Legacy Pizza & Bakery

1001 Vincennes St Suite 100, New Albany
(812) 725-0021

Recent Reviews

Zachary Richmond

Great pizza , we really enjoyed it , even the crust is delicious ?. This is our new favorite pizza place.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Breadsticks

Lisa Potter

Great place! We ordered three dishes and they were all delicious. Nice owners too.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Beef, Subs, Legacy Classic Pizza

Noah Wolf

Amazing food! Had the Rob Deep Dish, my fam got their own pizza and sandwiches they also loved. I asked for a substitution of bacon to replace the ham. They had a mix up and forgot to put the substitution in, which is fine -things happen. Unexpectedly, they comped me the messed up pizza and made me a whole new deep dish! Maybe I’m from an area with crappy restaurants but being left the food AND getting a replacement was a breath of fresh air! Will definitely return to eat some more delicious food

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Janna Schaefer

They have a great procedure for carry out. Food is delicious! The Rueben was stacked with corned beef. The Greek spaghetti squash meal was wonderful. It was a very large portion.I would definitely order this again.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Spaghetti Squash, Sandwich

Adam Borgman

The pizza was unreal!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Joshua Amsler

Everything I’ve had here is really good! I’ve been a few times and have tried a few of the pizzas and the Stromboli. All are so good you want more! I always get great service and the owners are very nice!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bacon Jam, Strombolis

Matt Collard

For the past 3 years my wife and I have spent Valentine's Day here. I can not recommend this hidden gem to enough family and friends! We love your food and cannolis! Keep making

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bacon Jam, Strombolis, Cookies

Courtney Reed

The pizza is delicious. We typically order pick up service from Legacy anytime our kid's school is hosting a pto fundraiser event through Legacy. However, tonight we decided to place a curbside order for the first time. When we pulled up there was no sign or information on what to do next, so we called just like you would at any other business that offers curbside service. The woman that answered the phone was pleasant and told us someone would be out to help us shortly. A female worker came out a moment later and explained to us that they have cameras so they know when someone has pulled up for a curbside order. She then proceeds to tell us how we didn't need to call the business once we arrived because it interrupts them from helping other customers and they are very busy and they don't have the time to answer the phone for curbside (this is all she came out for and took longer than my 30 second phone call.) I felt the last bit of information was very rude, unnecessary, and unprofessional. Her simply explaining that the cameras notify them that a customer is at curbside would have been enough. As mush as I love to support local businesses and my kids school, I don't think Legacy will be getting my service again.

Food: 5

Service: 3

Kerri M.

Bacon Jam Pizza Appetizer is insanely good! I wanted to check out a new pizza spot and this was an awesome find. The online ordering via Toast doesn't seem to work, I tried a couple times, then eventually just did old school call and order. They had curbside so that was pretty nifty. You pull up to what looks like a side door and they will come bring the pizza to you. I paid cash instead of card to make it easy on the curbside, but i'm sure it's fine either way.

Ryan H

Fantastic pizza, great flavor soft crust. The bacon jam and man o war pizza are both amazing. Staff was great. Literally the only downside is that its small so you may have to wait.

Stephanie M.

Food is amazing!!! Have tried deep dish pizza, calzone, pretz-oli, cheese sticks, & cannolis. All of it was unbelievably good!

L S.

Pizza is delicious and the crust is perfect texture with a interesting sausage shape. We loved it. Pepperoni bites are a good appetizer. Definitely a place to get good carbs. They have one of the best Reubens in the area. The bread is made in house, with lots of baked bread for sale and cookies. This place is a bakery and a darn good one! Good service. Great spot to eat.

Brittany Haas

Food is delicious! Breads are amazing. Wonderful service. Large portions. Great atmosphere.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Donna B.

Great pizza! And bonus, they have a bakery. Lots of fresh breads, brownies and cookies. They also make Canali.Dietary restrictions: We got gluten-free crust. It was excellent!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Ruby Rose Cannoli Is Only Available February to May, Legacy Classic Pizza, Brioche Bread Fresh Out of the Oven

Gigi Fry

Legacy is owned by a chef and his wife. They employ local teens and train them well. They serve pizzas, pasta, salads and sandwiches. They also have specials and a kids menu. They have carry out but I love the atmosphere. In the front there is a case full of sweet, wholesome goodies, such as bread pudding, brownies, blondies, and cookies. My favorite are the Oatmeal Cookies full of dried fruit. And if you are low carb or love spaghetti squash (as we do) you can have that as your pasta. IMO the food is totally delicious.Vegetarian options: Tell them what you want based on the menu and they will create it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Spaghetti Squash, Cookies, Legacy Classic Pizza, Bread Pudding, Brioche Bread Fresh Out of the Oven

Load More