Papa Pepperoni Pizza

594 Locust St, Middletown
(765) 354-9880

Recent Reviews

Cyndal Norris

Their deals are unbeatable.

Bryce Southgate

fair pricing and great for the munchies


Their pizza is okay , a little pricey for the pizza itself ; but we got their pasta & that was not good what so ever , I definitely would only order pizza from this place . Which is okay like I said . Very odd we heard great things about this place but I’ve had frozen pasta from a microwave better then the 25$ pasta meal we got tonight . Just very bad . Pizza is alright though , cheaper then pizza king so we will make do with it . Cinnamon bites are awesome .

Joel Whitesel

This was my first visit, and we picked a meat lovers, a half pepperoni half sausage and mushroom, garlic knots, and a large salad. Five of us were stuffed and we had plenty of leftovers. While it was all delicious, the pizzas were exceptional! Great sauce, ample toppings, and a "just right" crust. Take a trip to Middletown and try one. Easily a top three pizza within an hour's drive from Muncie.

Sassy Fraz

We have ordered from here many times for carry out and delivery and have nothing bad to say about them. The employees are always friendly and the food is good. The full meal deal is a great deal and feeds our family of 6 easily for a very fair price. It is also always a bonus when we get the opportunity to support small local businesses!

Faith Long

We come here every year when we come to the fair, the workers are so nice and get our pizza out perfectly made and timlely.

Abigail Elizabeth

I’ve lived in Middletown my whole life and I’ve watched businesses come and go but this ones different! All the staff are so kind and hard working. Food is always delivered on time or early and the delivery drivers never hesitate to go above and beyond. I’ve never had a single complaint and I’ve ordered from here at least 100 times! Pizzas are amazing, salads are always fresh and their dinner meals are great also! If you’ve never had Papa Pepperonis you’re missing out!!

Alyssa Gauldin

Whole menu is amazing!

Amy Ertel

The food here is great!! Always is. How it keeps getting better after each time is a mystery. If you want a baked sub this is the only place to go in my opinion!! Great customer service and the delivery people are sooo kind!! Thanks for all you do for the community.

Shannon Norris

Great pizza!!! I think this is my new favorite pizza place! Love the hand tossed crust and the pizza had the right amount of sauce. The triple pepperoni pizza was so good! We were told the pizza would be ready for pick up in 25-30 minutes and it was ready when we walked in the door!

Deka Sinnard

They have an amazing staff great menu fast service you get a great service instantly may I add you should try the cinnamon bread sticks

Andrew McKenzie

Absolutely love this small town pizzeria

Jamie W.

Our favorite local pizza! We especially like the Big Papa pizza, a huge pepperoni pizza for under $15 (easily feeds 3-4). Living in town, this is an affordable delivery option. I'm also a fan of their subs and breadsticks as well. I definitely recommend signing up for their free VIP Rewards cub, they'll send you a birthday freebie and goodies throughout the year. The online ordering option is super easy and convenient.

Megan R.

Good pizza and the full meal deal is a great price! We especially like the garlic knots and cinnamon bites. I've also got their cannolis and I wish I had more to compare them to but as far as I know, they were great! It's rare to have cannolis as an option around here and I was excited to see them on the menu!

Randy Bower

If you are busy, let your customers know. I was told the order would be ready in 25-30 minutes. I show up 32 minutes after the order. Was told it would be 10 minutes. 22 min pass, then ask again, oh. It will be 6 minutes more. Finally walk out with order 42 minutes after arriving to pick up.

Load More