Smithtown Seafood

501 W 6th St, Lexington
(859) 303-4100

Recent Reviews

Brandon C.

Me and my friends all got really sick after eating here. We had the oysters. Which came very late and tasted.... bland but off. Like, did they rinse them off knowing they were bad? I don't know. They gave us an extra oyster and dessert for the super long wait. It's the first time I've ever gotten sick from eating oysters, but also... why did I choose to eat oysters at a bar? Uhg. Never again.

Michael C.

Po boy is a little poor. I'm used to po boys being stuffed with whatever but only six shrimp had left me feeling wanting. However their fish and chips basket was decent portions and delicious. Sorry didn't grab a snap of that. Would return.

Steffanie C.

I'm absolutely obsessed with this place. There's not really much dining space in the actually restaurant, but you can order from West 6 brewery next door and they will deliver it to your table! The fried fish is of course a classic, but my favorite is actually the friend banana peppers. The dipping sauce they come with is amazing. I've also tried the shrimp and grits which were delicious. The staff are always super friendly! Food takes a bit to come out, but time is never wasted when enjoying the ambience of the brewery.

Karen Taylor

Very nice place good choices. Not too bad

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ken Wilson

Nice place to eat and enjoy craft beer & cider on

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

John

Friendly staff,great food!❤️

Teresa Davis

Average seafood, seating in 6th Street Brewing—nice selection of beers. The fried fish is good, Charlie’s Seafood is better for less. The clam chowder was watery and cold. The kale salad with garbanzo beans had little kale and no taste, and was so small—like a container of Cole slaw. Good, hot hush puppies, greasy fries. The grits and catfish is good, but the serving is not generous. It is too much money for what you get. Palmer’s Fresh Grill at lunch is better prepared, nicer ambiance, and a better experience. If you go, get the 6th Street beer and an appetizer of fried fish and hush puppies —you will enjoy it more than a meal on paper and plastic.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Catfish, Fried

David H.

First time here and not impressed. I had the fish and chips that came with slaw and hush puppies for $14. First the fish was very good, probably the best around the area. The bad, only one piece of fish, slaw and hush puppies were terrible and not eatable. The fries were just ok. My wife had fish tacos that came with no side $14. The tacos had a piece of fish the size of a hush puppy on them. Had the terrible slaw on them which she removed. Expected and hoped this place would be a-lot better.

Tamara Green

One of the best fish sandwiches ever! It's located next door to West 6th brewery, and they will deliver to your table there.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Bryan Gatlin

Great fried fish! The oysters were fresh, but on the small side. Good portions otherwise. Would recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fish & Chips

B

Dysfunctional operation. Be aware that when placing orders online, they will be completely out of certain items which they won’t take off of their website. After you place the order, they will call to say they are out. When you request a refund, you will never receive the refund and still be charged for the order and the tip! Still waiting for my money back. Stay away from this poorly run and managed operation, they will gladly take your money and make it difficult to ever get it back.

Food: 4

Service: 1

Greg Smith

Had the buffalo catfish sandwich, best fish sandwich I've ever had.

Greg Reichardt

I can't stop ordering and thinking about the Shrimp Po

Food: 5

Recommended dishes: Shrimp PO Boy

DN Buck

Food has been great every visit (Maybe 4 now). Dining space is in west sixth brewery and is extremely casual. The rocking chairs at the tables are very comfortable but the industrial vibe makes the ambiance a little cold.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fish & Chips

Rusty Shackleford

They ran out of American Cheese and had us substitute for White Cheddar for a $1 upcharge. I asked the waitress as a courtesy to substitute it for FREE since they ran out of what we wanted and ordered, but she refused to. It's not like I couldn't afford a $1, but it was more of a customer service courtesy situation.Vegetarian options: Need more options for vegetarians.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Clam Chowder

Load More