What are you looking for?

Mexican Restaurants in Michigan City

4.5 - 271 votes

Hours: 11AM - 8PM

3705 Franklin St, Michigan City
(219) 879-5124

Papa Johns Pizza

This time I tried the mushroom Swiss burger. Cooked exactly like I requested and it tasted great! More reviews

4.5 - 208 votes

Hours: 11AM - 7PM

731 Washington St, Michigan City
(219) 221-6071

Papa Johns Pizza

Love their ice cream and their burritos! They have real authentic Mexican food. Great service most the time! More reviews

4.3 - 240 votes

Hours: 11AM - 8PM

727 Franklin St, Michigan City
(219) 221-6639

Papa Johns Pizza

Delicious, decent bottled beer selection, excellent Mexican food. Cute refurbished old downtown location. More reviews

4.3 - 189 votes

Hours: 11AM - 9PM

3301 Franklin St, Michigan City
(219) 872-3333

Papa Johns Pizza

Awesome food, great service, huge portions and good prices. Vegetables were so fresh and chips were crisp. Apple pop was awesome, will come again if back... More reviews

4.3 - 180 votes

Hours: 11AM - 9PM

336 Dunes Plaza, Michigan City
(219) 243-7117

Papa Johns Pizza

This is the first time we tried this place during our visit to Michigan city and we were not disappointed. It is a decent size restaurant with cozy inter... More reviews

4.7 - 22 votes

Hours: 10AM - 5PM

429 US-20, Michigan City
(219) 221-6740

Papa Johns Pizza

Absolutely delicious….. The most flavorful chicken quesadilla I’ve ever had. The service is exceptional and the food is exceptional. 5 well deserved stars! More reviews

4.2 - 161 votes

Hours: 11AM - 9PM

2715 Franklin St, Michigan City
(219) 878-1802

Papa Johns Pizza

I always love Rios, my only problem is that they are so good and close to home that I want it all the time. More reviews

4.4 - 33 votes

Hours: 4 - 9PM

110 W 9th St, Michigan City
(219) 243-7136

Papa Johns Pizza

I came too late for food. Kitchen closed at 9. Drinks were very good but this place gets kudos for a very cool venue and excellent name. Agave Mansion ju... More reviews

4.2 - 65 votes

Hours: Closed today

123 Lighthouse Pl, Michigan City
(219) 262-5288

Papa Johns Pizza

There is no waiter and you have to place the order yourself at the window, they confused our order and as the guy was bringing the food to the table shou... More reviews

3.9 - 204 votes

Hours: 11AM - 9:30PM

4100 Franklin St, Michigan City
(219) 872-0760

Papa Johns Pizza

My favorite mexican restaurant in Michigan City. They have great authentic mexican food options as well as tex-mex for those who prefer it American style... More reviews

View on map