13 Best Coffee Shops in New Albany

Lady Tron’s American • $
147 E Market St, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Jane with Tomato Soup
Broccoli Cheddar
Bread Pudding
Soups

“I just got one of their specials (Vegan Ramen, and a Swiss, blue cheese, onion, and arugula grilled cheese on rye) and it was so so so good. I won’t get too into it because other reviews have done it way better than I could, but the atmosphere and service are so nostalgic and sweet. This is one of the best parts of New Albany for sure.“

4.9 Superb59 Reviews
Mickey's Coffee Shops •
624 Vincennes St, New Albany

“Gotta love Mickey’s! I’ve been here with family, friends, a first date, and even for an open mic night! The atmosphere is so inviting and cozy, and the staff is very friendly. I’ve gotten a different drink each visit and I’ve loved every one!I also love their book sales in addition to the coffee and treats! The perfect place to curl up and get some work done!“

4.8 Superb60 Reviews
Toni T's Cupcakes •
4510 Charlestown Rd, New Albany

“OK, first of all I'm reticent to review this business due to past experiences. A long time ago I did a review on King Donuts in Charlestown IN. I said King's Apple Fritters were the best I'd eaten. Now everytime I stop at King, they're out of Apple Fritters! Now for Toni T's. Wow, no seriously WOW. This was my first ever stop at Toni T's. It was later in the day so there wasn't a lot to choose from. I bought a serving of Bread Pudding. Now, I hate cake like bread pudding. I love moist, pudding like, Bread Pudding. Toni's Bread Pudding is the best I've eaten in my long life. It was moist, full of spices, and melted in my mouth. I swear, if it was calorie free I'd eat it everyday! I also bought some Banana Pudding but haven't tried it yet. Looks delicious.“

4.8 Superb48 Reviews
Starlight Coffee Co. Coffee Shops • $
3131 Grant Line Rd, New Albany

“I have been coming here for coffee for years! Staff is always helpful and friendly. I have never had a bad experience, never a bad coffee, never bad food or snacks. If you are wanting good strong coffee that tastes great then give them a visit. Coffee is so much better than some large chain store coffee places in the area!“

4.9 Superb29 Reviews
True North Coffee House Coffee Shops • $$
137 E Market St #103, New Albany

“True North was a happy break during our Saturday shopping in New Albany. My family was greeted right away and we enjoyed our drinks in the back room with chairs and couches. However, there's a lot of seating in the front room near the barista stand and it offers great natural lighting. The team making our drinks was friendly and pointed out their seasonal menu. I got the pistachio cold brew and when I asked about the sweetness they offered to tame it down a bit, which made it perfect. I wanted a cold coffee and having the pistachio flavor made it unique. There's so much on the seasonal menu to try, and if I lived closer I'd already be back today. Thanks for a great experience True North!“

4.7 Superb48 Reviews
Kolkin Coffee Coffee Shops • $
2736 Charlestown Rd #5, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Extra Shot of Espresso
Add Espresso
Whip Cream
Iced Latte
Bagels

“Let me start by saying I’m a coffee connoisseur. You will never find better coffee anywhere else!!! The employees are the friendliest people ! Always have a smile on their face. Kolkin is the highlight of my week ? Try the Iced Woodsman !“

4.7 Superb34 Reviews
Coffee Crossing Coffee Shops • $
140 E Main St, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Egg and Bacon Sandwich
Coffee Cake

“The downtown location has a small town charm. The building is rustic but yet contemporary. The staff are quiet, no one speaks much. Coffee is good and the hot coffee is very hot:). They offer delicious cold brews and what i like to call dessert blends, which are to die for. They offer a punch card for frequent guests, which gives a free beverage after so many punches. They offer a minor selection of baked goods, this location doesn't have as many baked items as the other CC locations. Bathrooms are clean. Dining area is comfortable enough, they offer couches and chairs, as well as table seating. Parking is a little small in front, but you can park in the back of the building and walk up the side ramp. My main issue is the hours for this CC location are very poor compared to the other CC locations.“

4.6 Superb36 Reviews
Coffee Crossing Coffee Shops • $$
4212 Charlestown Rd # 5, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Caramel Apple Cider
White Mocha Latte
Chocolate Caramel
School Crossing
Moose Crossing
Brewed Coffee
Criss
Caf

“Love coffee crossing! Highly recommend an Iced Moose Crossing for any newbies who like sweet drinks ! Service here is always amazing, professional, and personable, while always beating major chain prices! Amazing quality, chill atmosphere, and always very “

4.5 Superb52 Reviews
Coffee Crossing Coffee Shops • $
805 Talaina Pl, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Iced Chocolate Latte
Brewed Coffee
Coffee Cake

“They definitely have the best espresso. It's not watery, it's not burnt tasting. It's perfect. And their Strawberry Shortcake latte and blackberry cobbler latte are absolutely amazing! Super friendly staff and great atmosphere.“

4.4 Superb44 Reviews
Starbucks Coffee Shops •
4401 Charlestown Rd, New Albany

“First time I’ve ever stopped at one. Not a coffee drinker. But my girlfriend was given a gift certificate from a coworker. We both had a delicious cup of hot chocolate. She had peppermint put in hers and really liked it. Probably have to stop in and do this again. Service was friendly and fast!“

4.2 Good16 Reviews
Heine Brothers Coffee - State Street Coffee Shops • $
414 W Daisy Ln, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Egg & Cheese Sandwich
Banana Muffin
Bagel

“Mikaili made the best hot chocolate I’ve ever had! Balanced sweetness, hot but not scalding, with a beautiful swirl of whipped cream on the top. It has only been a few hours and I want to go ask them for another one and another one! Ask Mikaili for a peppermint hot chocolate and you won’t be disappointed!“

4.2 Good44 Reviews
Fresco Tea Bar Bubble Tea • $
2441 State St D, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Egg and Cheese on Everything Bagel
Unicorn Lemonade
Cinnamon Roll
Cotton Candy
Strawberry

“The lady is super nice. Our drink was absolutely delicious. So many flavors and options to create ur own. The inside is Beautiful. She offered to let my 7yr old try the different flavors. She even gave her a coupon for a free drink because we was there the day before and the AC unit was being fixed. It was all around a calm happy place. We loved it and we will definitely be returningKid-friendliness: She offered to let my 7yr old try different flavors.“

4.2 Good50 Reviews
Starbucks Coffee Shops • $
200 New Albany Plaza, New Albany

“Been going to the stand alone by the bank for the last year, and the last few months were just sadly filled with inconsistentcy. Started ordering from here this past week and they've been on point with my drinks. My main pregnancy craving is finally being fulfilled again.Vegetarian options: There are a few good vegetarian options. The impossible sandwich is my favorite food item on the menu, and I'm not even a vegetarian.“

3.5 Good32 Reviews
Loading...
map Map