12 Best Italian Restaurants in Columbus

Mabella's | Italian Steakhouse Italian • $$$
14 W 11th St, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Fillet Mignon with Shaved Brussel Sprouts and Baked Potato
Pistachio Crusted Florida Grouper
Chef's Board Red Sangria Moscato
Pan Fried Provolone Cheese
Cheesecake w Strawberries
Prosciutto Wrapped Dates
Grilled Chicken Marsala
Wild Mushroom Ravioli
Strawberry Cheesecake
Spaghetti Meatballs

“Mabella is hit or miss. I've had more miss visits than hits unfortunately but that hit visit keeps me coming back and hoping for another stellar experience. Service is always wonderful, it's the food that is hit or miss. The menu items are just okay in my opinion. We have had every app and a few of the entrees and they just aren't anything to write home about. I have only had one special that was pork that was incredible. The rest have just been meh. I would also say the cheesecake that the employees seem brainwashed to tell you to order is really just plain cheesecake. During my first visit I asked for a recommendation for desert and told the waitress I didn't like cheesecake and she still recommended it lol.“

4.5 Superb160 Reviews
Caffe Amici Italian • $$
2301 Airport Thruway E2, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Florentine Cheese Dip
Mozzarella Triangles
Chicken Parmigiana
Stuffed Mushrooms
Garlic Bread Each
Side Caesar Salad
Fettucine Alfredo
Lobster Ravioli
Chicken Marsala
Calamari Fritti

“Cafe Amici never dissappoints! One of my college roommates and I caught them right before closing this week and the meals were as if we'd been there within the first hours of operation. I had the Cabonera and she had a Chicken Cusine...not sure of what it was called but it had tomatoes and she chose Angel Hair pasta. I was nervous to take her, as she is a native of New York and we all know they are renowned for Italian. It did ruin our 32 year Sisterhood ?“

4.4 Superb61 Reviews
Italian Soul Bar •
4022 University AveSuite 9, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Chicken and Shrimp Alfredo
Homemade Garlic Bread
Auntie Pam
Mya

“If you’re having any doubts about how good Italian Soul is: worry no more! It was absolutely delicious and the portions will leave you more than enough leftovers but what was even better was the hospitality and kindness of the staff. I ordered for the first time on a very busy night and there were a few mistakes made on my order but as soon as I reached out, my issues were resolved promptly and professionally. Please support this great business; good food is hard to come in Columbus so don’t hesitate to get your plate at Italian Soul!“

5 Superb18 Reviews
Trevioli Italian Kitchen Italian • $$
7466 Blackmon Rd, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Spicy Shrimp & Lobster Linguini
Goat Cheese Marinara
Scallops & Risotto
Spicy Shrimp And
Chicken Alfredo
Lobster Mac
Bruschetta
Caprese

“By far the best place to eat in town! This is a locally owned place and the owners are extremely hands on with their business and service. It truly shows in the experience and food they serve!EVERYTHING is exceptional and it’s always so hard choosing what to order. All of the dishes are homemade, fresh, and full of flavor. Plus the portion sizes are amazing.I recommend the spicy shrimp and lobster linguine, any of the risotto dishes, and Cajun Mac. But whatever you order, you won’t be disappointed!Be sure to save room for Brandi’s homemade cheesecakes when you come in.I can guarantee you’ll be coming back for more!“

4.2 Good73 Reviews
Your Pie Pizza Pizza • $
1019 Broadway, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Build Your Own Pizza
Make Your Own Pizza
Personal Pizza
Cheese Sticks
Cheese Pizza
Gelato
Salads

“I frequent Your Pie at the downtown location, but the last time we went it was exceptionally busy. Line out the door, I was pleasantly surprised at how well the staff was handling it. Everyone was very polite, didn't seem flustered and everything came out quickly.“

4.2 Good71 Reviews
Carrabba's Italian Grill Italian • $$
5555 Whittlesey Blvd Ste H, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmesan with Fettuccine Alfredo
Mama Mandola's Sicilian Chicken Soup
Tuscan-Grilled Sirloin
Cannoli Cake for Two
Fettuccine Carrabba
Johnny Rocco Salad
Grilled Asparagus
Fettuccine Weesie
Lobster Ravioli
Fried Calamari

“Our waiter. James was an awesome. He was very attentive to our needs, and answered questions accordingly. I would highly recommend his service and the restaurant. The food was delicious as always. Plus, I like the $10 meals to go. That always helps.“

4.1 Good110 Reviews
Johnny's New York Style Pizza Pizza • $$
6770 Veterans Pkwy Suite D, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Johnny's New York Style Pizza
Cheese Calzone or Stromboli
Pepperoni Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Meat Deluxe

“Our server is very friendly! She ensured we are enjoying our foods. At the end, we told her that we aren’t from here and would like for recommend to other places to eat. Without hesitation, she came back with a list of places from the owner of this restaurant. Who else did that ! Thank you!! Definitely highly recommended!!“

4.1 Good80 Reviews
Nancy's Pizzeria Pizza •
5295 Whittlesey Blvd, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Thin Crust Pepperoni Pizza
Deep Dish Pizza

“We drove 3hrs just to have “real” pizza! Relocating from Bflo, NY to Alabama we haven’t had real pizza! Although i love my NY style, this Chicago stuffed was amazing! The Buffalo wings were just as good! A new travel destination for the summer!!“

4 Good75 Reviews
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant Italian • $
5555 G Whittlesey Blvd, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Shrimp Alfredo Fettuccine Alfredo Tossed with Saut
Never Ending Dipping Sauces for Breadsticks
Shrimp and Chicken Carbonara
Chicken & Shrimp Carbonara
Chicken and Gnocchi Soup
Never-Ending Soup Salad
Five Cheese Marinara
Fried Mozzarella
Chicken Parmesan
Chicken Marsala

“This is one restaurant in Columbus that is consistently great. I never have had bad service nor a bad meal at Olive Garden. Other restaurants in Columbus, Ga need to take lessons from this place.The service is always great, I never have to wait to be seated and the food is always hot and good. The portions are very large and worth every penny.“

3.8 Good123 Reviews
Peluso's Italian Restaurant Italian • $$
4519 Woodruff Rd # 9, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Thin Crust Pizza with Two Items
Spaghetti and Cheese
House Special Pizza
Two Items Calzone
Minestrone Soup
Spaghetti Sauce
Pasta Plater
House Salad
Green Salad
Lasagna

“In a desperate search for non-commercial pizza, we came across this gem. I would say it looks rather intimidating from the outside. But, go inside and you will find friendly staff, fresh ingredients, and a place where the locals frequent. Absolutely yummy!“

3.9 Good36 Reviews
Your Pie Pizza Pizza • $
5592-L Whitesville Rd, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Build Your Own Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Deluxe Pizza
Vegan Cheese
Gelato
Salads

“Worked with a person with purple hair, I believe their name was Vincent, my pizza wasn’t quite right and they remade it for me with no problem. They were very kind, sharp and remembered exactly what I ordered. This person definitely deserves a raise!Dietary restrictions: I have a dairy and citrus allergy and was able to eat“

3.8 Good71 Reviews
Trevioli Italian Kitchen at the Rapids Italian • $$$
1329 Front Ave Suite A, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Spaghetti and Meatballs
Shrimp and Lobster Pasta
Spaghetti Bolognese
Smoked Salmon Cakes
Chicken Parmigiana
Strawberry Negroni
Scallops & Risotto
Vegetarian Pasta
Chicken Alfredo
Lobster Bisque

“We celebrated our Anniversary at Trevioli tonight and it did not disappoint! The braised short ribs were so tender and flavorful and the ganache tart was delicious! The service was wonderful and the atmosphere was cozy. Perfect for a date night or celebratory dinner! Highly recommend!“

3.7 Good81 Reviews
Loading...
map Map