Wentworth Homemade Ice Cream

3697 Whitney Ave, Hamden
(203) 281-7429

Recent Reviews

Sean Hallinan

Ice cream is fine, but they have the most passive aggressive, annoying tip system I've ever seen in my life.

Liphahlee Marshall

Good ice cream. Customer service lacks.

Wei

Wentworth ice cream has been my favorite for the past 25 years. It’s the best!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dan Oldakowski

Their ice cream is delicious, definitely worth a trip out. They also have delicious ice cream cakes. Be sure to provide a little lead time for a cake purchase, and they will have it ready to go for you. I like to order mine about a week ahead of time.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: And Whipped Cream, Coffee Oreo, Scoop of Chocolate, Ice Cream Cone, Cookies and Cream Ice Cream, Hot Fudge

Deirdre B.

Stopped here at the end of November! Amazed at their hours when most ice cream places are closed already. Service was great, it was so quiet and the ice cream was delicious.

Fernando Torres

Pretty damn good ?, especially their seasonal Pumpkin & Apple Crumb

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Katie R.

Two words... banana splitThank God I didn't know about this place during my pregnancy

Jeffrey Hunt

Rude. They use common scoops for all of the ice-cream flavors, which means all the tubs of ice-cream could have nuts in them. That's unfortunate BUT not uncommon -- no big deal. But why be rude about it? Also, why advertise things like having gluten-free ice-cream when the same scoops are being used in all tubs (same issue).We got an ice-cream for our son, but then I had to go back and get an extra spoon. The same rude person ignored me (but another young lady did step up and apologize). This was 10/13 at about 6:00 pm.

Leah Hunt

I rarely leave reviews but we visited Wentworth's for the first time yesterday as a family with our young son. The person who helped us who was working behind the counter was annoyed that we asked about an allergy (peanut allergy, who I was with is very allergic) and was grumpy and rude around our young son, which is inappropriate. They said that the ice cream scoops are not cleaned in between different flavors and they did not offer an option for a flavor that had not been cross-contaminated with a flavor that had peanuts/peanut butter. This was our first time visiting Wentworth's and I was really excited to try it, but the experience was unfortunately very negative (most places have peanut flavors but are more friendly/polite, accomodating, or at least clean their scoops between flavors). I would not recommend them, as there are other better options in the area.

Jose Centeno

The ice cream is home-made, but they need more variety. I suggested they make corn ice cream with cinnamon.

Mark

Really good ice cream and friendly staff

Gene Sengstock

Super creamy ice cream, but a bit pricey.

Melissa A.

I would of given them a 5 star but if it wasn't for the flies around place looks very clean reminds me of nostalgic times. The ice cream is very very good . You can taste it's home made, I like the buttercream pecan one! So good. Service was very nice the team felt welcoming. I would deff go back.

Brianna C.

Tons of different flavors! The chocolate chip cookie dough had nice large chunks that were absolutely delicious! I loved the comfy chairs placed outside and there was plenty of seating inside as well. The service was quick and the team was kind!

Erik Devereux

I went here at the recommendation of my youngest who is in school nearby. I had the fabulous chocolate salted caramel oreo (with hot fudge). My youngest had the equally fabulous raspberry chocolate frozen yogurt. All the flavors look amazing and they have recommended sundaes that I'd go for with assistance. Portions are generous here so be aware when ordering. I definitely will go again.

Load More

Wentworth Homemade Ice Cream

3697 Whitney Ave, Hamden, CT 06518
(203) 281-7429