I work in Middletown First time eating here not impressed the sub was oily, I asked for light lettuce, and light onions wasn’t made right and I put in the instructions how I want it made my sub shop where I live in Chestertown Md makes way better and much bigger for the price I will not be coming back???
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 5
L T
I love Jersey Mike’s but as of lately the bread has not been as soft as it normally is & that turned me off because isn’t their bread supposed to be made fresh daily? I will absolutely choose them over Wawa anyway but I’d rather wait to purchase a hoagie from PA.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Alana Dudley-Sheldrake
The phone line is a part of the problem. I got a busy signal which I haven't heard since the 2000s to mid-2000s, or the phone will ring at least fifteen times with no answer and then I will call back the same thing happens then I call back and so on.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Salad Bowls, The Original Italian, Jersey Mike
Kristen Jammel
We’re big Jersey Mike’s fans and this was our first time at this location as we were driving through DE. Our club sub today was the best one we’ve ever had! It was full, made well and delicious! Very pleased.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Allie Crabill
I order 4 giant sandwiches last night for a pick up. I was happy to see it was already ready with my name on and the bag was sealed with a sticker. To my surprise, when I got home 2 out of the 4 sandwiches were correct. 1 of the sandwiches were only a regular size when I order a Giant and the other incorrect sandwich was clearly another customers (had someone else's name on it, tukery-blt instead of a loaded italian). At least 2 of my family members were satisfied but I do not think I will be going back to this location and will most likely next order online again to avoid this mishap.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 2
John Kay
It’s Jersey Mike’s, what’s not to like? It’s not a high end deli, but it’s super consistent and the food is good.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hollewood E. Brown
Upon entering, I was greeted with a cheerful welcoming. The sandwiches were made just the way I would have made them, but they added a lot more patience, which made them out great. I will be returning.Vegetarian options: THE mushroom sandwich is one of the best, that's all I have to say.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Abby Hamilton
I love Jersey Mikes subs! Their sliced meat is always fresh. I always order Giant sized so I can share half with a friend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tommy D.
Walked in at 8pm to extremely loud rap music, loud enough to where I could barely give my order. They were out of wheat bread and Bacon, but still charged me full price for my sandwich. I should of gone elsewhere, my mistake.
Bill Hughes
Great subs if they didn't make it so wet for takeouts. Rolls on two of our Italian subs were soggy when we came home to eat.
Had a large order at rush hour and a million questions. It was only my second time at a Jersey Mike’s. The first time, I was just ordering for me. Despite the mad pace of the dinner rush, they were so helpful and concerned. I didn’t want to look to see if the customers behind me wanted to drag me into the parking lot and rough me up, but the staff was unbelievably nice
Ryan E.
Had a large order at rush hour and a million questions. It was only my second time at a Jersey Mike's. The first time, I was just ordering for me. Despite the mad pace of the dinner rush, they were so helpful and concerned. I didn't want to look to see if the customers behind me wanted to drag me into the parking lot and rough me up, but the staff was unbelievably nice
kaitlyn t
Hit or miss. Most times I’ve had a good experience, especially in the morning/mid day. The food is always good, but the night crew always seems so miserable. One time, I saw them touch money and then go and make the food with the same gloves, but other than that it looks pretty clean in there.
Steven Butler
Good and friendly service, but ordered gluten free and was served on regular roll. Staff immediately made me a new sandwich, but others in my group had to wait for me. Unfortunately when I got home and tested with a Nima sensor, gluten was found. This is the second time I’ve had Jersey Mikes with a bad gluten experience. Would not recommend if you have Celiac disease or other serious gluten allergy
Victor C.
Love that this business is here in Middletown. The food is delicious and the service is great. Every time I go in they remember who I am and what I want to order. The staff is friendly and professional. The place is always clean.
I work in Middletown First time eating here not impressed the sub was oily, I asked for light lettuce, and light onions wasn’t made right and I put in the instructions how I want it made my sub shop where I live in Chestertown Md makes way better and much bigger for the price I will not be coming back???
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 5
I love Jersey Mike’s but as of lately the bread has not been as soft as it normally is & that turned me off because isn’t their bread supposed to be made fresh daily? I will absolutely choose them over Wawa anyway but I’d rather wait to purchase a hoagie from PA.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
The phone line is a part of the problem. I got a busy signal which I haven't heard since the 2000s to mid-2000s, or the phone will ring at least fifteen times with no answer and then I will call back the same thing happens then I call back and so on.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Salad Bowls, The Original Italian, Jersey Mike
We’re big Jersey Mike’s fans and this was our first time at this location as we were driving through DE. Our club sub today was the best one we’ve ever had! It was full, made well and delicious! Very pleased.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
I order 4 giant sandwiches last night for a pick up. I was happy to see it was already ready with my name on and the bag was sealed with a sticker. To my surprise, when I got home 2 out of the 4 sandwiches were correct. 1 of the sandwiches were only a regular size when I order a Giant and the other incorrect sandwich was clearly another customers (had someone else's name on it, tukery-blt instead of a loaded italian). At least 2 of my family members were satisfied but I do not think I will be going back to this location and will most likely next order online again to avoid this mishap.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 2
It’s Jersey Mike’s, what’s not to like? It’s not a high end deli, but it’s super consistent and the food is good.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Upon entering, I was greeted with a cheerful welcoming. The sandwiches were made just the way I would have made them, but they added a lot more patience, which made them out great. I will be returning.Vegetarian options: THE mushroom sandwich is one of the best, that's all I have to say.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I love Jersey Mikes subs! Their sliced meat is always fresh. I always order Giant sized so I can share half with a friend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Walked in at 8pm to extremely loud rap music, loud enough to where I could barely give my order. They were out of wheat bread and Bacon, but still charged me full price for my sandwich. I should of gone elsewhere, my mistake.
Great subs if they didn't make it so wet for takeouts. Rolls on two of our Italian subs were soggy when we came home to eat.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Restaurantji Recommends
Had a large order at rush hour and a million questions. It was only my second time at a Jersey Mike’s. The first time, I was just ordering for me. Despite the mad pace of the dinner rush, they were so helpful and concerned. I didn’t want to look to see if the customers behind me wanted to drag me into the parking lot and rough me up, but the staff was unbelievably nice
Had a large order at rush hour and a million questions. It was only my second time at a Jersey Mike's. The first time, I was just ordering for me. Despite the mad pace of the dinner rush, they were so helpful and concerned. I didn't want to look to see if the customers behind me wanted to drag me into the parking lot and rough me up, but the staff was unbelievably nice
Hit or miss. Most times I’ve had a good experience, especially in the morning/mid day. The food is always good, but the night crew always seems so miserable. One time, I saw them touch money and then go and make the food with the same gloves, but other than that it looks pretty clean in there.
Good and friendly service, but ordered gluten free and was served on regular roll. Staff immediately made me a new sandwich, but others in my group had to wait for me. Unfortunately when I got home and tested with a Nima sensor, gluten was found. This is the second time I’ve had Jersey Mikes with a bad gluten experience. Would not recommend if you have Celiac disease or other serious gluten allergy
Love that this business is here in Middletown. The food is delicious and the service is great. Every time I go in they remember who I am and what I want to order. The staff is friendly and professional. The place is always clean.