12 Best Pizza Restaurants in Normal

Pizza Payaa Pizza • $$
107 E Beaufort St Suite C, Normal

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Burrata Be Kidding Me
Double Fried Chicken Wings
Three Cheese with Basil
Gluten Free Crust Only
White Garlic Sausage
Grilled Cheese Payaa
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Cheesy Garlic Bread
Cheesy Bacon Bread
Sausage Fun Guy

“We drive 45 minutes to get food at Pizza Payaa. While there are a lot of good pizzas in central Illinois, this is one of our favorites. The light crusted, deep pan is unique to this area. The sauce, cheese and toppings are also excellent and flavorful. They are frequently introducing new pizzas and collaborations with local businesses. We love that. Everything we have ordered from the rest of the menu is consistently good. Service is great and the building is a great concept for a modern pizza place.“

4.7 Superb131 Reviews
Monical's Pizza Pizza • $
1219 S Main St, Normal

Customers` Favorites

Spaghetti with Meatballs
Thin Crust Pizza
Family Pleaser
Pepperollies
Side Salad
French Dip
Sausage
Lasagna

“We love Monicals as you may know by our orders, but the last two pieces we received didn't seem to hit the bar. One time yeah I'm good we can deal with that but the last pizza we got was overcooked and I'm not wanting to complain and call and want a free pizza, I just want folks to do better“

4 Good46 Reviews
BloNo Pizza Co. Pizza • $
1304 Cross Creek Dr, Normal

Customers` Favorites

Boneless Wings w Tots
New Haven Style Pizza
Smoked Wings 1 Pound
Boneless and Tots
Bucket of Balls
The Kevin Pizza
Personal Pizza
Dough Nuggets
Cheese Curds
The Breaks

“I was with a group hosted pizza buffet style. I am celiac so I needed gluten free. Most gluten free pizzas tend to have a chewy crust or falls apart, but mine was crisp and loaded with toppings. I ate the whole pizza. The server was very accomodating.“

3.7 Good85 Reviews
Avanti's Italian Restaurant Italian • $
407 S Main St, Normal

Customers` Favorites

Tortellini with Meat Sauce
Italian Beef Sandwich
Turkey & Swiss Gondola
Primo Pizza Burger
Chicken Parmigiana
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Fried Ravioli
Garden Salad
Pizza Bread

“We decided to go to Avanti's for dinner to celebrate my birthday instead of our usual delivery or pick up now that the dining room is open again.Very disappointed...you order at the front counter at the cashier and pay ahead of time, seat yourself, and then get your own drinks back by the banquet room and kitchen. Not sure what happens when they are busy! Only about 3 or 4 other tables with a few customers at each so they were not busy that evening.Someone did bring the food to our table, then we were never checked on or asked if we needed anything else. I even had to track down my own take home containers.I hope this is only temporary as we had hoped for table service in a resturant. I guess we will stick with delivery or pick up for awhile. Food was still good, although the salad could have been fresher.“

3.7 Good73 Reviews
Cardinal Place Pizza Pizza • $
1608 Northbrook Dr #105, Normal

“Love their pizza with the cracker crust, multiple cheeses, sausage, onion, and pepper. The dining area is fine, nothing bad about it, clean and tidy. They have gambling machines in another room. Pizza always delivered hot and fresh, quality ingredients, I hope this place continues to exist.“

4.3 Superb12 Reviews
Papa Murphy's | Take 'N' Bake Pizza Pizza • $
1531 E College Ave, Normal

Customers` Favorites

Pizza with Dipping Sauce
Marinara Dipping Sauce
Cowboy

“Nice place to grab a quick pizza to take home and cook it there since you control how you cook the pizza.Vegetarian options: You can get plenty of toppings that don't include meat.Dietary restrictions: They have a thin crust pizza and gluten-free crust.Parking: It's kind of hard to find a parking spot at times in such a small area.Wheelchair accessibility: You could get into the building, but you would probably have to have help with the door.“

3.9 Good24 Reviews
Blaze Pizza Pizza • $
1601 E College Ave, Normal

Customers` Favorites

Build Your Own Pizza Large
Build Your Own Vegan Pizza
Pizza Done Your Way
Custom Pizza
Blaze Pizza

“This place is exciting. It feels like a pizza place. The ordering method is straightforward once you read the board. It's all laid out in steps. They make a great gluten free/dairy free pizza. The online order shelf was moved behind the counter which makes it a little less convenient for getting your online order when they are busy.“

3.7 Good48 Reviews
D.P. Dough Pizza • $
121 E Beaufort St, Normal

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Calzone Hot
Calzone & Stix
Cheeseburg
Tater Tots
Gyro Zone
Sauce
Vegan

“I have ordered the Don Vito twice! Once without tomatoes and a side of au jus, both packed with flavor. They stuff them with the perfect amount of ingredients. You MUST try the creamy garlic sauce as well, it’s sweet and tangy. I’ve never tasted anything like it! On a final note, before I ate here, I was not a huge fan of calzones.“

3.6 Good66 Reviews
Pizza Hut Pizza • $$
1700 Parkway Plaza Dr #1, Normal

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza
Supreme Pizza
Cheese Sticks

“I ordered on the Pizza Hut app, which was so easy, and chose the $5 off $25 out of all the available deals. I also requested curb side pickup. Pizza was done in the 15 minutes it said and the guy that brought it to my car was very friendly. The pizza, breadsticks, and wings were delicious and cooked perfectly! The bone-in mild wings were wonderful to my surprise!! I will definitely be doing this again soon.“

3.8 Good20 Reviews
Joe's Station House Pizza Pub Pizza • $
305 Veterans Pkwy, Normal

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza
Buffalo Chicken
Dough Nuggets
Detroit Style
Onion Rings
Beef Roll
Tenders
Philly

“Love the atmosphere, laid backGreat bartenders. Looking forward to taco pizza. Heard the buffalo wing is kinda hot, passCan't wait to sink my teeth into the pizza. Only downfall is the over amount of IPA on tap. Found a good draft beer.“

3.5 Good53 Reviews

11
Casey's

Casey's Pizza Delivery • $
810 Beech St, Normal

“I went here on 10/22 around 8:45pm, and I note the time and date so management here can look up the guy and gal working the kitchen at the time because THEY WERE SO COOL AND GOOD TO ME. For real, give these two a raise. Their dynamic, the small talk they made with me, and their attitude were enough to make me want to work at this Casey's, and this is coming from someone with two jobs already! They made me a couple of those pumpkin shaped pizzas, which looked divine and special by the way. The guy, who had sort of a warm Post Malone swag, commented on how he thought I would probably be the most popular guy at the Halloween party I went to because of the pumpkin pizzas they lovingly crafted for me. He wasn't wrong, people loved them, and I told them the tale of the dynamic duo working the kitchen at the time. These two were makin' it happen and they absolutely made my day. Whoever reads this, please make sure they know and find out about how their excellence was noticed and appreciated.-Jack P“

3.7 Good10 Reviews
Firehouse Pizza & Pub Pizza • $$
129 E Beaufort St, Normal

Customers` Favorites

Personal Pizza

“Used to be a frequent at the old firehouse. My wife and I used to have once a week date nights there. Since going vegan they finally have a vegan cheese option and it’s very good. The XL New York vegan cheese is our go to! The old location and the ambiance was better overall and customer service here is really lacking but you do what you gotta do! Will be ordering again.Parking: Parking is always a gamble because uptown normal is always busy unless the students are gone. Easy to access if you’re walking around but parking isn’t great to pickup or dine in.“

3.5 Good25 Reviews
Loading...
map Map