17 Best American Restaurants in Islamorada

Square Grouper Islamorada New American • $$
80460 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Yellowfin Tuna & Avocado Eggrolls
Square Grouper Magical Brownie
House Square Grouper Sandwich
Grilled Oysters Rockefeller
Square Grouper Seafood Stew
House Smoked Fish Dip
Truffled Lobster Mac
Sesame Seared Tuna
Chicken Sandwich
Fried Calamari

“We were blown away with Square Grouper. Not only was the food the best meal we’ve had in the Keys but our server Rob was fantastic. He was extremely accommodating and was able to answer any questions about the menu with patience. We would 10/10 go back, recommend it to anyone, and ask for Rob!“

4.7 Superb265 Reviews
Mangrove Mike's Cafe Cafe • $
sunset inn, 82200 Overseas Hwy MM 82, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Pancakes with Eggs and Sausage
Kitchen Sink Tater Tot Tower
Cinnamon Roll French Toast
Craig's Hangover Helper
Eggs Bacon and Potatos
Gluten Free Hot Cakes
Eggs Bacon Pancakes
Breakfast Quesadilla
Biscuits and Gravy
Home Fries

“If I ever had a shark eat my legs, I'd drag myself slowly but surely back to this restaurant for one more tator tot tower from Brie. I live to eat, and I work to afford breakfast here as often as I can. Do yourself the favor and take a stop. If it ain't the food, it's the service. If it ain't the service, it's the awesome art and atmosphere around you. You can't start a day badly here.“

4.7 Superb206 Reviews
Wahoo's Seafood Bar and Grill Restaurant Seafood • $$
83413 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

The Wahoo's Fried Seafood Platter
Key's Local Whole Fried Snapper
Wahoo's Signature Seafood Rice
Classic Keys Fish Sandwich
Key Lime Pie in the Keys
Oysters on the Half Shell
Killer Conch Fritters
Mahi Mahi Fish Tacos
Key Lime Shrimp Bowl
Coconut Shrimp

“Doug is the best of the best waiter. Since we got there he treated us very professionally. The food was excellent and the place was clean and the best ocean view in the keys. Watch my video on YouTube. Miami fishing pipo. I highly recommend this restaurant and looking forward to come again. Video will be available Friday 4/12/24“

4.5 Superb304 Reviews
Lazy Days Seafood • $$
79867 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Oysters on the Half Shell
Broiled Seafood Platter
Key Lime Pie Slice
Key West Salad
Coconut Shrimp
Conch Fritters
Seafood Bisque
Conch Chowder
Conch Ceviche
Tuna Tartare

“Everything we ordered at Lazy Days was delicious. The location is right on the water, the service is excellent, and of course there's the food. It was so good we came back a second time! Oysters, escargot, conch chowder, lobster San Carlo, seafood pasta, all so good! Will definitely be back. Pack stretchy pants!“

4.4 Superb362 Reviews
Ziggie & Mad Dog's Seafood • $$$
83000 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Lobster Tail and White Truffle Mac & Cheese
Coach Shula's Barbeque Bacon Wrapped Shrimp
Ziggie's Classic Lobster Bisque
Hot Molten Lava Birfday Cake
Garlic Salted Onion Rings
Crabmeat Stuffed Snapper
Filet Mignon Medallions
Phyllo Crusted Escargot
Lobster Mac and Cheese
Potatoes Au Gratin

“Delmonico, scallops, truffle lobster mac were all excellent! Great wine as well. Our family agreed that our only complaint would be the chairs. The chairs were really hard and uncomfortable. That being said, it's not a reason to miss this restaurant when you visit Key Largo.“

4.2 Good180 Reviews
Marathon Bagel Co Islamorada American • $$
86701 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Whitefish Salad
Chicken Salad
Egg Sandwich
Italian Sub
Tuna Salad
Bagel

“Amazing fresh bagels! definitely get yours toasted and use one of the specialty cream cheeses. This is a wonderful breakfast spot, delicious muffins, bowls and pastries as well but the bagels are not to be missed! Great mural on the wall if you’d like to take photos.“

4.7 Superb68 Reviews
Morada Bay American • $$
81600 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Fish and Chips Morada Style
Big Boy BBQ Beach Burger
Bahamian Conch Fritters
Mahi-Mahi Fish Tacos
Whole Fried Snapper
Thai Shrimp Tacos
Catch of the Day
Watermelon Salad
Key Lime Pie
Calamari

“Just an amazing place by the ocean! The colorful decoration and all the little details are beautiful! We had the watermelon salad, lobster fritters (both delicious) and fish and chips! We would go back here for sure! Must be amazing during sunset!“

4.1 Good192 Reviews
Sunset Lounge Tapas Bar • $$$
80460 Overseas Hwy 3rd Floor, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Crispy Conch Steamed Buns
House Smoked Fish Dip
Lobster Roll
Disco Fries
Wedge Salad

“Loved this spot for a date night - so refreshing to have a kid free space in the area. The space felt new and had a modern and clean feel. Drinks were delicious and the seafood was amazing. We ended up doing a dozen oysters to try all their options then got another dozen of our favorites. We also got the caviar service which was lovely and the buttered toast it was served with was so over the top delicious. Also, the disco fries with filet mignon are a must order. Service was amazing as well.“

4.8 Superb32 Reviews
Green Turtle Inn Seafood • $$
81219 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Our Famous Turtle Sticky Bun
Captain's French Toast
Lobster Mac N Cheese
The Turtle Breakfast
Meatloaf Sandwich
Shrimp and Grits
Turtle Chowder
Conch Fritters
Bacon Wrapped
Crab Benedict

“I had such a memorable time here I didn’t even remember to take a photo or the delicious food or anything! I had the dish with key lime butter sauce and it was AMAZING my daughter ate her entire plate & she usually doesn’t eat fish! I was so impressed, the service was amazing and the sweet tea was amazing as well they have a big selection of drinks and wines and cocktails!“

4.2 Good156 Reviews
Hog Heaven Sports Bar and Grill Bar & Grill • $
85361 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Homestyle Mac N Cheese
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Key West Street Corn
BBQ Pulled Pork
Mahi Sandwich
Shrimp Tacos
Loaded Nacho
Lobster Mac
Key Lime Pie
Mahi Tacos

“Fun atmosphere, and beautiful view from the outdoor dining area.Food was amazing, and there was a nice variety of side options as well. Yummy drinks; unfortunately they were out of the Key Lime Coladas when we visited.Dietary restrictions: Decent variety of gluten free options. Not marked on the menu, but the staff was able to answer my questions.“

4.1 Good229 Reviews
Oceanside Safari Restaurant & Lounge Lounges • $$
73814 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Coconut Shrimp
Conch Fritters
Chocolate Cake
Cheese Burgers
Fish and Chips
Chicken Wings
Truffle Fries
Island Punch
Lobster Roll
Shrimp Tacos

“We had lunch at this restaurant and loved the food, service (excellent!) and drinks. We then were able to use the sun beds and relax by the ocean. That was a marvellous add-on!The only reason for lower mark on the atmosphere is because the place lacked class a bit (e.g. cocktail glasses were made of hard plastic rather than glass). It has so much potential with such a view and ocean front location!Vegetarian options: Matecumbe salad“

4.1 Good128 Reviews

Customers` Favorites

Brisket Sandwich with Fries and Collards
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Mac and Cheese
Baked Beans
Cornbread
Sauce
Ribs

“This place had great brisket. Also good Mac and cheese and collard greens. And to top it off, it was very affordable. Brisket, 2 sides, and corn bread was only $13! McDonald’s charges almost that for a quarter pounder meal and this is waaaaaaaaaaay better.Go here and get some barbecue!“

4.1 Good104 Reviews
Tides Beachside Bar & Grill Seafood • $
82100 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Mango Shrimp Tacos
Islander Burger
Conch Fritters
Key Lime Pie
Tuna Nicoise

“A beautiful view of the Atlantic Ocean and a very swift service by the pool. The wings and the tuna nachos were a great appetizer before we fished off the pier. The make a really great margarita at the bar!Parking: Once you enter the resort facility, go to the left and there’s a gravel parking lot in which to park for the restaurant or for visitors.Kid-friendliness: It’s a family resort and has a restaurant at the pool with a bar and chairs with umbrellas to sit under. Bathrooms are located across from the bar to the right near the painted wall with the green eel and other colorful fish wall art.“

4 Good31 Reviews
ReelCatch Restaurant Seafood • $$$
80001 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Belgian Waffle
Key Lime Pie
Black

“Chef Rico will give you the Cook Your Catch experience of your life. Amazingly talented, he took our fish and turned it into a 5-star meal!! Far beyond expectations, seriously just absolutely incredible and a lovely experience. If you're fishing in Islamorada, do yourself a favor and bring your catch to Chef Rico at ReelCatch.“

3.9 Good28 Reviews
Marker 88 Seafood • $$
88000 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Famous Homemade Key Lime Pie
Cheeseburger in Paradise
Islamorada Fish Sandwich
Yellowtail Meuniere
Key Lime Seafood
Shrimp -N- Grits
Coconut Shrimp
Lobster Bisque
Lava Cake
Crab Cake

“What a great find. I've been visiting the Florida Keys for over 40 years and finding good new spots to eat is a treat. Marker 88 doesn't dissapoint. The food was very good. My crispy fish sandwich was spot on. My guests had casedias, a rice bowl, and some wings. They enjoyed their meals too. The service was a little slow but the staff was very friendly. The atmosphere is over the top. Beautifully nestled on the water, this place is fun just to take in the sights. I recommend giving this place a shot. I know I will be back to try something different.“

3.8 Good268 Reviews
The Whistle Stop Pub Pubs • $
82685 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Chicago Deep Dish Cheese Pizza
Southwestern Egg Rolls
Mozzarella Sticks
Quesadilla

“Bartender was great, drinks were cheap, huge place and always crowded. However, they won’t control the jukebox box and some idiot put as priority of an entire album of Drake! It was a nightmare. No where in the entire place could u get away from the pounding nightmare music and everyone was miserable but they wouldn’t bypass it or turn it down. It ruined our night. Ohh food was good too.“

3.6 Good87 Reviews
MM 88 Tiki Bar Bar • $$
88 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

“We started with the Oysters, Rock Shrimp tempura, the ceviche and Chicken wings. The oysters were really good. They felt fresh. The shrimp came with a sweet sauce and the perfect mayo sauce. Someone in the table said it reminded them to the one in Nobu (I've never been there so I wouldn't know) but that's just how good it was. I hated the ceviche, it tasted weird. For entrees we ordered the Florida crunch salad, Spicy tuna roll and Yellowtail roll. We requested the cucumber removed on the spicy tuna roll and for some weird reason the server said they couldn't. Both rolls were delicious. Pretty simple, just how we enjoy it. The salad has all this crunchy items on it, that you actually enjoy eating healthy. Also the blackened shrimp that we added to the salad was $10 usd and it literally came with 3. For dessert we ordered the Banana Fried Roti and I promise you I will come back just for this. Vibes in there were amazing, they had live music. It's a nice, clean and well kept place. Our server kind of sucked. The place is on the pricey side, but just like everything else in The Keys.“

3.6 Good119 Reviews
Loading...
map Map