Tony Impellizzeri's

5170 Charlestown Rd, New Albany
(812) 949-3000

Recent Reviews

Lisa Stark

Love this pizza and cheese bread. Nice folks. So sorry to see it close but best wishes to Tony on his retirement.

Veronica L.

You're about to miss out on the worlds greatest pizza I've heard that this gentleman is closing the shop at the end of this week please if you have not had his pizza you better go this week because you'll never get it againGod bless him and his family we have enjoyed your food and your friendship

Diane Karem

Nothing like the original Impellizzeri's pizza. Jr did not disappoint. Only 5 weeks before he retires and closes so you'd better hurry and get a taste of history!

Kelly D.

Always outstanding. Tony is always there making the pizzas, coming out to say hello to his customers. Love this place. Great family owned authentic Italian food.

Kimberly Robinson

Great customer service and delicious pizza.

Michael Herrick

I drove three hours to meet friends and try Tony Impellizzeri's before they close next month. The pizza was worth every minute of the drive! Best pizza I've ever had! Service was AMAZING!

Texan Grit

Needed bread sticks and just made it in before they were closing. I only needed a large sauce and found out that they're closing this location in two months. So sad and happy for Tony who's ready to retire. You will be missed and I know we'll be visiting the Bardstown Location when we are in town and we have only found memories for this location and have been a customer ever since they opened up the local location. ?❤❤❤❤

ENGLAND CRESWELL-COLLIER

Great deep dish pizza! Was worth the accident we were in on the way there. ?

Donna Renn

Excellent service and excellent food. A place that has been a family favorite for more than 28 years and even longer for my husband. I just found out that that Tony wants to retire and this location is closing up and I don't want this to happen and we live out of town and come here several times every year and when we did live here we had it 1x a week and this is before this location was open I worked by the other one off Bardstown Road. We were thrilled to see it over here, but was told that he Tony is ready to retire. ☮ but ???????‍♀️

Kurt Reschar

I have been eating Impellizzeri's pizza for almost 30 years. Still the best pizza I have ever had. Tony makes the best breadsticks you will ever eat.

Sarah Nixon

Amazing pizza, great atmosphere (and that glorious SMELL) and a wonderfully friendly staff.

Donna Tolle

Long wait for large deep dish Sicilian pizza but ALWAYS worth the wait. Thanks Tony.

marty baugh

Absolutely the most incredible pizza ever.Their air conditioning was broke so it was hot in there, But that didn't matter because the pizza was so so so good . We still ate in. It was hot in there but the staff was chill I'd give it 10 stars if I could.

Kirby W.

This is our new favorite pizza place! Kind of a small family run place but they have the best pizza outside of Chicago! Lived in Chicago for 30 years- trust me when I say this is the best pizza in a 100 mile radius!!! Nothing else will do for me and my family now!!

Andy Nance

Every time I come in this place it gets better and better. The pizza is second to none, it's always big and I always usually eat on it for about 3 days. They never skimp on any toppings. And the lady that works the front desk is so nice and very personable like she knows you! 10 out of 10 would recommend??

Load More