6 Best Pizza Restaurants near Hollister

Straw Hat Pizza Pizza • $$
191 San Felipe Rd Suite A, Hollister

Customers` Favorites

The Works Pizza
To Go Salad

“It was nice I think the only thing good was the salad the pizza ? was like dough still it was quite. No one was in there ? enjoyed it had a nice family meal ☺️ beside the dough pizza why my mom did t take it back don't know think after a long day of moving we're just hungry.“

4.3 Superb143 Reviews
Valley Pizzeria Pizza • $$
551 McCray St, Hollister

Customers` Favorites

Korean BBQ Chicken Pizza
Personal Pizza With
Combination Pizza

“Went to Valley Pizzeria for the first time after wheeling at a nearby offroad park. My intent was to find the most "hole in the wall" pizza place I could because I'm not a fan of franchise pizza. This place definitely checks that box.-As we entered the restaurant, we got a throwback kind of vibe (it's a good thing).-The menu has a good selection of pizza styles and other items, yet it's not complex.-We ordered a large Carnivore Pizza along with some of their bone in wings (honey Sriracha if I remember correctly).-we were seated and promptly received our order of wings. The wings were phenomenal. They weren't undercooked like at other places. Even though the wings had sauce, you could still feel the crisp on the skin as you bit into them. Safe to say they were well done but not overcooked. (Perfect)-The pizza was brought to the table almost immediately after we received the wings. Just by looking at it, we knew the pizza was gonna be just as good as it looked. The crust had a golden texture along with a few burn bubbles, the meats had a crispy rim surrounding the edges. The cheese consistency looked like it was just enough cheese (not too much, not too little), and when we picked up a slice, the pizza didn't flop! It had a nice rigid structure. The undercarriage was crusty and crunchy while maintaining the same texture throughout the crust. When you bit into it, the toppings didn't slide off all over the place, and there was a nice and subtle crunch! The pie itself was a bit larger than your typical large pie at a franchise place. One thing I recommend if you're taking the pizza home is to reheat it in an air fryer at 375 degrees for 5 minutes. It'll come out just a bit crunchier but will still taste as if it was fresh. If you heat it in a microwave, you'll have soggy crust and a chewy pizza.Overall, this hole in the wall pizza place was a hit! We will definitely be going back after every wheeling trip. This review may seem long, but if you love pizza the way I do, you'll understand that a pie has to have certain characteristics to qualify as a true, made with a purpose pizza.“

4.2 Good72 Reviews
Mountain Mike's Pizza Pizza • $$
261 McCray St suite a, Hollister

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Sticks with Cheese
Pepperoni Pizza
Salad Bar

“I absolutely love mountain mikes. I moved to Florida and we don’t have a mikes here. I miss it dearly. I think about it often. Sometimes my fiancé gets jealous because when I sleep I moan for the cheesy gooey mountain mikes mozzarella. She often resorts to violence… but anyway. Do yourself a favor and bring ya self down to mountain mikes pizza today.Parking: Great parking“

4.1 Good33 Reviews
Grillin & Chillin Alehouse Brewery • $$
401 McCray St b24, Hollister

Customers` Favorites

Tri Tip Salad
Meatball Sub
Rib Eye 16oz
Beef Nachos
Chili

“After hiking at Pinnacles Natl Park, checked out this establishment. They have a great selection of beers and have ample seating. I ordered nachos and buffalo wings. They were delicious. The young gentleman that attended us was attentive and very helpful with the beer menu. They unfortunately don’t have Beer Flights, so you’re limited on how many beers you can check out. Other than that, it’s a great place.“

3.7 Good67 Reviews
Domino's Pizza Pizza Delivery • $
601 McCray St Suite 102 Ste 102, Hollister

“Yeah pretty much pre judged this pizza for an unknown reason. But thought, what the heck. Why not. Just a pepperoni and mushroom with garlic crust, and Boy, what a great flavor. This has been an eye opener. Try it on thin crust if you dare...“

3.6 Good36 Reviews
Papa Murphy's Pizza • $
1740 Airline Hwy Ste. #405, Hollister

Customers` Favorites

Create Your Own Half

“This was my first time going to a Papa Murphy's.I placed my order online and picked it up. I couldn't find the place and even drove in front of it the location. I had to call and ask them where they are located as their sign outside wasn't lit.When I got there, I had to wait to pick it up as there was one person in front of me so I had to wait a few minutes.I got home, put the pizza in the oven based on the directions and waited for it to be ready. The wait was worth it as the pizza was really good.I will definitely come back again.“

3.5 Good87 Reviews
Loading...

Hollister’s related cuisines

map Map