Bongiorno's New York Pizzeria

32459 Temecula Pkwy Ste 105, Temecula
(951) 302-7400

Recent Reviews

Luisa P.

All I wanted was NY pizza. I stopped after seeing the rating. Should've first read the reviews! I walked in. Wasn't busy. I walked up to the front counter and advised the girl it was my first time. I asked her how many slices were in either size and she cut me off and was short. Sort of snobby. What ever.I paid and didn't tip. I mean I was there to order and picking up my own pizza. I walked to find a seat and I could feel her stare. Didn't take long for me to get my pizza. Just got a plan 14 inch pep pizza. Didn't want to keep asking questions. Came home and already could see the grease seeping through the box. Pretty gross. As other reviews mention.. the pizza was def soggy. $20+ for grease. Maybe I should've tipped and the result would've been different? I'll never know. Def marking this place off the list.

Pre S

Caring Staff. Today I had the luck of being treated by the people who work here. They were so positive and authentically put love into my pizza. . The pizza sauce reminded me of the pizzas in Italy.

Tony S.

Ordered for delivery a large house special pizza that was good but the crust was over cooked. Totally unhappy with the Stromboli that was so overcooked that the bottom was black. If I had personally picked it up I would have made them replace it.

Mark D.

I've been ordering here for years. My first love was the stromboli. Its really good. Not a common item at most pizza places. The pizza....now let's talk. It's all about the crust what can I say. Yeah I like to eat all the crust..lol and it's good. Variety is good. And I like to drop by for a slice and get my pizza fix while running errands. The staff is always so nice and easy going. Located behind El Pollo Loco with lots of parking! Bon appetit!

Flores CC

We wanted to give a HUGE shoutout!!! We ordered 10 pizzas today for my son’s birthday and EVERYONE LOVED the pizza!!! Hands down best pizza ever!!!

B Trinh

Great pizza, a little pricey, but you're getting authentic New York style pizza by a local business. Wonderful service, a great treat :)

Dawn S.

The food is always good! My favorite is the Italian sausages with marinara and mozzarella cheese. Of course, every pizza we've ever ordered was delicious as well.

Debra S.

First I want to say I really like Bongiornos pizza, they do a great job! But there is one thing I wish they understood. Their menu says they have garlic knots, and they do not...they have breadsticks. Anybody from the east coast understands there is a difference. Its funny when the staff says to me "you can call them what you want." They get a little upset. I guess it's become kind of a game when I order their "breadsticks". They dont like that! Haha. So I am posting a picture of a "garlic knot" in hope's of the owner and staff learning that there is a difference. If you claim to be a " New York pizzeria "...you all should know the difference, and know that when I order your "breadsticks" that is what I am getting...breadsticks. But although mislabeled ..they are decent. Lol. Signed...East coaster.

JT R.

SCAMMERS!!! Anyone ever hear of "Truth in Advertising?" 17500. Business and Professions Code It is unlawful for any person, firm, corporation or association, or any employee thereof with intent directly or indirectly to dispose of real or personal property or to perform services, professional or otherwise, or anything of any nature whatsoever or to induce the public to enter into any obligation relating thereto, to make or disseminate or cause to be made or disseminated before the public in this state, or to make or disseminate or cause to be made or disseminated from this state before the public in any state, in any newspaper or other publication, or any advertising device, or by public outcry or proclamation, or in any other manner or means whatever, including over the Internet, any statement, concerning that real or personal property or those services, professional or otherwise, or concerning any circumstance or matter of fact connected with the proposed performance or disposition thereof, which is untrue or misleading, and which is known, or which by the exercise of reasonable care should be known, to be untrue or misleading, or for any person, firm, or corporation to so make or disseminate or cause to be so made or disseminated any such statement as part of a plan or scheme with the intent not to sell that personal property or those services, professional or otherwise, so advertised at the price stated therein, or as so advertised. Any violation of the provisions of this section is a misdemeanor punishable by imprisonment in the county jail not exceeding six months, or by a fine not exceeding two thousand five hundred dollars ($2,500), or by both that imprisonment and fine. Beware of dishonest business practices and terrible customer service. I ordered two large pizzas to be picked up. When I arrived and presented a coupon I was told, "It is too old." I pointed out that there were no expiration dates on their coupons. They tried to tell me that the mailer has the expiration date. I offered to present the mailer as I had it in the car. The female owner then said, "Just take it!" She then turned her back and was muttering under her breathe about my 5 year old coupons. When I pointed out that I could hear her and suggested better business practices a very arrogant boy stepped forward and took the pizzas back from the clerk and said, We don't have to sell to you." I told him that was fine and explained I was going to post on Yelp and destroy them in reference to my visit, experience and their behavior. The male owner she was making pizzas then said I wouldn't destroy them. The boy continued to talk as I walked out and then challenged me to meet him out back of their business. There are many pizzerias in Temecula. You decide if this is the kind of place you want to do business with. Not me. I will never be back.

Katesha W.

I ordered a pepperoni pizza with extra sauce and well done to have crispy pepperoni. There was no extra sauce and pepperoni was cooked but not crispy. I was really disappointed when I took a bite into a slice and there was a long blond hair. Yuck. I spit it out and threw the rest of the pizza away. Not gonna order from here ever again.

Franklin H.

First let me say..This place is the ONLY place you will Ever get REAL New York Style Pizza, living in Temecula!!! The Pizza is Amazing!!! You will NOT find a better spot. I have been coming here for years now, and I will Never go anywhere else. From walking in and being greeted, to getting that delicious pizza in your pie hole. But, even since covid, they have stepped it up. Now, when I order over the phone to actual delivery, they are Perfect!! I also want to give a shout out to Jaidyin (hope I spelled it right) who is always on point, with her being so nice and professional over the phone, and making sure my order is just right!!! She is a true Gem! Also, let me say that I pass about 3 pizza places, just to get there!+ That says Alot. I would give them 10 stars, if I could. HIGHLY RECOMMEND!

Armando S.

Last drop of the day here at my new job. And my friend who visits often wouldnt not stop bragging about this place. "Trust me, save your appetite." I looked at him, "it better be good, im starving." It is. He ordered half meat lovers with 1/4 buffalo chicken 1/4 bbq chicken. The pizza looked delicious and it was. 18 inches of top quality ingredients in a pie. Definitely coming back. Thank you to Nick and his crew, for making one of the best pizzas I've had in a while.

S E

We came down and got the meatlovers pizza. The quality of ingredients shine through, good cheese and good meats but not overly meaty or cheesy so as to take over the flavor. It is a small place but all of the staff were helpful and the owner was good to talk to and it was a great visit!

Jacob C.

Pizza is very good. Owner and the younger manager are pretty aggressive and rude if you ask any of their employees to wear a mask which is very reasonable when handling food. 1.5 on service and 4.5 on pizza.

S R.

Came out on a weekend for lunch and loved it! Great pizza, great salads, and such a friendly staff. We had the meat lovers and it was great, not overly meaty or cheesy, just right and they use fantastic ingredients! Highly recommend coming here for a great meal.

Load More