13 Best Italian Restaurants in Oak Park

Rustico Mediterranean • $$
155 S Oak Park Ave, Oak Park

Customers` Favorites

Costillas De Cordero
Seafood Paella Mixta
Pulpo a La Plancha
Spanish Tiramisu
Linguine Diavolo
Risotto Special
Grilled Calamari
Chicken Piccata
Fried Calamari
Patatas Bravas

“Rustico's new space on Oak Park Ave. (in the old Oak Park Brewery) is incredible in terms of its aesthetics. Very open, high, exposed bow-tie roof trusses, reclaimed wood plank ceiling, a really cool floor (tinted concrete?), and exposed brick walls. Totally cool vibe indeed. Myself, my wife, and two 21 year old kids dined there 1.5 weeks ago and it was awesome. Upon arriving, we were seated immediately. All of the staff that helped us were great: fun, personable, and attentive. We ordered the seafood Paella, Carbonara, Fruitti Di Mare, and Braised Short Ribs. All seafood in the Paella and Fruitti Di Mare was cooked to perfection-nothing was the least bit rubbery and everything was quite savory. The Carbonara was so tasty and incredibly decadent (which, when ordering Carbonara, you almost expect!). The Braised short ribs that my son ordered were so good (based on his review), but unfortunately, decorum prohibits printing the words he used to describe his love of the dish herein. When the bill arrived, there was absolutely no sticker shock and in fact, my wife and I felt that the entrees were very reasonably priced (especially given their generous portions). I don't think that many diners leave this place hungry. Personally, I love Rustico as the food is awesome but the restaurant is anything but pretentious. We will most def be back soon! Jimmah!“

4.4 Superb269 Reviews
Victory Italian | Oak Park Italian • $$
100 S Marion St, Oak Park

Customers` Favorites

House Garlic Bread with Cheese
Crispy Brick Chicken
Our Garlic Bread
Grilled Calamari
Chicken Parmesan
Fried Calamari
Eggplant Stack
Meatball Salad
Chocolate Cake
Caesar Salad

“This was my first visit to Victory and definitely not my last! Food and cocktails were delicious and our server, Orlando, was the NICEST person! Thanks to the manager who took care of me and my bestie. Wonderful ambiance and friendly staff!“

4.5 Superb89 Reviews
Cucina Paradiso Italian • $$
814 North Blvd, Oak Park

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Wrapped Dates
Rigatoni Bolognese
Brussels Sprouts
Fried Calamari
Arugula Pizza
Bread Basket
Shrimp Scampi
Cucina Puffs
Caesar Salad
Pear Pizza

“JOSE was our Waiter last night his service was impeccable! Smiles, jokes, makes you laugh, he waited on our party of 8 for 2 Birthdays, my Son and Mom, our party had various meals and everyone enjoyed! Jose always came back asking if we needed anything else, always made sure we had enough refills on drinks and making sure food was great. The restaurant is beautiful. Jose mentioned a dessert that crossed my curiosity. It was a Basil Blueberry Cheesecake. Now you would think spicy, not at all, it was delicious when you incorporate that savory and sweet flavors it was truly amazing! When I forgot the cakes, Jose had a plan B and made the Birthdays just as special. Thank you for making our 1st a Great Time! Will Definitely be coming back!The only thing that was a little difficult was finding a place to park, but other than that we asked after getting in and they do have a garage you can get your ticket stamped. Call ahead for parking.Hoping in the future that your restaurant might consider Valet Parking.“

4.4 Superb102 Reviews
Il Vicolo Trattoria Italian • $$
116 N Oak Park Ave, Oak Park

Customers` Favorites

Coconut Crusted Walleye
Chef's Soup of the Day
Salmone Alla Griglia
Pasta with Meatballs
Bread and Olive Oil
Ravioli Della Nonna
Pappardelle Al Ragu
Lamb Chops Vesuvio
Insalata Caprese
Insalata Spinaci

“I enjoyed Vicolo Trattoria, the service was good, the ambiance was your basic Italian restaurant. They have a bar seating area and more tables in the back. They also have a large patio for seating outside in the summer that I can't wait to come back for. The food was great overall: we had the grilled calamari to start. It was just okay for me - I have had more flavorful grilled calamari before, but others may think the grilled calamari is great so it's really just personally preference. Entree: we had the lobster ravioli which was really tasty served in red sauce. Also tried the wrapped beef that my husband really liked. He asked for medium but it was probably prepared medium well - there wasn't much pink in it. Drinks: I am a margarita fan - tried the spicy pineapple margarita and it did not disappoint. It didn't taste too sweet and had the right amount of spice. Also tried the Mandarin dreamsicle - on the sweeter side and filling.“

4.4 Superb86 Reviews
Betty's Pizza & Pasta Italian • $
1103 South Blvd, Oak Park

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken
Chopped Salad
Garlic Knots
Mac & Cheese
Cheese Pie
Vodka Pie

“The waiter and cook that were working there acted like they knew how to really treat people. And they did. This place has good food and staff that acts like they want it to succeed. They cared about us as customers and they have future restaurant owners written all over them.The low volume 50's music told me these people know what's up“

4.4 Superb69 Reviews
Trattoria 225 Italian • $$
225 Harrison St, Oak Park

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Saltimbocca with Prosciutto Capers and Lemon Wine Sauce
Strawberry Walnut Salad
Steamed Black Mussels
Chopped Italian Salad
Margherita Pizza
The Goat Pizza
Funguy Pizza
Beet Salad
blt Pizza
Pizzas

“One of us had an outstanding Manhattan and the other prosecco to start. Always enjoy the warm crusty bread that's a prelude. We split a Seafood Linguini which was excellent . Since it was Oak Park Restaurant Week we got a free dessert. We had warm apple tart with vanilla gelato which was also very fine.“

4.3 Superb97 Reviews
La Notte Ristorante Italiano Italian • $$$
1120 Pleasant St, Oak Park

Customers` Favorites

Fettuccine Bolognese
Pollo Alla Parmigiana
Spaghetti Carbonara
Grilled Calamari
Fried Calamari
Caesar Salad
Creme Brulee
Bruschetta
Cannoli

“Pablo, our waiter, was exceptional. During our first visit here, he warmly welcomed us and showcased impressive knowledge of the menu, even extending to items not listed. He encouraged us to customize our meal to our liking, and he certainly delivered! For starters, we chose the grilled calamari and Rockefeller oysters. The calamari was tender and impeccably cooked, steering clear of the typical rubbery texture. Opting for balsamic instead of oil was a perfect choice. The oysters were superb, not overwhelmed with cheese. I ordered the veal picatta from the menu, expecting a thin slab, but was pleasantly surprised by the generous portion size. The angel hair pasta complemented the dish well, although I could have done without the mushrooms – a personal preference, which I should've mentioned. Nonetheless, if you're a mushroom enthusiast, they give you plenty. My boyfriend ordered off-menu, enjoying the Zuppe di Pesce with shrimp, clams, extra calamari, and rigatoni Diablo style in red sauce. It was absolutely amazing and satisfied his taste without being overly spicy. To accompany the meal, I had a glass of the house Chardonnay, which was light and buttery. Even my boyfriend, who doesn't typically drink wine, enjoyed it. Our heartfelt thanks to Pablo and the owner/chef Giovanni for an outstanding dining experience, both in terms of the meal and the service.“

4.2 Good89 Reviews
Cuzzo's Pasta, Pizza, Panini, & More Pizza • $
330 Madison St, Oak Park

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni and Sausage with Bacon
Fettuccine Alfredo with Shrimp
Caesar Salad with Chicken
Cuzzo's Special Salad
Cuzzo's Special Pizza
Italian Beef Sandwich
Pizza by the Slice
Cheese Pizza Slice
Sausage Pizza Slice
Pizza and Wings

“I have always had great experiences here. They accommodate your needs too! Not a fan of meat pizza and if they don’t have any veggie slices they are usually able to make it on the spot. No one else would do that! Especially not that spot on Roosevelt!“

4 Good49 Reviews
Tre Sorelle Ristorante by Mancini Italian • $$
1111 Lake St, Oak Park

Customers` Favorites

Polenta Con Funghi
Homemade Gelato
Fried Calamari
Prosciutto
Gnocchi

“Booked a reservation for my wife and on Valentines Day. It turned out great. There was a live pianist that gave a great atmosphere. The service was great. We were checked on multiple times. Everyone was kind and respectful. The food was tasty. We would go back.“

3.9 Good56 Reviews
Rosati's Pizza Pizza • $$
1013 Madison St, Oak Park

Customers` Favorites

Crosstown Classic Combo Sandwich
Rosati's Cheef Sandwich
Italian Table Salad
Chicago-Style Pizza
Personal Size Pizza
Chicken Parmigiana
Thin Crust Pizza
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Tenders
Marinara Sauce

“One of my favorite local pizza spots on the West Side next to Home Run Inn. I’ve tried many items on the menu and haven’t had a bad meal yet. The staff is very friendly. My order is also ready for pick up and delivery is always earlier than expected.“

3.8 Good103 Reviews
Buona - Oak Park Italian • $
7025 W North Ave, Oak Park

Customers` Favorites

Italian Beef and Fries
Vegan Italian Beef
Crispy Chicken
Chopped Salad
Cheese Fries
Cesar Salad
Buona Beef
Peppers

“Second time coming; this time encouraged me to leave a review. Super sweet staff and made sure we were good/if we needed anything. Food is always really good and taste fresh.Parking: Parking lot is a little small but never had an issue parking.Kid-friendliness: Kid meals available“

3.5 Good51 Reviews
Salerno's Pizza & Pasta of Oak Park Italian • $$
7128 Roosevelt Rd, Oak Park

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo
Sausage Pizza Kit
Cheese Pizza Kit
Minestrone Soup
Chicken Vesuvio
Chicken Fingers
Fried Calamari
French Fries
Italian Beef
Garden Salad

“I have not eaten here in years. Decided to order a pizza for my birthday for my family. The dough at the bottom was so thick it took away from the delicious tasting sauce and cheese and sausage. This was a regular pizza I thought it would not be that thick. Probably should have ordered thin crust.“

3.6 Good101 Reviews
Oak Park - Lou Malnati's Pizzeria Pizza • $
1038 Lake St, Oak Park

Customers` Favorites

Chicago Classic Deep Dish Pizza
Toasted Mozzarella Sticks
Chicago Deep Dish Pizza
Garlic Parmesan Wings
Italian Beef Sandwich
Chicago Classic Pizza
Deep Dish Sausage
Great Bruschetta
Lou's Bruschetta
Thin Crust Pizza

“Dined here a few days ago, and Lou Malnati's in Oak Park never disappoints! Our server, April Diaz, was so accommodating and hospitable -- made us feel right at home. Mario and Dan are also extreme stand outs, as they've helped us in the past. A great touch by Ronnell, the manager, for stopping by our table just to say hello and make sure everything was being taken care of! Can't wait to return!!“

3.6 Good137 Reviews
Loading...

Find More Tastes In Oak Park

map Map