Papa Kelsey's Pizza & Subs

$ • Pizza, Gluten-Free

Hours:
2285 E 17th St, Idaho Falls
(208) 523-3136

Take-Out/Delivery Options

Customers' Favorites

Papa Kelsey's Pizza & Subs Reviews

3.8 (37)

Went to Papa Kelseys before the midnight madness parade.. and I have to say that the crew was on point!!! The place was insane busy, but everyone was calm, cool, collected. It was clear that everyone had a job to do and they each did their part perfectly! We didnt have to wait long to order, and our order was perfect, and came out alot quicker than we anticipated! Kuddos the the entire crew, and a great job being prepared for a big rush!!

Can’t believe I haven’t tried them until now! My family and I tried a little of everything and we loved everything we tried! Taco salad was huge and delicious and fresh. The pizza was super tasty, the Italian sub sandwich was to die for. The staff was super friendly and helpful 10/10 recommend!!

So this is my first time here. This place was pretty cold inside. And it was pretty cold outside too. I think their heater was broken. Not sure?But I decided to sit down and eat.It took a fair time to cook.The server brought me my pizza. My pizza was kind of cold, but it was good.The price was okay.Maybe it came at the wrong time. But it did the job.

More Reviews(148)

Ratings

View all photos

Hours

Monday 7AM - 9PM
Tuesday 7AM - 9PM
Wednesday 7AM - 9PM
Thursday 7AM - 9PM
Friday 7AM - 10PM
Saturday 7AM - 10PM
Sunday Closed
Updated on: