The Batter Up Bakery

26490 Ynez Rd Suite K, Temecula
(951) 677-4555

Recent Reviews

Camden Gunter

Found them on Instagram and decided to give them a try. They were amazing and their service was

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Roberto Chavez

The sweet potato pie is absolutely delicious!!!! ? recommend!!!

Food: 5

Marcos Villalobos

Awesome place 10/10 coming back for

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Red Velvet

Ochi C

Amazing service! Just as Amazing as their freshly made Cakes, Pies, cupcakes, macaroons, pastries.. etc etc etc.Relaxed atmosphere. Comfortable couches to sit and enjoy GREAT COFFEE!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

VFW AB

If you're in a pinch and need a cake, Lisa and the Batter Up Bakery are batting for you. She shows up.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Christy Waller

Wedding cake so can't be a redo. Awful. Too expensive, $350 + delivery fee and mostly frosting that was too sweet. Strawberries were beginning to spoil in the cake. People took a bite didn't finish

Food: 1

Traditional Catholic

This Bakery has the most DELICIOUS pies!! We were able to have the Cherry which was divine <3 and the Pumpkin which was creamy and scruptious with a firm and tasty crust!!! If you haven’t been your missing out!!! Batter up!! We’re coming back!!! What a home run!! The Escobar Family

Oscar Amezcua

Amazing cherry pie !?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

PS Couple

Desserts are delicious!!!

Food: 5

Noah Wurr

Ever since they changed bakers everything is over cooked and very plain. Drinks are still amazing but something needs to change in the kitchen

Alicia Poore

Not recommend at all, they have a banner, saying their vet friendly, but that’s just to get paying customers in the door. Unfriendly service and low quality, bakery items, and drinks!

Joey L.

Ordered two birthday cakes from them, they were the worst cakes i have ever eaten in my life! Terrible!!! Wont ever order from them again!

Pepper Ann

This marks perhaps my third or fourth visit to this bakery, each time filled with anticipation, only to leave with my expectations unmet. I’ve decided to cease expecting high-quality baked goods from this place. It’s true that the cakes and desserts are visually appealing, but they fall short in taste. For instance, I tried a rainbow cake that turned out to be unpleasantly spongy, possibly the worst I’ve ever tasted, to the point where I couldn’t even finish my slice. I will say, however, that the customer service is consistently good. My hope is that they will improve by using better recipes, ingredients and refrain from using American buttercream on everything, which I find unappetizing.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

Monique Jefferson

I placed an order with Jill for a cake based on a photograph from the website. I was nervous planning a party from out of state but was assured they would bring my vision to life. I stopped in prior to the event to check in with Jill but she was unavailable. I left a message and she never got back to me. Event day 2/10/24 I pop in to pick up my cake and was very disappointed. When I spoke with Angela she acknowledged my concern and tried her best to fix it. Unfortunately, it didn't get better. Hey it happens. I contacted Angela after the party and we discussed the situation. Since she was in agreement with me she issued a full refund for the cake. A few things I'd like to note: customer service - amazing, location and bakery atmosphere - super cute and quaint, bakery menu and selections - look amazing. I didn't taste the cake so I cannot comment. The flow of customers tells me that they do a consistently good job. My experience does not take away from their established representation. The customer service alone is 5 stars. Thank you Angela!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Tom Smith

Used to be great! Very disappointing, the bakery used to be great, then it got a new baker and was not so great and then they came back around and fixed that. Shower now it’s awful and expensive. I had not been going because they had stopped making some favorites. Then whenWe did go the few times it was not good. Went today to give one more try since in the past they had been inconsistent, but today was the worst ever. The muffin we got tasted stale, the cup cake same and the scone, not sure why they change the recipe. Supposed to be cranberry orange but no orange. Muffin was not only stale but it was blueberry apricot and had zero apricot. Scones are $6 here so it should be top notch as should a $5 muffin. Sad.

Load More