The Exchange Pub + Kitchen

118 W Main St, New Albany
(812) 948-6501

Recent Reviews

Kayla Stallard

Cool place, but the food was not good at all (to me), and I'm sorry but 17 dollars for a freaking burger is absurd. If it wasn't for the birthday I was there for, I wouldn't have paid. I won't be recommending this place to anybody I know nor will I willingly go back on my own.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Chelsea Payne

I have been going here for years and it’s been one of my favorites. The last two times we have eaten here, I have been very disappointed. The burgers are not consistent with being cooked through. I’ve had areas where it was well done and other areas are medium at best. They forgot the pickles on the burger and the forgot the honey on the goat cheese fritters. I’m not sure if they are under new management or have got new cooks but It’s been very disappointing the last two times. I wanted to give it another shot because everyone has off nights but two times in a row his concerning. I hope changes are made and they get back to The Exchange I used to know.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Goat Cheese Fritters, G O a T Burger

Stan

A Great Place!!! Our food was excellent and our waitress was The Best!!! Loved the building and decor!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Goat Cheese Fritters, Fish & Chips, Pretzel

Branden Criss

Nice atmosphere and great drink selection.

Atmosphere: 4

Service: 5

Travis Mock

We were taking here for lunch by friends who absolutely raved about it and we were not disappointed. Everything about this place is first class. I truly believe it’s the best Berger within 30 miles of Louisville.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Steak Frites

Vicki Vincent

They food was surprisingly of lesser quality than expected. Our server was a bit unfriendly, but who I believe may have been the manager (dark-haired women) was extremely hospitable and kind. Ordered the goat cheese balls and a steak sandwich. Honestly, the goat cheese balls were something I had never had, and I did not enjoy them, but that may be just a personal preference. The steak on the sandwich was what the lower rating on the food was for. It was extremely chewy and un appetizing.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 3

Jason R Smith

Excellent place to visit. Food was amazing, staff was incredibly friendly, and very good craft beer. It is such a cool place. I highly recommend it!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Goat Cheese Fritters, Short Rib Gnocchi

Van Lankford

This place is on point with any meal you choose. Flavor artists.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Steak Frites, Verlasso Salmon Bowl, Goat Cheese Fritters, Beer Cheese, Exchange Burger, Pretzel

SHAWN SIMAR

Great place nice atmosphere with friendly staff. I had the fish and chips and it was very good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fish & Chips

Wife and I were seated right on time Waiter came got drink order . Cry polite and prompt Ordered the pretzels and cheese delicious Ordered Fish and chips Cooke just right plenty on serving Desert was bread pudding again delicious Wife got lemon dessert delicious as well Great place to enjoy a meal

Our food was fantastic! Flavors were awesome, everything was cooked to perfection. Next time we're in town we'll be coming back for the exact same thing we ordered if possible! If not, we're excited to try something else off the rotating menu!

Joe

Excellent atmosphere!!! Service was OK and slow. I had the Havarti grilled cheese with bacon and fries. Sandwich was good but fries were average. I'll be back......

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Grilled Cheese

Kevin Cole

We went for lunch, she got a chicken and I got a classic hamburger, she got the parmesan french fries and I got the regular french fries, both of us got iced teas. The hamburger I got was great, so was the fries. The wife’s fancy chicken was delicious and her Parmesan french fries were very good too. The iced tea was good. The place was really clean. The food was delicious. The people there were very nice or server was great. I recommend this place!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dakota Welbourn

Genuinely don’t understand the hype at all. Grossly overpriced for what it is. Burger was rare, requested mid-well. Fries had to have been made 2-3 hours prior(under done and had the consistency of wet sponge-cake). Short Rib Gnocchi was basically half mushrooms with two tiny slivers of short rib. Goofy prices for subpar food.

Food: 1

Service: 5

Cody Lamm

Prepare to be blown away because it seems like the culinary gods have descended upon this eatery, gifting us with gastronomic miracles that merit not one, but two emphatic "Slap Yo Mammas" seals of approval! Behold the celestial marvel that is the "Stupid Delicious, GOAT Burger," a divine concoction crowned with sinfully sweet candied bacon that will have you chanting in tongues of sheer delight. As if summoned by the gods of rock themselves, the ambiance envelops you in a cocoon of cool with the dulcet tones of Metallica serenading in the background, setting the stage for an encounter with the most hip and ink-adorned waitstaff you've ever laid eyes on. Among these deities of dining, our server Hanna stood out as the omniscient oracle of the menu, guiding us with sage wisdom that could only come from years of culinary battles. She's not just an employee; she's the heart and soul of this temple of taste. Driven by a hunger that knows no bounds, we embarked on a pilgrimage lasting over an hour to reach this promised land of flavor, and let me tell you—it surpassed every expectation. This is a sanctuary worthy of the highest praise from diners, drive-ins, and dives across the land. We'll be returning on our next quest for culinary enlightenment sooner rather than later. Oh, and a little birdie told me the manager bears an uncanny resemblance to Jack Black—no joke. But let's keep our focus on what truly matters: this place is a revelation.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Goat Cheese Fritters, Short Rib Gnocchi, Brussels Sprouts, Truffle Steak Fries

Load More