10 out of Five ?I stopped in to look/smell and the woman working chatted me up, gave me a sample cookie and then a box of cookies? ?More proof that New Albany is one of America's great cities?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Devon Beevers
My wife had received a box of cookies as a Christmas present. They were so good had to get another box. They are the best around.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jess Ehm
Great cookies! Very friendly service! Definitely worth every penny.
Olivia Andrews
When we have friends and family visit from out of town, the first thing we do is buy them a box of Rookies’ Cookies!
Marvin Young
Excellent selection of cookies, danishes, and doughnuts.
Jennifer Cook
Rookies Cookies and Cakes made the cake for our daughter's wedding. I had many many people tell me that it was the best cake they have ever eaten! I was also pleased that Shara (the business owner) was willing to deliver the cake and set it up for me at the venue! Thanks so much for great service!
Joe Wheeler
Second time my family and I have stopped in for some Danish. They are delicious!
Chris A.
New Albany legendary bakery. Take the cookies to out of town friends & relatives and you'll be a big hit
Billy meredith
We love the cakes and all the treats! They are so pretty, detailed and delicious! The whole staff so amazing!!!
Jessica Haycraft
I had them make my daughters birthday cake for the second time this year, both beautiful and delicious! Super sweet staff too.
5/5 would recommend, they did sheet cakes for our wedding and everyone raved about them. Personal favorite is the Italian cream with cream cheese icing, and you could never go wrong with their thumbprint cookies! They matched our wedding colors perfect! Will be back in the future for sure!
Josh Braun
What a wonderful, amazing and delicious experience. I tasked Rookies with a last minute order, that they had no business accepting. Not only did they accept it they made unbelievably awesome volleyball cookies for HHMS 8th grade team!!! This was an awesome ending to the season. Quick!! Great customer service, and some of the best cookies ever according to the team. Thank you Rookies Cookies for your 5 star performance. Buy local!! Will definitely be back.
Angela Renee Elmore
My friend took me here fir the first time, today. The lady waiting on us was helpfully pleasant person. The desserts were decadently delicious.
Jennifer Leach
5/5 would recommend, they did sheet cakes for our wedding and everyone raved about them. Personal favorite is the Italian cream with cream cheese icing, and you could never go wrong with their thumbprint cookies! They matched our wedding colors perfect! Will be back in the future for sure!
Angel Hood
Delicious cookies, the little thumbprints and reasonably priced. Check hours though cuz closed for baking on unusual days and times.
10 out of Five ?I stopped in to look/smell and the woman working chatted me up, gave me a sample cookie and then a box of cookies? ?More proof that New Albany is one of America's great cities?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My wife had received a box of cookies as a Christmas present. They were so good had to get another box. They are the best around.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great cookies! Very friendly service! Definitely worth every penny.
When we have friends and family visit from out of town, the first thing we do is buy them a box of Rookies’ Cookies!
Excellent selection of cookies, danishes, and doughnuts.
Rookies Cookies and Cakes made the cake for our daughter's wedding. I had many many people tell me that it was the best cake they have ever eaten! I was also pleased that Shara (the business owner) was willing to deliver the cake and set it up for me at the venue! Thanks so much for great service!
Second time my family and I have stopped in for some Danish. They are delicious!
New Albany legendary bakery. Take the cookies to out of town friends & relatives and you'll be a big hit
We love the cakes and all the treats! They are so pretty, detailed and delicious! The whole staff so amazing!!!
I had them make my daughters birthday cake for the second time this year, both beautiful and delicious! Super sweet staff too.
Restaurantji Recommends
5/5 would recommend, they did sheet cakes for our wedding and everyone raved about them. Personal favorite is the Italian cream with cream cheese icing, and you could never go wrong with their thumbprint cookies! They matched our wedding colors perfect! Will be back in the future for sure!
What a wonderful, amazing and delicious experience. I tasked Rookies with a last minute order, that they had no business accepting. Not only did they accept it they made unbelievably awesome volleyball cookies for HHMS 8th grade team!!! This was an awesome ending to the season. Quick!! Great customer service, and some of the best cookies ever according to the team. Thank you Rookies Cookies for your 5 star performance. Buy local!! Will definitely be back.
My friend took me here fir the first time, today. The lady waiting on us was helpfully pleasant person. The desserts were decadently delicious.
5/5 would recommend, they did sheet cakes for our wedding and everyone raved about them. Personal favorite is the Italian cream with cream cheese icing, and you could never go wrong with their thumbprint cookies! They matched our wedding colors perfect! Will be back in the future for sure!
Delicious cookies, the little thumbprints and reasonably priced. Check hours though cuz closed for baking on unusual days and times.