7 Best Sandwich Shops in New Haven

1
Olmo

Olmo Sandwich Shop • $
93 Whitney Ave, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Small Combo w Schmear of Cream Cheese
Lox Bagel with Cream Cheese
Choose Your Bagel Sandwich
Pastrami Egg & Cheese
Cacio E Pepe Bagels
Bacon Egg & Cheese
Hot Pastrami
Lox with Love
Olmo Bagel
El Diablo

“The staff is incredibly friendly, upbeat, and helpful. Above all, the bagels and shmears are nonpareil!!! The best anywhere. I’m sad that I don’t live in New Haven anymore.Vegetarian options: I think the majority of spreads are vegetarian“

4.7 Superb162 Reviews
Del Monaco's Italian Market Sandwich Shop • $
475 Townsend Ave, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Steak and Cheese
Chicken Cutlet
Steak Overload
Steak Bomb
Sandwiches
Pizzas

“My first time going there. I got a sub - the thing was HUGE! I got 3-4 meals out of it! Lots of meat and the bread - OMG!!!! I'd go there just to buy the bread! HIGHLY recommended!!!(I didn't take a picture because I was so hungry, but a picture wouldn't have done it justice anyway.)“

4.9 Superb37 Reviews
Ninth Square Market Fast Food • $
72 Orange St, New Haven

“My favorite place for lunch in New Haven! My go-to is the #2 and it's perfect every time. Great deal for a delicious sandwich, pickle, and chips. Sandwiches are a delicious and filling lunch and big enough to split between meals if you'd prefer. Staff is incredibly friendly, and I always look forward to saying hello. Aside from great deli sandwiches, the market carries a variety of other foods, ingredients, and beverages.“

4.9 Superb11 Reviews
Johnny Salami's World Class Sandwich Shop • $
205 Food Terminal Plaza, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Breakfast Burrito
Cuban Egg Roll
Roast Beef
A Burger

“The food is very good, whether it's a breakfast sandwich or a grinder for lunch. Freshly made and wonderful to taste. Great experience every time.Wheelchair accessibility: Not wheelchair accessible. Restaurant is located in a building with a loading dock style platform entrance, high up and with stair access only.“

4.2 Good19 Reviews
Meat & Co. Sandwich Shop • $
285 Nicoll St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Sandwich
Haute Tuna Melt
Pastrami

“Sandwich shop inside East Rock Market. I can't say I was too excited about any of the limited options, but the tuna melt punched above its weight. Tons of tuna and some good melted cheese on a panini-pressed ciabatta. I get that they're called Meat...but would be nice to see a veg sandwich option too...“

4.3 Superb13 Reviews
Koffee Katering Sandwich Shop • $
104 Audubon St, New Haven

“Koffee? Is exactly what you would want in a local coffee shop. they have great fare, and offer local artists and musicians a place to showcase their talent. you may also sometimes find a nationally known act here, you never know, Absolutely patronize this joint. You won't regret it.“

3.8 Good24 Reviews
People's Choice Grocery and Deli Sandwich Shop • $
734 Dixwell Ave, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken & Cheese
Sausage Egg & Cheese
Steak & Cheese
Cheeseburger
French Fries
Sandwich For
Ham Salami
Salad

“They make the best sandwiches and chicken in the Ville and the prices are good Hats off to people choice for not giving a greasy steak sandwich..the owner is always pleasant and knows his customers ........Wonderful.. a great variety of everything“

3.9 Good8 Reviews
Loading...

New Haven’s related cuisines

map Map