14 Best Italian Restaurants near Chesterton

Villa Nova Pizzeria & Bistro Pizza • $$
213 Broadway Ave, Chesterton

Customers` Favorites

House Salad with Blackberry Vinaigrette Dressing
Grilled Chicken Pecan Salad
Spaghetti with Meatballs
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Caesar Side Salad
Fried Cheese
Meat Lovers

“This restaurant originally from Chicago is my boyfriends favorite pizza in the absolute world. He would talk about it constantly, he lives out of state now and I live a few hours away from Chesterton. We decided to take a trip for my birthday and get some food. We ordered pizza, and shrimp Alfredo. The bread that comes as a side with the pasta is delicious and the pizza was too. We’ll be back!“

4.5 Superb56 Reviews
Lia's Bella Cucina Italian • $
401 Broadway Ave, Chesterton

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmesan
Meatballs
Lasagne

“Cute place, love the assortment of tables and chairs. The owners are fun - one of them especially is a riot! Love her! Definitely try one of the desserts while you're here - I love the tiramisu. Only reason for 4 stars instead of 5 is I wish there were a few more menu options, and the last two times I ordered the meatball sub I had to have them re-heat it because the meatballs weren't hot inside. BUT - when they were re-heated, they were great! :)“

4.6 Superb28 Reviews
Val's Famous Pizza & Grinders Pizza • $
112 S 11th St, Chesterton

Customers` Favorites

Sausage Pepperoni Mushroom Onion Pizza
Chesterton Fire Pizza
Spagoni and the Bomb
Sicilian Table Salad
Italian Beef Grinder
French Bread Pizza
Val's Special Pizza
The Bomb Sandwich
Veggie Grinder
Chicken Wings

“After a day of hiking through the Dunes, we were happy to find a restaurant with 4+ stars. The ratings were true. Our waitress was very kind and patient with our questions about the menu. She was prompt on refills and a delight to talk to. The food was good and we will definitely stop back by when we return in the summer for a new Dunes experience.“

4.2 Good83 Reviews
Lucrezia Café Italian • $$
428 S Calumet Rd, Chesterton

Customers` Favorites

Roasted Lamb Shank with Roasted Potatoes Onions and Braised Red Cabbage
Stuffed Chicken Breast
Three Meat Lasagna
Fettuccine Alfredo
Braised Lamb Shank
Four Cheese Pizza
Linguine Pescatore
Chicken Piccata
Stuffed Eggplant
Minestrone Soup

“The manager was our server, he was knowledgeable and let me make a scallop appetizer into a meal. My husband had stuffed shells which he also really enjoyed. The ghost rider wine was very nice. Tiramisu was quite good as well. In all, a total thumbs up!!“

4 Good81 Reviews
Gelsosomo's Pizzeria Chesterton Pizza • $$
371 Indian Boundary Rd # B, Chesterton

Customers` Favorites

Spinach Tortellini with Tomato Alfredo
Spaghetti with Marinara Sauce
Deep Dish Cheese Pizza
The Works Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Sausage Pizza
Garlic Bread
Tossed Salad
Bread Sticks
Pizza Bread

“This was an "accidental" visit. We were traveling on Christmas Eve and they were open. How lucky for us! I knew exactly what I wanted, so I ordered a small sausage/mushroom/ onion pie. My husband couldn't decide so he had our server choose from 3 options. She came back with a meat lovers with bbq sauce instead of pizza sauce. Both pizzas were excellent, and the service was super. I don't know if I'd have been so cheerful if I were working Christmas Eve. She kept our (very large!) cups filled with pop and checked on us a few times during the meal. And the price wasn't too bad! We'll be adding Gelsosomo's to our routine when traveling back and forth between Michigan and Wisconsin. Thank you so much!“

4 Good82 Reviews
Albano's Pasta Shop Italian • $$
Inside lambstone cellar, 1555 West Lincolnway, Valparaiso - 9.53 miles

Customers` Favorites

Kale Caesar Salad Saffron Tagliatelle
Curried Cauliflower Stew with Veggies
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Spaghetti with Meatballs
Short Rib Tortellini
Chicken Tortellini
Meatball Appetizer
Rabbit Tortellini
Beef Tortalenii
Eggplant Pasta

“Great for catering parties!!! We ordered Albano’s pasta catering pans for a baby shower. The food was delicious, pasta pans were packed full, and pick up was easy at the time we requested. Would absolutely recommend ordering Albano’s pasta for your next party/event!“

4.6 Superb79 Reviews
Tomato Bar Pizza Bakery Pizza • $$
2310 Laporte Ave, Valparaiso - 10.05 miles

Customers` Favorites

Hand Tossed Cheese Pizza
Magic Potion Pizza
Pizza of the Month
Oven Baked Wings
Blta Sandwich
Inch Calzone
Dough Nuts
Bruschetta
Dirty Bird
Tomato

“Yum, as always! Hummus was so delicious! Really appreciate the generous portions, especially in this economy. Great service!Vegetarian options: Many meatless optionsParking: Busy strip mall...parking spaces can be competitive.Kid-friendliness: Lots of room at this location“

4.7 Superb107 Reviews
Pizza Terra Pizza Takeaway •
302 Melton Rd, Burns Harbor - 3.23 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cinnamon Toast Crunch Cheesecake
Chicago Style Beef Sandwich
Marinated Chicken Breast
Crispy Brussels Sprouts
Wagyu Meatball Sandwich
Italian Beef Carpaccio
Seared Beef Carpaccio
Chocolate Tiramisu
Peanut Butter Pie
Pepperoni Pizza

“If there were more stars to give, I would happily award them to Angelica! From the moment we stepped into the restaurant, her warm smile greeted us, setting the tone for a delightful evening. Angelica's impeccable hosting skills transformed our dining experience into a memorable occasion.Her attention to detail was exceptional. She ensured that every guest felt valued and attended to. Her ability to anticipate our needs and preferences was truly remarkable. Angelica effortlessly navigated the flow of the evening, orchestrating seating arrangements with grace and efficiency.Not only was Angelica professional, but she also exuded genuine warmth and hospitality. Her cheerful demeanor and friendly banter created an inviting atmosphere, making us feel right at home. It was evident that she genuinely cared about our comfort and satisfaction throughout our visit.Angelica's dedication to her role as a hostess is commendable. She went above and beyond to accommodate our requests and ensure that our dining experience exceeded expectations. Her passion for hospitality shone brightly, leaving a lasting impression on us.In conclusion, Angelica's exceptional service elevated our dining experience to new heights. Her professionalism, warmth, and attention to detail were truly outstanding. We are grateful for her contributions to making our evening unforgettable. We can't wait to return and experience her hospitality again!Thank you, Angelica, for being an exemplary hostess and for making our visit so special!Warm regards,Phil“

4.7 Superb99 Reviews
Pesto's Italian Restaurant Italian • $$
3123 Calumet Ave, Valparaiso - 7.95 miles

Customers` Favorites

Macadamia Nut Crusted Chicken
Parmesan Crusted Filet
Roasted Garlic Chicken
Italian Beef Sandwich
Our Famous Breadsticks
Fettuccine Alfredo
Chicken Parmigiana
Seafood Alla Vodka
Chicken Parmesan
Toasted Raviolis

“The food was great ( rich, high-quality Italian food), and our server Cheyenne was on top of her game!Our party of six was able to be seated quickly, as they have ample seating. I ordered the appetizer sampler to split, and it was exactly what I had hoped for... Crispy fried ravioli and mozzarella, buttery garlic shrimp and well prepared calamari. Their Italian beef was really well seasoned and generous amounts of meat. I highly recommend! YUM!On a previous visit I tried their tiramisu and loved that too.“

4.4 Superb116 Reviews
Fazoli's Italian • $
2809 Calumet Ave, Valparaiso - 8.08 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fettuccine Alfredo with Broccoli
Fettuccine Alfredo and Pizza
Cheesy Double-Stack Lasagna
Cinnamon Swirl Breadsticks
Spaghetti with Meatballs
Six Extra Breadsticks
Chicken Carbonara
Garlic Breadsticks
Chicken Alfredo
Baked Lasagna

“I was so excited to find a Fazoli's, hadn't had it since I left college 25 years ago. It's still the same reliable, quick, budget-friendly pasta I knew all those years ago. And the breadsticks are FIRE, just as I remember. I'll gladly stop by whenever I'm in town again. Thanks for the memories!“

4.3 Superb67 Reviews
Santini's Pizza And Wings Pizza • $$
390 W U.S. Hwy 6 Ste G, Valparaiso - 5.8 miles

Customers` Favorites

Large 3 Topping Pizza
Mozzarella Sticks
House-Made Burger
Bread Sticks

“Ordered pizza for pickup tonight. Got large sausage and onion and bread sticks. It was one of the best pizzas I had in a while. Very great taste from the sauce to the crust. Bread sticks were good also.Service was great also no problem as it was on time. Did order pickup but the ambiance looked good . Will definitely order again when I am on the area. If you want a good pizza and price to go with it. This is the place. Thanks team.“

4.2 Good47 Reviews
Buona - Valparaiso Italian • $$
2901 John Howell Dr, Valparaiso - 9.86 miles

Customers` Favorites

Italian Beef Sandwich with Mozzarella Baptized and Fries
Gluten Free Italian Beef Pita with Green Peppers
Italian Beef with Sweet and Hot Peppers
Grilled Chicken Avocado
Mini Rainbow Cone
Meatballs Sausage
Birthday Cake
Sweet Peppers
Crispy Chicken
French Fries

“Shout out to evening assistant manager at the Valparaiso Buono! We were there Valentine's evening to get a rainbow cone. It was closed, but manager offered to open a nd make us a couple. Wow, have to say excellent customer service! Very friendly and outgoing. We will be definitely be back!“

4.2 Good93 Reviews

13
Cappo's

Cappo's Pizza • $$
6656 W U.S. Hwy 6, Portage - 6.32 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bosco Cheese Filled Breadsticks
Sausage and Pepperoni
Gourmet Mac & Cheese
Garlic Cheese Bread
Angus Steak Burger
The Mediterranean
Cappo's Combo
Baked Cod
Lasagna
Fries

“My wife's been wanting to come try this place out. We ordered some delicious cocktails. The crab cake and hot wing appetizers were also very good. The egg plant parmesan was really good but the lasagna was out of this world. It has some really unique and delicious flavors I wish I knew how to replicate because it's the best lasagna I've ever had!! I've heard their pizzas are delicious as well. I can't wait to come back to eat more.“

4.1 Good99 Reviews
Aurelio's Pizza of Portage Pizza • $
6500 W U.S. Hwy 6, Portage - 6.55 miles

Customers` Favorites

Thin Crust Pizza - Medium 13 Inch Canadian Bacon Mushroom and Onion
Pepperoni Sausage Banana Peppers and Tomatoes
Italian Beef Sandwich with Onion Rings
Chicken Parmesan Dinner
Italian Beef Sandwich
Breaded Mushrooms
Deep Dish Pizza
Chicken Tenders
Hawaiian Pizza
Stuffed Pizza

“The service was great! Our waitress was training and was so very friendly. The food was alright. I got the Chicken Parmesan sandwich...not too much flavor unfortunately. I'd like to go back and try their pizza! The breaded mushrooms and ranch were delicious however.“

3.8 Good63 Reviews
Loading...
map Map