Country Potatoes
Original Potato Pancakes
California Crepes
Harvest Bendict
Tofu Scramble
Hot Cakes

“The food is so good here for breakfast. Service is sort of slow at times but usually friendly. The restaurant is very cold at times and very hot at other times depending on where you sit I guess. I enjoy going because of the very good food and that is what counts the most.“

4.6 Superb72 Reviews
Five Eleven American • $$
511 2nd St, Eureka

Customers` Favorites

North Bay Shellfish Kumamoto Oysters
Polenta Crostini
Ceasar Salad
Duck Confit
Bolognese
Lasagna

“Update 3/2024: they changed their mushroom polenta crostini to Polenta Crostini with Ragu. While I get the chef is an Italian chef, this isn’t an Italian restaurant. While it was good, won’t be re-ordering something I used to always order. Won’t remove a star for it as everything else was still on point. Please bring back the original polenta. Speghetti sauce & not formed polenta ruins it.12/2023:511 has always been my fave restaurant here. Went there tonight and had the best food ever. It’s always been great but this was so so good. It was on point, delicious and what I kept referring to as a “foodgasm”. Food was so good that I only remembered to take pics of the main course. Forgot the appetizer & deserts. Their drinks are perfect although there’s usually a long wait to get a drink there for some reason. The Chocolate & Espresso pot de créme desert needs to stay on the menu. It was heavenly. The Bananas Fosters” Cake– Brûléed had a bit of crispiness on the top which took it up a few notches above any others I’ve ever tried. Nice touch.Appetizer (a repeat that I always get):POLENTA CROSTINI – Shiitake mushroom marsala, parmesan, herbsEntree:WOODFIRED FILET MIGNON (8oz) – Black truffle compound butter, crispy phyllo potatoes, broccolini & butter braised leeks, demi-glaceEntree:GRILLED STEELHEAD – Lobster risotto, grilled asparagus, beurre blanc 38Deserts:Chocolate & Espresso pot de créme– Cinnamon whipped cream“Bananas Fosters” Cake– Brûléed, vanilla ice cream, spiced rum caramel“

4.6 Superb61 Reviews
Sea Grill Seafood • $$
316 E St, Eureka

Customers` Favorites

Surf and Turf or Land & Sea I Can't Remember
Pan Fried Oysters - Local Pacifics 6
Smooth Oysters on the Half Shell
Macadamia Crusted Halibut
Dungeness Crab Fettuccine
Crab Fettuccine Alfredo
Oysters Rockefeller
Sea Grill Chowder
Kumamoto Oysters
Lobster Alfredo

“Incredible food with excellent staff in a gorgeous Victorian building. Maybe the best clam chowder I’ve had! Delicious kunomoto ousters, crav cakes, scallops, double stuffed potato and chocolate pecan tort for dessert. Absolutely recommend!!“

4.5 Superb69 Reviews
Adel's Restaurant American • $
1724 Broadway St, Eureka

Customers` Favorites

Towering Haystack Burger with Fruit
San Francisco Cheeseburger
Cinnamon French Toast
Vegetarian Omelette
Biscuits and Gravy
Chicken Fried Steak
Chicken Fried
Eggs Benedict
Garlic Fries
Milk Shakes

“Came in here for a late night snack yesterday. I tried the fisherman sandwich. Big cuts of fried juicy fish topped with homemade coleslaw with a side of potatoe salad (the best potato salad around) and my boyfriend got the hot corned beef sandwich with extra pickles and garlic French fries. Everything was amazing. Huge portions but very tasty. Service was friendly and timely. The kitchen had our food out within 10 minutes too.“

4.4 Superb95 Reviews
Eureka Village Pantry American • $
1912 Broadway St, Eureka

Customers` Favorites

Ham Home Cut Potatoes and Eggs over Medium
Pancake or French Toast Supreme
Cinnamon Roll French Toast
California Eggs Benedict
Country Breakfast Plate
Classic Pantry Burger
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Apple Cinnamon Roll
Biscuits and Gravy
Chicken Cobb Salad

“Fantastic restaurant with great service and friendly people. It was busy when I arrived, but despite that, my food came out quickly. I ordered the taco salad, which was both generously portioned and delicious. It came in a crispy shell and had generous amounts of ground beef and other toppings. The restaurant itself was very clean despite how busy it was, there were staff members constantly cleaning and bussing tables to keep the place running. Lots of parking as well, and easy to access the lot.“

4.4 Superb89 Reviews
Tavern 1888 Cocktail Bar • $$$
139 2nd St Suite 2, Eureka

Customers` Favorites

Brioche Bread Pudding
French Press Coffee
Misoyaki Black Cod
Ginger Rogers
Poke Tower
True Grits
Crab Cakes
Duck a L
Ravioli

“Great restaurant and lovely bar too. The food can be on the heavy side but it’s a place to go when you want to live it up.That said they do have some great small plates and you can’t miss the bread and herbed oil sauce - it’s another level of delicious. And yes it’s just bread and herbs and olive oil but hot dang it is done superbly. Don’t snooze on this.Love coming here - highly recommend.“

4.4 Superb86 Reviews
Restaurant 301 Bar • $$
301 L St, Eureka

Customers` Favorites

Opera Cake

“Lovely Inn, staff and service is excellent. Love the lobby sitting area with fireplace and restaurant 301. Very welcoming. Nice rooms, bathrooms a little on the small side but functional. Walk in shower would be better. We will be staying again in a few weeks on our return trip back.“

4.5 Superb37 Reviews
Humboldt Bay Bistro American • $$
1436 2nd St, Eureka

Customers` Favorites

Tahitian Vanilla Bean Creme Brulee
Humboldt Bay Kumamoto Oysters
Lobster and Filet Mignon
North Coast Clam Chowder
Grilled Asparagus
Chicken Marsala
Cheese Plate
Calamari

“While most restaurants in Humboldt lack finesse and the casual assumption of 'foodie'ness of the Bay Area, this one has a deft kitchen, comfortable and friendly atmosphere, and generous in good ways. Plus a sunset view on those rare clear evenings from the wine bar. And it's NOT in the Bay Area--an excellent choice for homies and visitors. Vegan/vegetarian specials too.“

4.2 Good76 Reviews
Kristina's Restaurant Family • $
250 W 5th St, Eureka

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Fried Steak and Eggs
Breakfast Burrito
Country Skillet
Denver Omelette
Garlic Bread
Fiesta Salad
Hash Browns
French Dip
California
Classic

“I’m very confused why there aren’t more people eating here. I’ve only had the dinner, but it’s all good! Certain dishes are stronger than others, but there isn’t anything really bad. The atmosphere was quiet as there were only two other tables, but nothing bad.“

4.1 Good117 Reviews
Sequoia Park Zoo Cafe American • $$
3414 W St, Eureka

“Nothing fancy but very good food and a nice place to eat it. There's often a bit of a wait to get your order but it's hot and tasty when you get it and you can check out some of the exhibits while you wait. Don't forget, zoo memberships get you a discount on food! Also, it's right near the entrance so it's easy to go to the zoo just for a meal.Vegetarian options: They make a good garden burger and you can get salad instead of French fries.Kid-friendliness: Standard kids menu but with particularly good chicken strips.“

4.4 Superb22 Reviews
Cafe Nooner Mediterranean • $
2910 E St, Eureka

Customers` Favorites

Chopped Ham and Scrambled Eggs
Raspberry Cheesecake
Chicken Kebab Plate
Bacon Cheeseburger
Country Breakfast
Biscuits & Gravy
Eggs Benedict
French Fries
Flatbread
Lamb Wrap

“Fave coffee and brunch joint. My pardner and I visit here for fantastic espresso, lattes, macaroons and sometimes breakfasts when family visits.The staff are absolutely lovely.Vegetarian options: There are several, clearly marked vegetarian options including a tempeh poh-boy.Dietary restrictions: There are gluten and dairy free options. Staff is knowledgeable about dietary restrictions.“

4.1 Good50 Reviews
Surfside Burger Shack Hamburger • $
445 5th St, Eureka

Customers` Favorites

The Mushroom Swiss Burger
Burger and Fries
Fried Mushrooms
Ripcurl Fries
Garlic Fries
Onion Rings
Cheeseburger
Deep Fried
Hamburger
Sandwich

“What a DELICIOUS meal. ONIONRINGS golden brown,crisp bracelet sized !WOW !!The burgers done perfectly lettuce tomato pickle fresh crisp so good. FATHER & SON TEAM WINNING THANK YOU SI VERY MUCHKid-friendliness: Welcoming and lots of room“

4.1 Good47 Reviews
A A Bar & Grill Bar & Grill • $$
929 4th St, Eureka

Customers` Favorites

Rib Eye Steak with Gorgonzola Butter Sauce
Rib Eye Steak & Onion Rings
Mac N Cheese Bites
Steak and Fries
French Fries
Hot Wings
Chips
Fish

“For what it is, definitely the best steak joint in its class. I had, two steaks there on two separate occasions. Absolutely fantastic, and I worked at Ruth's Chris... If you are looking for good steak, without the markup of a fancy atmosphere. This is it.... Also do yourself a solid, try to gorgonzola butter...Five stars in all categories take into consideration the type of place this is... This is not an upscale spot, this is a dive, with better steaks than most upscale joints I've been to.“

4 Good90 Reviews
Siren's Song Tavern Bar • $
325 2nd St, Eureka

Customers` Favorites

Stone Neverending Haze
Lime & Ginger Clarity
Chicken Skewers
Assorted Ramen

“Love it!! Great music, friendly, chill vibe l. I really got taken in to the music. Welcoming to all ages. I think it's important to expose my kids to live music and this was a safe place to enjoy myself while my youngsters get to see what it's all about with live bands“

4.1 Good21 Reviews
Pacific Bar & Grill @ Red Lion Hotel Bar & Grill • $$
1929 4th St, Eureka

“The lady at the front desk was very informative of the area and had it if good pointers on food as well. She said she was from Michigan and I can believe it with her charming personality. The rooms were clean and the showers were sparking . We will stay there again if we are in town.“

4.1 Good16 Reviews
Jack's Seafood Seafood • $$
4 C St, Eureka

Customers` Favorites

Oysters on the Half Shell
Halibut and Chips
Fried Clam Strips
Grilled Steelhead
Pan-Fried Oysters
Seared Ahi Salad
Seafood Alfredo
Fried Mushrooms
Coconut Shrimp
Fried Calamari

“Calamari was great perfectly cooked with a great fresh flavor. The coconut shrimp was perfectly deep fried with deep fried coconut flakes on it along with an amazing sweet chili sauce. The oysters had a subtle smokey flavor with a rich and tangy aioli sauce.“

3.9 Good124 Reviews
Lost Coast Brewery & Cafe Cafe • $$
617 4th St, Eureka

Customers` Favorites

LCB World Famous Buffalo Wings
Crispy Cod Sandwich
Famous Hot Brown
Chowder & Salad
Draft Root Beer
Cowboy Burger
Fish and Chips
Beer Tasting
Shrimp Tacos
Caesar Salad

“We always have the best service whenever we eat here! I just recently discovered I have a gluten intolerance, and it has made going out to eat more difficult. Lost Coast has gluten free buns from Arise Bakery, and they were really decent as far as GF bread goes. I was so psyched to be able to eat a burger again!! And the cherry cider is so good. We ate at the bar and the bartender Marcus was phenomenal.“

3.9 Good93 Reviews
Tea Garden Cafe Chinese • $
1338 Myrtle Avenue, Eureka

Customers` Favorites

Pork Fried Rice and Pork Chow Mein
Lunch Chicken Chow Mein
Teriyaki Chicken
Mongolian Beef
Broccoli Beef
Ton Soup
Rolls

“First try I loved the egg foo yung It was just what I was looking for. The only reason 4 stars is the appetizer platter is not so good especially for the price, I did like the egg rolls though . But regular meals at great prices the first time there will be back ! Very nice people and definitely a old school cute chinese restaurant.“

3.8 Good30 Reviews
Humboldt Smokehouse Barbecue • $
310 5th St, Eureka

Customers` Favorites

BBQ Beans with Pork
Cadillac Burrito
Sliced Brisket
Cornbread
Sandwich
The BBQ

“Friendly & helpful employees. Delicious chopped brisket sandwich (we added crispy onions) & baked beans. Several flavorful BBQ sauces to choose from with great descriptions to help you decide - ultimately ended up purchasing a bottle of their "Georgia" sauce to bring back home with us.“

3.7 Good52 Reviews
Fresh Freeze Drive-In American • $
3023 F St, Eureka

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Burger with Cheese
Chicken Strip Combo
Sundae with Caramel
Chili Cheese Fries
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Tenders
Root Beer Float
Chili Kraut Dog
Ice Cream Cone
Deluxe Burger

“I had the garden burger, garlic cheese fries, and an Oreo milkshake. Everything was delicious and service was provided with a smile. The atmosphere is nostalgic with 1950’s era decor. I live just up the street and frequently visit here. I’m never disappointed…Vegetarian options: Garden burger“

3.5 Good91 Reviews
Loading...
map Map