“If you're looking for a classic diner experience, you can't beat the Athenian Diner! We enjoyed their fries, sandwiches, and a vanilla milkshake. The food was all outstanding, and the service was excellent! We will definitely be going back, to try their breakfast items!“
“Their organic butternut squash is incredible. Amazing menu, excellent with any food allergy you can think of (dairy, nuts, fish, grain, soy, eggs...), where the food is actually delicious no matter what your restriction is. Normally buckwheat pancakes taste a little gritty, but not these! These (vegan! GF!) ones are fluffy and beautiful and taste right like your childhood. Even the free refill coffee is excellent. We tend to spend quite a bit when we come because their cocktail menu is too good.This place is making me consider moving to West Haven just so I can eat there all the time.Vegetarian options: Incredible vegan breakfast and vegan lunch menus!Dietary restrictions: Incredible selection of gluten free baked goods (the sandwich bread is delicious!)“
“Best diner in the area. Years ago they were kind to my kids when their theater company from school are eight there after the shows. They treated them with respect. I can't say that about the other diner in the area. Since then they have my business and that of my family. Great people.“
“A very friendly atmosphere I stopped by 3 days a week to get my breakfast sandwich sausage sausage egg and cheese homemade egg and the cashier Rudy such a nice guy and Mario the cook always gave me a warm friendly greetingKid-friendliness: Kid-friendly very homey atmosphere“
“Amazing staff, and comfy little breakfast spot. They keep the coffee flowing and the home fried potatoes hot. best breakfast potatoe you'll find. all your basic breakfast needs, and then some. if you're looking for a perfect breakfast that's comes quickly, this is your place.“
“The food is amazing.... best turkey Reuben anywhere! Only gave four stars because they refused to give me a mimosa because it wasn't 10 o'clock yet... but I'll keep going because it's so good! Maybe just after 10 next time “
“Staff made eatting there a pleasure. Drinks nd food came fast. The atmosphere was awsome. Very clean bathroom clean with pleasant sent. They serve alcoholic beverages which are yes, yes, yes made right. Food was impeccable. Plenty of parking. Reasonably priced for the amount of food and drinks we got. Definitely going again. I recommend trying anything on menu that appeals to you. You can't go wrong.“
“Always has a great breakfast but I really love the burger. Super affordable either by itself or deluxe with fries and cole slaw. Wish I took a picture of the menu to show the price. Plus it’s only two dollars to add bacon to your burger if you want. basically paid $20 (with tax and tip) for a double bacon cheeseburger deluxe with a Diet Pepsi. The only downside is that you only get 1 refill with the soda.“
“Yummy breakfast but sooo much food. I had a quesadilla with egg, cheese, bacon and hashbrowns. It came with salsa and sour cream. My husband had an omelette with mushroom, onion, cheese and jalapeño. The jalapeños were huge. He said it was good. Clean bathrooms also.“
“OMG! Talk about food that makes you want to come back! 5 stars for many reasons. Excellent service was provided all the way through from start to finish.Food was delivered very quickly and it was hot and delicious! Fries were crispy, sandwich was moist and yummy, don't even get me started on the (Custom) Banana Nutella French Toast! My wife tried the Avacado Omelette and also gave it 5 stars! Even the Cole Slaw was good, and we never eat the Cole Slaw!Coffee was hot and perfectly robust ? I believe it's Omar coffee brand but for some reason it tastes better than other restaurants lol I'm not sure what they're doing better.Prices were fair considering prices are going up everywhere, we still kept it under $50 not including tip.Definitely plan on coming back!“
“First time here. Stopped in for breakfast for 2 on a Saturday morning. We were immediately seated. The service and food were awesome! We had omelets and Belgian waffles. We'll definitely be back!Parking: Lots of parking available around the back.“
“I love the Westville Diner. My wife and I come here pretty often, and we enjoy the idea of exploring the menu, even though we often gravitate towards our favorites.Ioanna, the owner, and all the staff, are so friendly, it's incredible. You end up with the feeling like you know them all personally. And if you come here often enough, you will.Just a great place to come, sit down, relax, take a deep breath, enjoy some good food, and some friendly faces.Tonight I'm having the steak tips, which comes in a brown sauce with onions and mushrooms over rice. It is absolutely delicious. It is enough to make two meals, so now I know what I'm having for lunch tomorrow! By the way, my meal came with a side salad and dessert. Am I ordered the fries because I couldn't help myself :).My wife had the blueberry pancakes, one of her favorites. They're huge, so she automatically cuts them in half as soon as she gets them, and she brings one half home for the next day. So she gets two meals out of hers also.“
“Huge portions of delicious food at lower prices than anywhere around. The most attentive service that I think I've only otherwise experienced in very expensive restaurants.Warm atmosphere, filled with locals.One of the top few diners that I have ever eaten at. Can't wait to go back. I keep trying to justify in my mind the cost of travel from Long Island just to again have such an amazing breakfast!“
“I haven't dined in here for years. I do pick up different dishes every now and then. But sitting in to dine was very nice. The atmosphere, food, and service... great! I really enjoyed everything. I would definitely want to dine in again soon!?“
“A real trip back to the 1950s and it's great from the music to the decor... I feel like Marty Mcfly will be stopping by. The food is really good,big portions and delicious. The staff here was attentive and felt like home. This is a must stop by if you are in the area, you'll be very happy.“
“4:00 in the afternoon for breakfast (don't ask me why), so I Googled places near me that serve breakfast all day. I've driven by this diner quite a few times. I've never been there before. I had a craving for bacon eggs over easy and hash browns with some decaf. And it was perfect. I loved it. it hit the spot. First time there, but I'm going back again.Kid-friendliness: The Waitresses were really especially nice. They were extremely professional and pretty too“
“great service - great food - great prices. The best part is they are always consistent and their portions are always enough for leftovers the next day. We go there at least once a week and my kids love it as well! They also have gluten free options which is amazing so my son can still enjoy a grilled cheese!“