“The guy Mason that runs the store is an absolute Pizza genius!! I've literally ordered pizzas from hundreds of other stores and they've never came close to the delicious decadent meal that was prepared for me this evening by the young man named Mason!! Thank you sir for your fine dining experience! We will absolutely be back for more pizza pies“
“Service is good. The staff looks over worked. If they had less stress on them, maybe more training or preparation for the busy hours the rating would definitely go up.Kids are doing the best they can trying to bust their butts to get pizzas out as fast as they can.It’s easy to find flaws in things but when’s the last time you gave someone in the customer service industry a compliment? Food for thought.I love my pizza and I am way too tired to cook so thank you guys.“
“It's always fresh and warm when I go and pick it up. The staff is friendly and usually about their business. They don't talk much. Only things I can say badly is that sometimes the pizza is a little too greasy (but nothing a tap down with paper towels can't help) & 2/10 times they don't cut it the way I put it. But overall the pizza is always good and barely have any problems.“
“I've been a semi-regular customer here for the last several months, ordering every other week or so. The pizzas have always been correct, delicious, and ready when they said they would be. I recommend this Papa John's location.Parking: Probably 20 parking spots. Has never had more than a few cars at a time, so have always had easy parking close to the door.“
Pizza • $
“I barely eat pizza, but when I do I'll go to Papa John's every time! I was expecting a long wait, because it was Super Bowl Sunday, but I got in and ordered and was out in less than a half hour! Maybe I got there before the pizza frenzy started! I appreciated the fast friendly service!“
“I LOVE THIS PAPA JOHNS! Papa John’s on Oaklandon is probably one of the best pizza places ever. We order delivery probably once every week. Each driver is very humble and are always very nice. The manager is also very good at what they do and we get our food within the est delivery time every time. Our favorite is the Alfredo pizza with meatball and sometimes adding steak. I definitely recommend this pizza place forever anyone wanting a good pizza and a good experience. Thank you Papa John’s for making us have a good experience every time!“
“This is probably one of the fastest, most professional pizza places in the area. The front staff are polite, courteous, and prompt. They don’t ignore you after you make eye contact and they typically have your order ready at the right time. The pizza is always on point but the service is what makes me recommend to others. Thank you for being kind!!“
“Love this Papa Johns. I used to go to the Plainfield location and they were always rude and snarky. The people here are usually nicer, and the food is great most of the time. There have been a few issues, but most of the time they're easily resolved. I would recommend this location. They're usually pretty fast too if you have a normal sized order.“
Pizza • $$
“I, like many others, ordered take out pizzas on Halloween. This Papa John's was run like a well-greased machine! Everyone had their job down pat, were extremely professional, and W♡W... the pizzas were hot and delicious, just like usual! There had to be 20 people waiting patiently... all smiles and I'm sure happy to be at that Papa John's! Kudos to the employees, managers, and general manager! I'm impressed!“
“The Friday night crew is AWESOME. Caitlyn is always so friendly at the register no matter how many people are in line or calling she is always so helpful! Nathan is a rock star! When they’re behind the counter I know our order will be 100%! Since Gina took over Friday nights I know that I can order earl in the day forget about it snd show up and it is spot on perfect every time! The whole gang is just a pleasure to see each time!!“
“I have to preface this review with the fact that we always carry out. I can’t speak to the quality of the pizza that’s delivered but I can say we have used the specific Papa John’s for over 15 years and I can count on one hand the times we’ve got a pizza that was less than excellent. I guess I should also share that in that time we’ve ordered, with no exaggeration, we’ll over 150 pizzas! Keep up the great work staff at Papa John’s on Southport.“
“Just want to give credit where credit is due, especially these days when it comes to our service industry. I thought the breadsticks I ordered looked a little small (length wise) compared to my typical order... after I mentioned it, without hesitation she offered to correct the situation by making a new set and had it ready in a few mins.Thanks for making my Friday a lil better“
“Ordered online and picked up in store. My chicken wings was supposed to be buffalo but the manager at the counter caught that they was barbecue. She yelled back to get a new order of wings done asap. Few minute's later I was out the door with my complete order.“
“The two gentlemen that helped me were very nice and helpful! One making the orders and the other the driver. The place was very clean, the guys were professional and also let me know that they could deliver to where I lived and gave me a menu as well. Had little wait time for a great Pizza! Thank you!“
“I was quite disappointed when I made my order and my points did not get applied, despite my selection to do so, via the app. However, the food arrived shockingly fast and the driver was extremely courteous and had a very positive attitude, a rarity for Indianapolis. If there was a way to have my order corrected and my points applied to the purchase, I would ask that the $20 I paid go to the driver for the exceptional service.I would also like to make the recommendation for adjusting the tip amount after the period of delivery as the standard tip I gave was given under the expectation of a standard delivery and I would have liked the option to update the amount according.“
“Great place to try out pizzas. Their create your pizza option was really good, and the Twix bites give you heavenly feelings. The chicken wings, along with the different sauces and dipped, are mind-blowing. You can also order late night and experience the same taste as you get in the “
“I've ordered from this location a few times in the last month or so. They've been consistent with the product and service. I always order online and it's easy to navigate. Today was a delivery order and it arrived so fast and fresh. I just want to give a shout out to whomever you have running the spot because I know it can be a challenge. I also would like to thank the driver for being friendly and making sure my order was accurate. Keep up the great work!! It's hard to find decent places to spend our money!!“
“A follow-up to my review on 10.29.23: The manager followed up with a phone call and was very apologetic. He said he wished they did not have to outsource their deliveries, but they have no choice. He said he was going to use our experience to provide some customer service training. I'm fine with that and appreciate the follow-up. He gave us a coupon for a free pizza. I shared with him that all I really wanted was accountability and an apology. I received both. Thank you.“
“Not feeling the need to cook.. easy cleanup.. and enjoy the rest of day..Vegetarian options: VegetablePizza.. cheese pizza..Dietary restrictions: Tell them what you want..Parking: Large parking..Kid-friendliness: The kids will love the aroma ?Wheelchair accessibility: Very large entry door.. nice ramps...“