Farina's Supper Club

3311 Pottawattomie Trail, Michigan City
(219) 874-7729

Recent Reviews

Andrea Bowmar

Excellent everything!

Love this place especially in the summer months. The food is very good, it's a little pricey but they do a nice job of making you feel at home. Our service was excellent and everyone is so friendly. It's a little out of the way which makes it even more special.

Sean Tennant

What a great place. 2 nd time here, came in from Detroit. Michael was are server, was a professional. Awesome dude.The whole place is top notch. Food was amazing. Had the special NY strip with asparagus, WOW.French onion soup is spectacular.Great wine and atmosphere.Definitely worth the trip. Made our night.Keep it going, you have a beautiful place.Sean

Service: 5

Rod Gayda

Great food, nice atmosphere.

Service: 4

Chad Miller

This is one of those hidden jems! Great food, service, and atmosphere!

Service: 5

Wavraider

Food was good as usual. Service was unusually slow and lacking. Server seemed less more attentive to the other tables around us than us. We were only a party of 2. The table of 4 next to us, she was making 2-4 stops and checks on them and walk backward or sideways away from us. Took 90 minutes to get our first and only order of bread. Server claimed other servers were taking them and not leaving her any. Our bread came as we were asking for boxes for our leftovers. Service Came out with an almost empty pitch of water to start our service and only offered 1 refill. Forgot to put in our drink order from the bar. But table next to us got drinks, grasshoppers, and wines before she realized to put in our bar order. My wife finally broke down and asked the other server in the same room we were in to find out where our server, drinks, and bread was. Then by magic our server arrived and asked if we needed anything! Ummm, yes. Like everything we ordered. Promised an extra order of bread with our leftovers, and that didn't happen either. When it was time to order, after I ordered my meal, she then remembered to tell me that the prime rib was being substituted by a NY strip. Would of been nice to know that like 30 minutes that we waited to place our order. I understand menu changes and supply issues and just running out of an item. But telling me about a substitution after I order as an afterthought was not professional. For the first time that we have eaten here ( like at least 10 times before) that we were glad to leave. We understand that staff is sometimes overworked and overwhelmed at times but coming to a fine dining establishment and paying fine dining prices I do expect a certain level of prompt and on time service. For only a few dollars more that we spent we could of eaten at Copper Rock Steak house where the service is always an 11 out of 10. We certainly hope that this was an one off bad night. This was one of our favorite places to dine on special nights.

LauraK

This was a tough one - used to be one of my favorite places to dine, especially when it was Duneland Beach inn. However last evening for Valentines Day, we were seated (for the second time!) against a wall. The restaurant was almost completely empty as we were early diners. Let me tell you, no one wants a view of a wall. Secondly, my partners food was cold, my side pasta dish was cold. Our server Michael was great and very professional. My martini came with one single green olive (is there a shortage of olives?!) We went away feeling like we were not given the treatment one would expect at this type of establishment. Probably won't be back - but from the way things went, I don't think they'll care much. I have always given this restaurant's name when friends would ask where to go - that will stop.

CandyA

Wonderful place, food top notch. Our server was exceptional. If there is a draw back it would be the parking. Lot is very tight and lighting could use some improvement. Overall a wonderful experiance

Erika Rodriguez

Brick Chicken Velasco---spicy and amazing. Bring an appetite. This place has amazing portions and great service! Delicious food. Parking can be challenging because its in a private location, but once you find it....don't miss out!!

Service: 5

TedF

We had a very nice dinner with friends at Farina's Supper Club. The food and ambience were very nice. I had the gnocchi which was great. Also had the grilled calamari appetizer with was very flavorful as well.

The parking situation is very bad.. Someone needs to let customers know before they turn into that unfortunate parking lot. Not some kid who does not want be there and does not do his job. If you know parking is an issue your plan needs to better

Yolanda Vega

I must say this was my 5th time there good never disappoints. Took my neighbors there for their first time and they loved it. However, I must say extremely upset as always with the parking lot tonight it was just pure mud. I cannot believe that of all times I’ve been there that the parking lot has not been fixed yet. It is beyond disgusting to say the least. Such a shame because I absolutely love this place.

Service: 5

AnnE

Wonderful experience last night at Farinas. Our server Kendra was very helpful and always there at the right time. Can't wait to go back! If it is on the menu, don't miss the King Salmon!

CBPRSeven

What a pleasant evening my husband and I had at Farina's Supper Club! The service was outstanding and the food was amazing. I would definitely recommend making time to dine here if you are in the area.

Timothy Lindstrom

Food was very good. Very good flavors. The wait staff was pleasant.

Load More