Polly's Pies Restaurant & Bakery
CLOSED$$ •
Recent Reviews
Their pies are *chef's kiss* I haven't eaten here but annually, I order about 5-10 pies for birthdays, holidays, and just because. I would highly recommend the Banberry and French Silk. I'm a creature of habit so I typically go with crowd favorites but I'm sure the other pies are great too.
The good ol' Polly's Pies. It's my first time at a diner since pre-COVID. I'm surprised they're still around. This location is big, but it's dirty. The floors, tables, and seats could be cleaner. There's plenty of parking in the parking lot. The food was ok overall. I had an item from the fall special menu: turkey pie dinner. It came with really salty mashed potatoes, which has potato skin. The mashed potatoes had a nice presentation though! They dug a well and poured gravy in...read full review
I'm so heartbroken about this location's permanent closure. Boyfriend and I loved coming here for the weekday breakfast specials. The food and coffee was always great and so were the servers. I'm going to truly miss this place!