Restaurants in Otterbein

Pizza King 109 S Main St, Otterbein Pizza • $$
109 S Main St, Otterbein

“Picked up some pizzas for an impromptu family get together. Picked up the order that was ready pretty quickly and I was going to need to make two trips and offered to help me carry it out. So appreciated!”

4.5 Superb64 Reviews
CJ’s Nite Owl 112 S Main St, Otterbein Bar & Grill • $
112 S Main St, Otterbein

Customers` Favorites

Salad Bar
Queen Cut Prime Rib Dinner
2pc Catfish Filet Dinner
Wednesday Wing Nite
Fried Mushrooms
Perch Sandwich
French Fries
Black Angus
Onion Rings
Hot Wings

“Food was great. Service was a little slow and the atmosphere was also a little slow. I will definitely go again and give it another go, as I've heard great things.”

4.4 Superb80 Reviews
The Dugout Otterbein Ice Cream Shop • $$
Otterbein

“Always an amazing ? from the food to the dessert.. its all incredible. They are always so nice. If there is a wait... its sooo worth it! You can call in your order too. I love that! ❤️ I have a couple of my free kiddi cones left so my girls and I will be back soon and my hubby's been craving a burger and pb shake ;)!!! Lol seriously tho. Check this place out. (It's a hidden gem! ?)”

4.2 Good88 Reviews

4
Subway

Subway 9150 W 500 N, Otterbein Sandwich Shop
9150 W 500 N, Otterbein

3.7 Good19 Reviews
map Map