facebook instagram facebook instagram

Petonito's Pastry and Cupcake Shoppe

$$ • Bakery, Cupcakes

Hours:
190 Main St, East Haven
(203) 469-1817

Take-Out/Delivery Options

Recent Reviews

3.9 (107)

I ordered a selection of 20 pastries for a corporate party, and everyone absolutely loved them, rave reviews and we have a lot of pastries from different places in my company, nobody usually comments on the desserts, but everyone loved these so much. One employee said the chocolate cannoli was the best he'd ever had in his life. We will be back!

Petonito's Pastry Shoppe is an Italian Pastry Bakery that opened in New Haven, Connecticut in 1954. It was founded by Salvatore Petonito. The son of Italian immigrants, Salvatore received his initial training as a baker at the young age of 11 when he started working at Lucibello's Pastry Shop in the mid 1930s. He was drafted into the navy in World War II and worked as a baker on several ships during his tour of duty. After returning home, Salvatore would later open up his own...read full review
So sad that this bakery has really gone down hill! I really hesitated to write this review but feel others who love the traditional Italian pastry and pies should be informed. Been getting pastries here for over 30 years, and had my wedding cake made here 30 years ago. We travel to Ct for Christmas every year ( we now live out of state) and bring pastry for Christmas Eve and Christmas Day . Last year the pastries were inedible, but I thought maybe because of Covid it was a fluke....read full review

More Reviews(105)

Ratings

View all photos

Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday 8:30AM - 2PM
Wednesday 8:30AM - 5PM
Thursday 8:30AM - 5PM
Friday 8:30AM - 5PM
Saturday 8:30AM - 5PM
Sunday 8:30AM - 1PM
Updated on: