Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mill St.

$ • Pizza

110 N Mill St, Lexington
(859) 281-1101


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Recent Reviews

The ideal place to eat if you’re drinking on or across the street. We came over from the Rosebud Bar at the bartender’s rec. The pizza isn’t anything special, but it’s tasty nonetheless and definitely hits the spot when you’re drunk. They sell it by the (very large) slice if you don’t want a whole pie, and the small pies are easily enough for two. I went three times over the course of one night, and each order (Pesto Bread, small Wiseguy, small Pepperoni & Sausage) full review
I haven't been to this location in a very long time but I use to go to the one on Manchester on a regular basis . This week has been a train wreck at work. I was really craving a "taste of home" which is New York. I decided to stop by and get a piece of pizza then I saw the canollis and the black &white cookies (you can find black&white cookies in any bakery in New York City or the surrounding boroughs). You can NOT find black &white cookies at bakeries here in Lexington. full review

Goodfellas is by far, the best pizza in Lexington. Missing New York? You can get your fix right here in Lexington! The thin crust amazingness has the perfect sauce to cheese ratio and never disappoints. Be sure to get a breadstick (they are the size of your arm by the way) and a side of their homemade ranch on your way out!

More Reviews(226)


Monday 11AM - 12AM
Tuesday 11AM - 12AM
Wednesday 11AM - 12AM
Thursday 11AM - 1AM
Friday 11AM - 2AM
Saturday 11AM - 2AM
Sunday 11AM - 12AM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.