19 Best Pizza Restaurants in Columbus

Cerrone's Brick Oven Pizzeria - Pizza Restaurant | Pizza Pizza • $$
7830 Veterans Pkwy G, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Build Your Own New York Style Gluten Free Cheese Pizza
Meat Lovers Pizza with Jalapenos
Small Pepperoni Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza Large
Buffalo Chicken
Supreme Pizza
Garlic Knots
Greek Salad
Meatballs
Meat Pizza

“We wanted pizza and instead of ordering from the normal places we do, we gave this place a shot. The service was great, pizza was cooked within 6-10 minutes and we got a large, even though we thought I’d would be too much for a party of 3. Will definitely recommend this to anyone looking for somewhere other than your normal pizza place like dominoes or Pizza Hut. Will definitely come back soon. ???? “

4.7 Superb113 Reviews
My Boulánge & Tower Pizza Pizza
111 12th St #101, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Quiche Specialitwaa 1175
Salmon Broccoli Quiche
Creme Brulee Croissant
Slow Your Roll Latte
Chocolate Croissant
My Favorite Quiche
Breakfast Sandwich
Almond Croissant
Quiche Lorraine
Chicken Panini

“5 stars for Seth and his works of art with Pizza and Strombolis. Between the dough being made from scratch daily, fresh cut toppings for each pie or Stromboli and the fact that he still hand tosses the pizza in air brings “Old School” Italian cuisine to downtown Columbus. We did the same at my father’s pizza shop in Baltimore….it’s as good if not better than my Dad’s pies! If you want a pleasant ambience, excellent staff and excellent food..this is the place!“

4.5 Superb63 Reviews
Speakeasy American • $
3123 Mercury Dr, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Club Sandwich a Favorite Triple Decker
Roast Beef ASU with Curly Fries
Chili Con Queso with Warm Chips
C C Q Chili Con Queso
Chicken Finger Basket
Grilled Chicken Plate
Taco Rider Supreme
Reuben Sandwich
Signature Burger
Cheese Sticks

“The waitress was outstanding. The food was speakeasy normal. Which is good. It's a great stop for lunch and they might advertise the camel rider they have a bombastic lasagna.Vegetarian options: I wouldn't. Vegetarians can't taste food anyway. Lmao, there is not many but they are marked on the menu as vegetarian.“

4.4 Superb73 Reviews
Rising Flour Pizza Pizza • $$
3709 Gentian Blvd Suite 1, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Build Your Own Pizza
Rising Veggie Pizza
Meat Lovers Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Cheese Sticks
Lunch Special
Bread Sticks
Cupcakes

“I ordered a chicken bacon ranch pizza, because it intrigued me. Little did I know though, that someone was cooking up a masterpiece in the back. The bread sticks come out and they're nice and warm and the taste is amazing. Not too much later, my pizza comes out and they place it on the table. I was pleasantly surprised by how good it looked. I pick up a slice and I have the greatest cheese pull I've ever seen outside of a commercial. I bite into it and all I taste is heaven. It's creamy, the proportions are perfect, and each bite I take gets even better. The wait time was a little longer than I had hoped, but pizza like that takes time and care. I would definitely come back here again, probably with friends. The price is pretty nice as well.“

4.6 Superb48 Reviews
Your Pie Pizza Pizza • $
1019 Broadway, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Build Your Own Pizza
Make Your Own Pizza
Personal Pizza
Cheese Sticks
Cheese Pizza
Gelato
Salads

“I frequent Your Pie at the downtown location, but the last time we went it was exceptionally busy. Line out the door, I was pleasantly surprised at how well the staff was handling it. Everyone was very polite, didn't seem flustered and everything came out quickly.“

4.2 Good71 Reviews
Mellow Mushroom Columbus Pizza • $
6100 Veterans Pkwy, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Spinach Artichoke Dip with Bread
Mellow Mushroom
Buffalo Chicken
House Special
Pretzel Bites
Caesar Salad
Spinach Dip
Beer Cheese
Bruschetta
Meat Pizza

“Our family has come here for about 9 years. The food is consistently good, the atmosphere is AMAZING, and the service is great. We get the brushetta every time we go, and it never disappoints. However, we try a different pizza every time we go. Last time, we had Pacific Rim, and this time was the house special(no mushroom on half). They never mess up the order, and we usually have a big order. Mellow mushroom is our family's go-to. The atmosphere can be noisy(as to be expected), so it's not intimate seating and may not be hearing aid friendly but a great family or friends place. Good job mushroom, way to set the vibe!“

4.1 Good90 Reviews
The Mix Market Bar • $
1040 Broadway, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Mongolian Beef with Fried Rice
Quesadilla Chicken and Cheese
Cheeseburger and Fries
General TSO's Chicken
General TSO Chicken
Chicken Wings

“Great atmosphere in downtown Columbus. Everything was fantastic. The restaurant is beautiful decorated preserving some history. The service was amazing. The staff were all friendly. The dill dip for the fries was something different for a change and did not disappoint.“

4.1 Good82 Reviews
Johnny's New York Style Pizza Pizza • $$
6770 Veterans Pkwy Suite D, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Johnny's New York Style Pizza
Cheese Calzone or Stromboli
Pepperoni Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Meat Deluxe

“Our server is very friendly! She ensured we are enjoying our foods. At the end, we told her that we aren’t from here and would like for recommend to other places to eat. Without hesitation, she came back with a list of places from the owner of this restaurant. Who else did that ! Thank you!! Definitely highly recommended!!“

4.1 Good80 Reviews
Pizza Pronto Pizza • $$
4400 2nd Ave #6, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Original House Special Pizza
Large 1 Topping Pizza

“Hidden gem! $7 for a large 1 topping pizza, $1 for each additional topping. The hubby got a pepperoni and bacon. He loved it. I ordered a mushroom and onion. Delicious! When you order, there is a small window to place your order. There is no access to go inside. Restaurant is located in a small strip mall with most of the businesses closed. Looks a bit sketchy, but definitely worth a try. Health Department inspection is on the front window with a 95. Don't let the outside appearance keep you from trying it! Pizza is delicious!“

4.4 Superb37 Reviews
Nancy's Pizzeria Pizza •
5295 Whittlesey Blvd, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Thin Crust Pepperoni Pizza
Deep Dish Pizza

“We drove 3hrs just to have “real” pizza! Relocating from Bflo, NY to Alabama we haven’t had real pizza! Although i love my NY style, this Chicago stuffed was amazing! The Buffalo wings were just as good! A new travel destination for the summer!!“

4 Good75 Reviews
Mr. Pizza Brick Oven and Tap Pizza • $$
3443 Macon Rd, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Knots with a Side of Marinara or Ranch
Side House or Caesar Salad
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Brick Oven Calzone
Whole Farm Pizza
Zucchini Salad
Pepperoni Pizza
Pig Farm Pizza
All Meat Pizza
House Salad

“It's one of the BEST pies we've ever had!!! My husband and I had supper and a couple of cold beers the other night when we were in town for our son's Turning Blue Ceremony. Beers were ice cold, and the service was on point. We started with the Brickhouse salad topped with homemade balsamic dressing, which turned my husband into a believer of a new dressing. We finished with the original crust Pig Farm. DELICIOUS. Highly recommend a side of their homemade marinara for your crust.“

3.9 Good59 Reviews
Your Pie Pizza Pizza • $
5592-L Whitesville Rd, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Build Your Own Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Deluxe Pizza
Vegan Cheese
Gelato
Salads

“Worked with a person with purple hair, I believe their name was Vincent, my pizza wasn’t quite right and they remade it for me with no problem. They were very kind, sharp and remembered exactly what I ordered. This person definitely deserves a raise!Dietary restrictions: I have a dairy and citrus allergy and was able to eat“

3.8 Good71 Reviews
Trevioli Italian Kitchen at the Rapids Italian • $$$
1329 Front Ave Suite A, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Spaghetti and Meatballs
Shrimp and Lobster Pasta
Spaghetti Bolognese
Smoked Salmon Cakes
Chicken Parmigiana
Strawberry Negroni
Scallops & Risotto
Vegetarian Pasta
Chicken Alfredo
Lobster Bisque

“We celebrated our Anniversary at Trevioli tonight and it did not disappoint! The braised short ribs were so tender and flavorful and the ganache tart was delicious! The service was wonderful and the atmosphere was cozy. Perfect for a date night or celebratory dinner! Highly recommend!“

3.7 Good81 Reviews
Peluso's Italian Restaurant Italian • $$
4519 Woodruff Rd # 9, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Thin Crust Pizza with Two Items
Spaghetti and Cheese
House Special Pizza
Two Items Calzone
Minestrone Soup
Spaghetti Sauce
Pasta Plater
House Salad
Green Salad
Lasagna

“In a desperate search for non-commercial pizza, we came across this gem. I would say it looks rather intimidating from the outside. But, go inside and you will find friendly staff, fresh ingredients, and a place where the locals frequent. Absolutely yummy!“

3.9 Good36 Reviews
Papa Johns Pizza Pizza • $
6381 Milgen Rd, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni and Cheese Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza

“It's pizza, you either do it right or you don't. They did it right and even accommodated a last minute change to an online order. They were plenty busy. So, good job, folks!Parking: The store is in a small strip mall, so when all the businesses are hoping, parking is at a premium.“

3.8 Good29 Reviews
Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom Pizza • $
6581 Whittlesey Blvd, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Craft Your Own Calzone
French Dip Sandwich
Cheesy Garlic Bread
Chicago 7 Calzone
Mozzarella Sticks
Cauliflower Crust
Individual Pizza
Thin Crust Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Deep Dish Pizza

“This is my favorite pizza place! I found them in Colorado Springs in 09 but upon moving to Georgia I searched and only found one in Chattanooga but now I have one in Georgia! I love pizza and I am very picky. They have the best crust! Try them all I recommend!“

3.5 Good101 Reviews
Papa Johns Pizza Pizza • $
4801 Buena Vista Rd Ste A, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni and Jalapeño Pizza
Meatlovers Pizza with Jalape
Chocolate Brownie
Pepperoni Pizza
Cheese Pizza

“my friend and i accidentally placed an order for the wrong location, and the guy helped us and was super kind about it! even called the place to have the order cancelled for us. only took 10/15 minutes and we got fresh pizza and brownies. thanks guys!“

3.7 Good35 Reviews
Papa Johns Pizza Pizza • $
5870A Veterans Pkwy A, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Brownie
Buffalo Chicken
Cheese Pizza

“I’ve never had Papa Johns before but my friend ended up getting it delivered and I was surprised at how good it was! We warmed it up in the oven and man it was popping! We got the 3 topping pizza with chicken, pineapple, and pepperoni! Yess pepperoni belongs on pizza! Nice pizza joint ??“

3.7 Good23 Reviews
The Suite Bar & Grill Bar & Grill • $$
5300 Sidney Simons Blvd, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

10pc Wings

“Nice place and atmosphere. We sat at a table and waited for about 10 minutes before I had to go to the bar to ask for service. We ordered wings. They had great flavors and the wings were a decent size. We also had drinks that my lady friend enjoyed. Seems secure as there were security guards walking around constantly. Unfortunately, we had to leave soon, but I believe there was a party scene brewing for later. I would visit again.“

3.5 Good46 Reviews
Loading...
map Map