The Tuesday meatball and spaghetti special was delicious!! Hefty helping of spaghetti and 2 large meatballs cut in half was enjoyed by all 4 of us! A nice salad with warm rolls completed the meal. Waitress was very efficient and friendly. Lots of pick up orders were going out while we enjoyed our dinner.
H3LLYEAH
We read good reviews about this place, and decided to give it a try, and what a disappointment. The pizza dough was definitely not fresh tasted like cardboard. They were not generous with the pizza toppings at all. We will not be going back.
1Dealman
What an amazing find off the beaten path. One awesome thing about this place is the super friendly owner, who will make you any pizza he has ingredients for. However, if you love Philly Cheesesteaks then in my opinion you have to request an item on their secret menu. The "Philly Cheesesteak Pizza" and by the way their large is a huge 18" pie so come hungry with friends or you will be leaving with leftovers. Which I don't mind as reheating in my air fryer makes it as close to fresh as reheating can get. Plus they have amazing coupons in a local publication "Americas Favorite Coupon Book" So check this place out and bring their coupon with you and I assure you that you won't regret it.
Robert Savittieri
Personnel, atmosphere, all good, very nice. Most of items are very good ie pizza & subs. Menu is ala carte, so everthing is seperate. A dinner comes with whatever you order & bread knots, salad extra, (expensive lettuce & olives). Had Chic Fransese "soup" (see pic) had good flavor. If you like soggy breaded chicken then order, "I" don't recommend it. Theirs is on left after moving pasta to get away from 'sauce' - Most other's on right (different rest). Like I said pizza, stk & cheese, & subs all great, but chic fran dosen't cut it. (BTW I have 39 yrs in F&B business frm chef to F&B Mgr of Hiltons, jus sayin).Pups loved it
Cathie Mullins
GREAT pizza! I've been waiting 20 years for a decent restaurant to hit this spot and it finally happened. If you haven't tried City Nights Pizza yet, you really need to. The dough tastes homemade, and it's the perfect blend of slightly chewy and a little bit crispy on the crust. We will definitely be back.
Laurie Hrh
?? Outstanding. This place got new owners and had a name change recently “ City Nights” we pass by here frequently so decided to give them a try for takeout tonight. The food was really great ! My husband had a seafood pasta dish , it can be ordered mild medium or hot we got hot and it was perfectly spiced. I got the linguine with white clam sauce asked for it heavy garlic for wonderful sautéed garlic pieces in almost every bite . Wait staff was friendly and we enjoyed a glass of wine while we waited for our takeout. This most definitely will be a new regular spot for us
Denise Lambert
I stopped in to try their pizza, but their other selections caught my eye. I ordered a Shrimp Scampi for me and the Clams, Shrimp, Calamari, Mussels for my husband. Once we got home I planned on eating only half of my meal because it was so much food, but it was so delicious, I ate the whole meal and even followed it with a slice of their cheesecake, heavenly!!!
Eric Rizzo
Wow, this is a GREAT Chicken Pahm sub!1st time here & it was a toss up between pizza or this.The Tues dinner special is insane for the price! Top quality food too!They just changed the hours, so pay attention.Family owned & operated, nice people.Go show them some love & support.You will NOT be disappointed!
carmenrU7394DA
I had a great time at City Nights Pizza restaurant. My brother and I truly enjoyed the pizza, eggplant parmigian and their delicious cheese cake. Very spacious. The staff were very kind, welcoming and attentive. My brother and I plan on returning to enjoy the food and atmosphere.
Mike C
I went here for lunch. The person who took my order was extremely friendly and accurate. The flavors were very good but if the execution was better I would have been able to enjoy the Cheesesteak more . The sandwich was delicious but was just hard to eat. And I believe it was made with care but using a better hoagie roll that could stand up to all those delicious ingredients and care would have made the difference. I am definitely going back. Very solid experience. I thank you and your wonderful staff. Delicious food that may be a little messy isn't a big deal. The big deal is that the food is delicious. Thank you again I will be back. I normally don't do reviews because I believe most unfortunately are unfair and describes a singular experience good or bad . But to be fair is a rather rare occasion. I believe you have to go to a place more than once but the fact that I am willing to go back speaks volumes about my personal experience. I am from the Philadelphia area and I found your Cheesesteak comforting and full of flavor. Thanks again.
Family time at City Nights Pizza.We had a wonderful time. Treated with kindness and sweetness. The Waitress was very attentive.Not to mention the food is yummy ?Pizza pie & Eggplant Parmesan. Garlic knots so delicious.And also, delicious Cherry and Strawberry slices of cheesecake ?
Brandie Leffler
Awesome food!! Very very good! We will be back, next time in person! The food smelled delicious and tasted even better!!!! Well done!!
RD McIntyre
We had an excellent dinner. The owner Robert was very nice and one of his daughters waited on us. She was awesome, very pleasant and an excellent sales person! They offer a fried Calzone that was out of this world.We will be back soon.
Scott Weathersby
I frequent Pal Joey's and have been for four years now. The new owner Billy is doing an amazing job! The chicken parm tonight was awesome and the cheesecake I have to say was probably the best I have ever had and I have had a lot of cheesecake! Keep up the good work! #great job
John S.
The food was good, but the problem for me was the first thing you see when going through the front door is the back of the bar. It was as chaotic as a teenagers bedroom if u let them do what they want. It was visual diarrhea. Kinda makes me not want to go back because there are too many other Italian restaurants to choose from.
The Tuesday meatball and spaghetti special was delicious!! Hefty helping of spaghetti and 2 large meatballs cut in half was enjoyed by all 4 of us! A nice salad with warm rolls completed the meal. Waitress was very efficient and friendly. Lots of pick up orders were going out while we enjoyed our dinner.
We read good reviews about this place, and decided to give it a try, and what a disappointment. The pizza dough was definitely not fresh tasted like cardboard. They were not generous with the pizza toppings at all. We will not be going back.
What an amazing find off the beaten path. One awesome thing about this place is the super friendly owner, who will make you any pizza he has ingredients for. However, if you love Philly Cheesesteaks then in my opinion you have to request an item on their secret menu. The "Philly Cheesesteak Pizza" and by the way their large is a huge 18" pie so come hungry with friends or you will be leaving with leftovers. Which I don't mind as reheating in my air fryer makes it as close to fresh as reheating can get. Plus they have amazing coupons in a local publication "Americas Favorite Coupon Book" So check this place out and bring their coupon with you and I assure you that you won't regret it.
Personnel, atmosphere, all good, very nice. Most of items are very good ie pizza & subs. Menu is ala carte, so everthing is seperate. A dinner comes with whatever you order & bread knots, salad extra, (expensive lettuce & olives). Had Chic Fransese "soup" (see pic) had good flavor. If you like soggy breaded chicken then order, "I" don't recommend it. Theirs is on left after moving pasta to get away from 'sauce' - Most other's on right (different rest). Like I said pizza, stk & cheese, & subs all great, but chic fran dosen't cut it. (BTW I have 39 yrs in F&B business frm chef to F&B Mgr of Hiltons, jus sayin).Pups loved it
GREAT pizza! I've been waiting 20 years for a decent restaurant to hit this spot and it finally happened. If you haven't tried City Nights Pizza yet, you really need to. The dough tastes homemade, and it's the perfect blend of slightly chewy and a little bit crispy on the crust. We will definitely be back.
?? Outstanding. This place got new owners and had a name change recently “ City Nights” we pass by here frequently so decided to give them a try for takeout tonight. The food was really great ! My husband had a seafood pasta dish , it can be ordered mild medium or hot we got hot and it was perfectly spiced. I got the linguine with white clam sauce asked for it heavy garlic for wonderful sautéed garlic pieces in almost every bite . Wait staff was friendly and we enjoyed a glass of wine while we waited for our takeout. This most definitely will be a new regular spot for us
I stopped in to try their pizza, but their other selections caught my eye. I ordered a Shrimp Scampi for me and the Clams, Shrimp, Calamari, Mussels for my husband. Once we got home I planned on eating only half of my meal because it was so much food, but it was so delicious, I ate the whole meal and even followed it with a slice of their cheesecake, heavenly!!!
Wow, this is a GREAT Chicken Pahm sub!1st time here & it was a toss up between pizza or this.The Tues dinner special is insane for the price! Top quality food too!They just changed the hours, so pay attention.Family owned & operated, nice people.Go show them some love & support.You will NOT be disappointed!
I had a great time at City Nights Pizza restaurant. My brother and I truly enjoyed the pizza, eggplant parmigian and their delicious cheese cake. Very spacious. The staff were very kind, welcoming and attentive. My brother and I plan on returning to enjoy the food and atmosphere.
I went here for lunch. The person who took my order was extremely friendly and accurate. The flavors were very good but if the execution was better I would have been able to enjoy the Cheesesteak more . The sandwich was delicious but was just hard to eat. And I believe it was made with care but using a better hoagie roll that could stand up to all those delicious ingredients and care would have made the difference. I am definitely going back. Very solid experience. I thank you and your wonderful staff. Delicious food that may be a little messy isn't a big deal. The big deal is that the food is delicious. Thank you again I will be back. I normally don't do reviews because I believe most unfortunately are unfair and describes a singular experience good or bad . But to be fair is a rather rare occasion. I believe you have to go to a place more than once but the fact that I am willing to go back speaks volumes about my personal experience. I am from the Philadelphia area and I found your Cheesesteak comforting and full of flavor. Thanks again.
Restaurantji Recommends
Family time at City Nights Pizza.We had a wonderful time. Treated with kindness and sweetness. The Waitress was very attentive.Not to mention the food is yummy ?Pizza pie & Eggplant Parmesan. Garlic knots so delicious.And also, delicious Cherry and Strawberry slices of cheesecake ?
Awesome food!! Very very good! We will be back, next time in person! The food smelled delicious and tasted even better!!!! Well done!!
We had an excellent dinner. The owner Robert was very nice and one of his daughters waited on us. She was awesome, very pleasant and an excellent sales person! They offer a fried Calzone that was out of this world.We will be back soon.
I frequent Pal Joey's and have been for four years now. The new owner Billy is doing an amazing job! The chicken parm tonight was awesome and the cheesecake I have to say was probably the best I have ever had and I have had a lot of cheesecake! Keep up the good work! #great job
The food was good, but the problem for me was the first thing you see when going through the front door is the back of the bar. It was as chaotic as a teenagers bedroom if u let them do what they want. It was visual diarrhea. Kinda makes me not want to go back because there are too many other Italian restaurants to choose from.