17 Best Italian Restaurants in Middletown

Avella's Italian take out Italian • $
232 William St, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Old School Sicillian Pizza Pie
Broccoli Rabe & Sausage
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Brocc Rabe & Sausage
Chocalate Chip Cookie
Chicken Italiano
Antipasto Salad
Chicken Cutlet
Dr Melfi Salad
Potato Wedges

“Sal worked with us for my grandsons baptism party. The roast beef was tender and flavorful. Lemon chicken was amazing. Roasted vegetables with hot peppers, WOW! Roasted potatoes, fantastic! Portions are more than expected. Sal is wonderful to work with and you will not be disappointed with the food“

4.8 Superb91 Reviews
BellaNotte Restaurant Italian •
2100 S Main St, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Veal Parmigiana
Garlic Rolls

“The prices for the food are great and the garlic knots are to die for. The dining room is very noisy but I can get past it, they're busy and popular so to be expected. I can't stop thinking about the garlic knots. I got the burrata salad with chicken and it was all incredible. The food also came out super quick given how packed it was there on a Saturday night.“

4.7 Superb62 Reviews
Stella D’oro Italian • $$
109 College St, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Scallop & Shrimp Fra Diavolo
Salmon Stella D'Oro
Salmon Caesar Salad
Gnocchi All Nonna
Veal Oscar
Lasagna

“I can believe we didn’t try this amazing restaurant until tonight. I can’t say enough about the excellent service and attention paid to our party. Top notch recommendations made for the best tasting meal I have had in a long time. We will enjoy this fantastic place many times in the future as our staple for high quality and superb food. Thank you for the exceptional evening and we look forward to joining you again in the very near future!“

4.5 Superb70 Reviews
Fiore II Restaurant Italian • $$
332 Main St, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Caesar Salad with Chicken
Chicken Parmigiana
Chicken Parmesan
Fried Mozzarella
Lobster Ravioli
Sole Francaise
Fried Calamari
Eggplant Parm
Chicken Fiore
Pasta Dishes

“My husband and I went to Fiore II on the way home from a trip. It was a great find. Awesome service by Jimmy and another young man. Lovely atmosphere, but most importantly the food was amazing. So many choices. We will be back and are considering catering for holiday parties this year. Thank you.“

4.4 Superb102 Reviews

5
Mondo

Mondo Pizza • $
10 Main St, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Prosciutto & Arugula Pizza
Truffle Honey Pizza
Half Portion Salad
Med Veggie Pizza
Eggplant Fries
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Pesto
Mondo Special
Caesar Salad
French Fries

“I usually love their pizza but I would recommend going there in person for it or double checking it lately. Ordering online doesn't work since its hard to customize pizzas and ots a 10 minute longer wait minimum. We got 2 pizzas for pick up ordered over the phone. 1st the girl was handling more than one phone at a time so not really knowing if we had her full attention. 2nd we ordered the oozy egg no proscute with an extra egg instead. there was no proscute but also no extra egg and the eggs were on only half the pizza. my hubby asked for a side of red pepper flakes they gave him .5oz, kind of stingy. the 2 pizzas came to $38+ and at that price they could at least pay attention and get the order right. Even if they might have been busy, at least do a quality check or read the order back to the customer so it is right.“

4.3 Superb137 Reviews
Cantina Cafe Ristorante Italian • $$
74 Court St, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Italian Antipasto Cantina
Shrimp Fra Diavolo
Chicken Siciliana
Stuffed Mushrooms
Antipasto Plate
Chicken Parm
House Rolls
Cannoli

“First valentines with my finance and boy I have to tell you this man knows his way to my heart. We had a wonderful experience at this restaurant. What an amazing place. The food was excellent, fresh and full of taste. This will be my restaurant to visit when craving a great pasta meal.“

4.4 Superb60 Reviews
Illiano's Ristorante and Pizzeria Pizza • $
534 Washington St, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Make Your Own Pasta with Fresh Mozzarella and Meatballs
Make Your Own Pasta with Pesto and Sausage
Chicken Parm Sandwich
Sausage Parm Pizza
Buffalo Chicken
Eggplant Parm
Brócoli Pizza
Grandma Slice
Garlic Rolls
Garlic Bread

“Highly recommend! Came in to grab some slices and they were so yummy. Jay was incredibly kind to us and helpful to accommodate some special food needs we had. The buffalo chicken slice had chunks of blue cheese and was so flavorful. All 3 slices we got were delicious. Dying to try their Big Mac slices. The closest I’ve seen to nyc in terms of pizza by the slice. Slices were big and so yummy. Thanks so much!!! We will definitely be back!“

4.3 Superb57 Reviews
Red Fox Restaurant Steak House • $$
218 Smith St, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Red Fox Combo Stuffed Mushrooms Clams and Mussels
Grilled Zucchini Rollatini
Red Fox Veal Scallopini
Molten Lava Cake
Shrimp & Scallops
Chicken Piccata
Mashed Potatoes
Shellfish Combo
Fried Calamari
Caprese Salad

“Service was amazing, beyond polite, the presentation of the food was one of the nicest I’ve ever seen in my life. The 24k tomahawk steak was to die for, all 3 sides tasted amazing, they also went off menu to accommodate me for a side. 10/10 everything.“

4.2 Good160 Reviews
Jon's Restaurant Italian •
825 Saybrook Rd, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Veal Parmigiana Grinder
Chicken Caesar
Italian Combo
Greek Chicken
Small Cheese
Greek Salad
Pizza
Rolls

“Greeted so pleasantly the second we walked in. Seated right away. Delicious garlic knots! Amazing service from start to finish. We got a salad and a wrap, and it was just what we were craving! Finished up with some tea/coffee and cheesecake. Overall really wonderful experience, will definitely be returning!“

4.3 Superb51 Reviews
Esca Restaurant & Wine Bar Wine Bar • $$$
437 Main St, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Shrimp Pappardelle
Rigatoni Bolognese
Grilled Octopus
Calamari Fritti
Arancini Balls
Burrata Salad
Esca Burger
Caesar Salad
Tuna Tartare
Tiramisu

“Esca is a bustling spot in Middletown. I started the meal with a burrata salad and arancini. Both of these were delicious. For my main course I got the duck breast. The skin had a beautiful salt crust and perfectly whipped mashed potatoes. I would highly recommend this to anyone that is looking for some delicious Italian food. Quite delicious.“

4.1 Good61 Reviews
Amici Italian Grill Italian • $$
Riverview Center, 280 Main St, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Tuscany Garlic Bread
Stuffed Mushrooms
Chicken Milanese
Chicken Parmesan
Chicken Marsala
Caesar Salad
Lasagna
Soup

“Overall, Amici provides a wonderful experience on all categories. The atmosphere inside is wonderful and there is a great ambiance. When you sit they give you some bread, nothing special but a nice touch. The servings on the entrees were big and each entree comes with a side salad. We tried 3 entrees all were good but nothing incredible. I would definitely recommend this place. I think it provides one of best experiences and food out of the Italian restaurants on main street. Would be great for date night.“

4 Good46 Reviews
Newfield Pizza Pizza • $
558 Newfield St #4, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Large Bacon and Small Pepperoni Pizzas
Cold Cut Combo Grinder
Chicken Caesar Salad
Garlic Rolls
Greek Salad
Meatballs

“Great food! Great service. Place was empty. I went here with family after a burial. It was spacious and accommodating, perfect for the intimate moment. I ordered potatoes skins.. (sorry no pic I ate em before I could snap one ) penne a la vodka was delicious. Great place to eat!“

3.9 Good17 Reviews
East Main Fish & Chips Fish & Chips • $
276 E Main St, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Fresh Fried Fish and Chips
New England Clam Chowder
Popcorn Shrimp
Fish Sandwich
Curry Chicken
Beef Patties
Jerk Chicken
French Fries
Coco Bread
Jerk Pork

“Holy wow! I finally got around to trying this place and I have no complaints. I ordered ahead online and my order was ready as soon as I walked in. I got a Jamaican beef patty and the pulled pork sandwich which were both soooo good and flavorful. The pulled pork practically melted in my mouth. It was so delicious, and also very filling. I was only able to eat one half at a time and saved the other half for leftovers. The sandwich came with a bunch of thick steak fries, which were also super filling, I couldn’t even finish those either. I probably ate about 1/3 of what they gave me before I was full.I’m not sure what the one star reviews are talking about, I feel like I got more than enough food for the price. I’m definitely recommend and will come again!“

3.9 Good36 Reviews
Z's Rustic Pizza & Espresso Bar Pizza • $
218 Smith St, Middletown

“This is a restaurant you have to try! Food is authentic, delicious and made with passion by Michelle and staff who are most friendly and engaging. Rustic Z is a hidden gem that begs to be discovered! Check them out, you won’t be disappointed! We’re visiting from Florida and I wish we had a place like this down there! We had the eggplant rolatini, meatballs and sauce over penne and garlic knots! The sauce is the real deal! That’s coming from an Italian wannabe Irishman whose Italian wife makes great sauce, so I’ve been well taught!“

3.8 Good26 Reviews
Jerry's Pizza Pizza • $
635 S Main St, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Sweet Potato Fries
Buffalo Chicken
Jerry's Pizza
Small
Bone
Large

“After visiting FunIn I take my kids and their friends here. They love it. If you go on a Saturday night, you can hear the live band in the bar. I enjoy myself while my kids enjoy the food & their friends.Dietary restrictions: Gluten free chicken salad and sweet potato fries are quite good. No reactions.“

3.9 Good75 Reviews
Athenian Diner II Italian • $
864 Washington St, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Pancakes Sausage Bacon
Toast and Home Fries
Corned Beef Hash
French Fries
Chicken Soup
Kielbasa
Sandwich
Diner

“My family and I have been going here for years now since about 2016. Service is always very prompt and friendly. They are conscious of nut allergies and make me feel very comfortable dining there. Breakfast places can be difficult for me with nuts and peanut butter. But I love it here and they make me feel safe to eat! Atmosphere is very retro diner which is how most diners appear. I always get hash browns and pancakes and the quality is very consistent. Whether we come in the morning, middle of the day or the evening I have always had the same experience. I even brought my parents here who love frequenting unique diners across the country and they loved it.“

3.9 Good83 Reviews
Illiano's Ristorante and Pizzeria Italian • $
404 S Main St, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmigiana with Pasta
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Eggplant Parmigiana
Sicilian Pizza
Big Mac Pizza
Stuffed Veggie
Grandma Pizza
Cheese Slice
Square Pizza
Garlic Knot

“The pizza was delicious and the staff was super helpful. We had 20ish people for a 4yr olds birthday party. The restaurant is a bit out dated inside and it was very hot but you could tell people mostly go for takeout and not eating in. Still was a great experience.“

3.9 Good85 Reviews
Loading...
map Map