This is no longer Bellagios it is now Fratellis .When you order they decide what you come home with. literally ordered buffalo wings mild they gave us Lemon pepper . Ordered a large Grandmas with pepperoni . Got it without .They put the salad in the same bag as the wings leaving the salad wilted .While the pizza does taste good the service is piss poor and clearly whoever is answering the phones isn’t communicating with the chef or maybe the chef is just doing what ever they want .They should make known when you call that you’re calling a different place . It’s bizzare that the number is the same and that this place is running under the name Bellagios .
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
First Name
I don't know what is or is not authentic NY Pizza, but I presume I will never have the authentic NY pizza experience unless I'm in danger of being mugged on the way to the pizza place and back while wading through throngs of impersonal, angry people against a sound track of blaring horns, the murmur of voices, and cell phone chimes.Inappropriate political commentary aside, this pizza is delicious, without any regard for its similarities to pizza from another region. I'm no connoisseur but I believe the mushrooms are sautéed and the veggies seem fresh. Subjectively, the crust is crispy, thin, and light, the sauce is of the sweet variety, and the meatballs and sausage are more flavorful compared to the more conservative selections used by many pizza places. On the Supreme, I generally could not sense the cheese, which might speak more about me than the pizza, but isolating it reveals a good mozzarella. The pricing of the pies is on par with chain pizza like Dominos and Papa Johns, so, let's say it's average.Any gripes I have are minor matters of preference, so, they do not influence the rating. For example, I prefer doughy garlic knots but these more closely resemble baked bread. Feel free to disregard my tastes based on pizzas I think stand out: I consider Mellow Mushroom to be the very best chain pizza. The BBQ chicken from Papa Johns is a 9/10. My favorite sauce is, somehow, Little Caesars, despite (or maybe because of) the abundance of garlic powder in the recipe.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Coolcee42
This place is never open even on Saturday it’s ridiculous I’ll never go there again they’re only open 2 days a week what a shame
nyc texas
This is proper New York Pizza, so very good. ?The problem with this place is that it's supposed to be open, according to the schedule on the door and Google maps, but when you arrive there's another sign saying "We closed earlier". This has happened twice already! ? Today (12/30/2023) they were supposed to be open till 9:00, but it was closed at 6:00. It sucks to drive all the way over there and the place is closed when it's supposed to be open. Very unprofessional! ☹️* Update: I went today, January 2nd 2024, and again a sign: "We are closed for the holidays " (see picture ). This sign was not there on the last day that they were open. I know that because I went there on the last day they were open (see above). Amazing!** Update: I went again today, January 4th, which according to the sign says they will be open. They open at 11: 00am, I arrived at 12:00... closed, nobody there! I hope they don't go out of business because the pizza is damn good.
Food: 5
Service: 1
Robert Sumpter
Excellent all the time!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Maybank Media 7
I’m a little upset I’ve been in Lawrenceville almost 12 years and I’m just now visiting this place. I will be ordering my pizza here from now on.I’m very particular about my pizza, usually avoiding the big chain stores. I don’t mind waiting a little bit on good food.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Susan H.
I had Uber Eats deliver a pasta entrée. Sorry I didn't take a pic- it was OK. Not bad, but certainly not memorable. Not returnable bad, just average at best. I would Not reorder or even try another entree. Frozen dinner quality..
Andy V.
This was one of my favorite places for pizza, knots, cheese bread, salad, calamari, even fries. Everything was fast and fresh with quality ingredients. I am not sure what happened but a recent visit was none of the above.I am seeing similar reviews here and elsewhere. I will be monitoring reviews before trying again. The staff also used to be very friendly and pleasant, that was not the vibe for my last order.
Quintus J.
Best NY style pizza in Atlanta metroI drive from Buford to get this and always worth it
Torin T.
When Bellagio's first opened, the pizzas were very tasty and loaded with sausage, pepperoni and other delicious topping. The sauce and cheese were proportional which made the pizza worth the price. But no more. A friend of mine ordered three different pizzas and brought them to our house. Each pizza was disappointing. Instead of large chucks of sausage, generous portions of pepperoni, chewy pieces of cheese and ample tomato sauce the pizzas lacked consistency with sauce and cheese. The pizzas had tiny pieces of sausage and only a few pieces of pepperoni. They were mediocre at best. We will not order pizzas from Belllagio's any more until the quality of the pizzas substantially improve.
We love this place! And the staff is amazing too, the atmosphere is very warm and welcoming, this is a great place for family time, portion is good, price is not economical but is worth it if you want a quality large pizza
Kristen M.
They have excellent pizzas, Strombolis, salads, and their marinara sauce is amazing too!
Remy Smith
Bellagio's used to be our favorite NY style pizza place, but recently the quality has gone down.
Sam Shannon
We love the pizza; but have rarely been treated so poorly. They close at 8pm on the weekend. At 7:15 they start putting up the chairs inside. They bring the pizza in a to-go box; lock the door and turn off some of the lights at 8pm. Customer hospitality also apparently ends at 8pm. If they're going to accept a fine in order at 7:15, they shouldn't be pushing people out the door at closing. Closing does not mean all patrons must be done and gone.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 2
T C.
Disappointed they actually gave me burnt knot rolls. Just sad, everything I've ordered from there has been fine until today. Just bad business when your bread is burnt & worse when they know they burnt them smh ..I will stick to Biba's for my pasta & bread next time....
This is no longer Bellagios it is now Fratellis .When you order they decide what you come home with. literally ordered buffalo wings mild they gave us Lemon pepper . Ordered a large Grandmas with pepperoni . Got it without .They put the salad in the same bag as the wings leaving the salad wilted .While the pizza does taste good the service is piss poor and clearly whoever is answering the phones isn’t communicating with the chef or maybe the chef is just doing what ever they want .They should make known when you call that you’re calling a different place . It’s bizzare that the number is the same and that this place is running under the name Bellagios .
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
I don't know what is or is not authentic NY Pizza, but I presume I will never have the authentic NY pizza experience unless I'm in danger of being mugged on the way to the pizza place and back while wading through throngs of impersonal, angry people against a sound track of blaring horns, the murmur of voices, and cell phone chimes.Inappropriate political commentary aside, this pizza is delicious, without any regard for its similarities to pizza from another region. I'm no connoisseur but I believe the mushrooms are sautéed and the veggies seem fresh. Subjectively, the crust is crispy, thin, and light, the sauce is of the sweet variety, and the meatballs and sausage are more flavorful compared to the more conservative selections used by many pizza places. On the Supreme, I generally could not sense the cheese, which might speak more about me than the pizza, but isolating it reveals a good mozzarella. The pricing of the pies is on par with chain pizza like Dominos and Papa Johns, so, let's say it's average.Any gripes I have are minor matters of preference, so, they do not influence the rating. For example, I prefer doughy garlic knots but these more closely resemble baked bread. Feel free to disregard my tastes based on pizzas I think stand out: I consider Mellow Mushroom to be the very best chain pizza. The BBQ chicken from Papa Johns is a 9/10. My favorite sauce is, somehow, Little Caesars, despite (or maybe because of) the abundance of garlic powder in the recipe.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place is never open even on Saturday it’s ridiculous I’ll never go there again they’re only open 2 days a week what a shame
This is proper New York Pizza, so very good. ?The problem with this place is that it's supposed to be open, according to the schedule on the door and Google maps, but when you arrive there's another sign saying "We closed earlier". This has happened twice already! ? Today (12/30/2023) they were supposed to be open till 9:00, but it was closed at 6:00. It sucks to drive all the way over there and the place is closed when it's supposed to be open. Very unprofessional! ☹️* Update: I went today, January 2nd 2024, and again a sign: "We are closed for the holidays " (see picture ). This sign was not there on the last day that they were open. I know that because I went there on the last day they were open (see above). Amazing!** Update: I went again today, January 4th, which according to the sign says they will be open. They open at 11: 00am, I arrived at 12:00... closed, nobody there! I hope they don't go out of business because the pizza is damn good.
Food: 5
Service: 1
Excellent all the time!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
I’m a little upset I’ve been in Lawrenceville almost 12 years and I’m just now visiting this place. I will be ordering my pizza here from now on.I’m very particular about my pizza, usually avoiding the big chain stores. I don’t mind waiting a little bit on good food.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
I had Uber Eats deliver a pasta entrée. Sorry I didn't take a pic- it was OK. Not bad, but certainly not memorable. Not returnable bad, just average at best. I would Not reorder or even try another entree. Frozen dinner quality..
This was one of my favorite places for pizza, knots, cheese bread, salad, calamari, even fries. Everything was fast and fresh with quality ingredients. I am not sure what happened but a recent visit was none of the above.I am seeing similar reviews here and elsewhere. I will be monitoring reviews before trying again. The staff also used to be very friendly and pleasant, that was not the vibe for my last order.
Best NY style pizza in Atlanta metroI drive from Buford to get this and always worth it
When Bellagio's first opened, the pizzas were very tasty and loaded with sausage, pepperoni and other delicious topping. The sauce and cheese were proportional which made the pizza worth the price. But no more. A friend of mine ordered three different pizzas and brought them to our house. Each pizza was disappointing. Instead of large chucks of sausage, generous portions of pepperoni, chewy pieces of cheese and ample tomato sauce the pizzas lacked consistency with sauce and cheese. The pizzas had tiny pieces of sausage and only a few pieces of pepperoni. They were mediocre at best. We will not order pizzas from Belllagio's any more until the quality of the pizzas substantially improve.
Restaurantji Recommends
We love this place! And the staff is amazing too, the atmosphere is very warm and welcoming, this is a great place for family time, portion is good, price is not economical but is worth it if you want a quality large pizza
They have excellent pizzas, Strombolis, salads, and their marinara sauce is amazing too!
Bellagio's used to be our favorite NY style pizza place, but recently the quality has gone down.
We love the pizza; but have rarely been treated so poorly. They close at 8pm on the weekend. At 7:15 they start putting up the chairs inside. They bring the pizza in a to-go box; lock the door and turn off some of the lights at 8pm. Customer hospitality also apparently ends at 8pm. If they're going to accept a fine in order at 7:15, they shouldn't be pushing people out the door at closing. Closing does not mean all patrons must be done and gone.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 2
Disappointed they actually gave me burnt knot rolls. Just sad, everything I've ordered from there has been fine until today. Just bad business when your bread is burnt & worse when they know they burnt them smh ..I will stick to Biba's for my pasta & bread next time....