We are traveling from Indiana. We have never had Rotolo's Pizza and thought it looked good. We ordered online. When I arrived to pick up our order of 2 small pizzas and an order of breadsticks they had made 2 of the same pizza. They said, "we will make it right." Problem was, they only remade one pizza. The other pizza and breadsticks were cold by the time the 2nd pizza was made. I mentioned it to one of the staff, saying the other pizza and breadsticks will be cold by the time the corrected pizza is made. To which she replies, "if that's the case we will make it right." Well, 8 minutes later the pizza was cooked and of course the 2nd pizza and breadsticks were cold. No one bothered to try to "make it right". Why would anyone think it's acceptable to only remake one pizza in this situation? The entire order should have been remade.Flavor was good considering more than half the order was cold.We were very disappointed to say the least and won't order from Rotolo's Pizzeria again.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Georgina G.
Some of the best pizza anywhere. Crust is tender but crisp on the edges. It was loaded with toppings. Poboy bread is the best! Service is quick and the building is very nice.
nicole parfait
The pizza is great. It's the dang calzone. I ordered the deluxe and when it arrived at the table the inside was cold to the touch like refrigerator cold. They took it back and I assume just heated it in microwave . It came back to the table and the toppings weren't cooked. I mean aren't the mushrooms and peppers supposed to be cooked? It was crispy raw is the only way I can explain it.. I've never experienced this with a calzone and had I known it was like this I would of never ordered it. Oh and couldn't even find the cheese inside. But hey the cheese sticks and pizza are amazing! Just beware of the deluxe combination calzone. I'll add that they did take it off the check. I just hate having to do that. I never like being that person. But then again I work hard for my money ?
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Tina Chaisson
The food was good and fresh. It was a nice, calm atmosphere. The muffala wasn't as good as we remember, but it wasn't bad. The pizza and appetizer were perfect.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Muffuletta, Pizza
Dominique Douglas
hadn't had a calzone in a long time,got the combination deluxe and it was fantastic,fresh ingredients and simply delicious ?
We all went to eat at Rotolos today. 8-20-23 My first time there. They were busy. But the food was really good. Everyone that ate, really liked their food. A little on the pricey side. Atmosphere was ok. Waitress did a great job and moved as fast as she could! ! I would go back again and I would recommend this location on St. Charles street. ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Meat Feast
Anita G.
We all went to eat at Rotolos today. 8-20-23 My first time there. They were busy. But the food was really good. Everyone that ate, really liked their food. A little on the pricey side. Atmosphere was ok. Waitress did a great job and moved as fast as she could! ! I would go back again and I would recommend this location on St. Charles street.
G
Deluxe Combination 12” pizza was amazing, fresh and flavorful. Caesar salad was okay. Will
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Gary Severns
Deluxe Combination 12” pizza was amazing, fresh and flavorful. Caesar salad was okay. Will
This was the most awesome food service and employees were great. Also my husband lost $300 cash at our table he realized it after we left. Our waitress found it turned it in to her manager they got my name from my receipt I paid with my card looked me up on Facebook and informed me that they had our cash. We went and picked it up and we're so very grateful and very impressed with the honesty. The food was fantastic as well. Go there you won't regret it honestly!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeffrey Mouton
Mia was a great waitress, knows the menu very well .my wife had lasagne w/roll bites and I had a garden salad, wth walnuts and cranberry s added w/ ranch. This is a must stop if you like Italian food, and yes they have pizza! The bar section always enjoys a good LSU baseball game. Conventlely located on St. Charles stKid-friendliness: Good options for all ages (even for the kid inside us)Parking: Parking is amble shared with the other shops located thereWheelchair accessibility: They are compliment with accessiblity
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
kris hardwick
Always a solid place to visit with great food. Anytime day or night is good time for one of their pies especially the non-traditional selection. And the Ricotta dip is amazing
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Raymond Sonnier
meatballs appetizer is great! Pizza was delicious and crispy. Beer was cold!
I love their pizzas,The food is
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Deluxe Combination Calzone
We are traveling from Indiana. We have never had Rotolo's Pizza and thought it looked good. We ordered online. When I arrived to pick up our order of 2 small pizzas and an order of breadsticks they had made 2 of the same pizza. They said, "we will make it right." Problem was, they only remade one pizza. The other pizza and breadsticks were cold by the time the 2nd pizza was made. I mentioned it to one of the staff, saying the other pizza and breadsticks will be cold by the time the corrected pizza is made. To which she replies, "if that's the case we will make it right." Well, 8 minutes later the pizza was cooked and of course the 2nd pizza and breadsticks were cold. No one bothered to try to "make it right". Why would anyone think it's acceptable to only remake one pizza in this situation? The entire order should have been remade.Flavor was good considering more than half the order was cold.We were very disappointed to say the least and won't order from Rotolo's Pizzeria again.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Some of the best pizza anywhere. Crust is tender but crisp on the edges. It was loaded with toppings. Poboy bread is the best! Service is quick and the building is very nice.
The pizza is great. It's the dang calzone. I ordered the deluxe and when it arrived at the table the inside was cold to the touch like refrigerator cold. They took it back and I assume just heated it in microwave . It came back to the table and the toppings weren't cooked. I mean aren't the mushrooms and peppers supposed to be cooked? It was crispy raw is the only way I can explain it.. I've never experienced this with a calzone and had I known it was like this I would of never ordered it. Oh and couldn't even find the cheese inside. But hey the cheese sticks and pizza are amazing! Just beware of the deluxe combination calzone. I'll add that they did take it off the check. I just hate having to do that. I never like being that person. But then again I work hard for my money ?
Recommended dishes: Pizza
The food was good and fresh. It was a nice, calm atmosphere. The muffala wasn't as good as we remember, but it wasn't bad. The pizza and appetizer were perfect.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Muffuletta, Pizza
hadn't had a calzone in a long time,got the combination deluxe and it was fantastic,fresh ingredients and simply delicious ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Old Fashioned Root Beer Float, Muffuletta, Buffalo Wings, Side Salad, Pizza, Philly Cheesesteak, Meat Feast, Tomato Basil Soup, Spaghetti
We all went to eat at Rotolos today. 8-20-23 My first time there. They were busy. But the food was really good. Everyone that ate, really liked their food. A little on the pricey side. Atmosphere was ok. Waitress did a great job and moved as fast as she could! ! I would go back again and I would recommend this location on St. Charles street. ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Meat Feast
We all went to eat at Rotolos today. 8-20-23 My first time there. They were busy. But the food was really good. Everyone that ate, really liked their food. A little on the pricey side. Atmosphere was ok. Waitress did a great job and moved as fast as she could! ! I would go back again and I would recommend this location on St. Charles street.
Deluxe Combination 12” pizza was amazing, fresh and flavorful. Caesar salad was okay. Will
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Deluxe Combination 12” pizza was amazing, fresh and flavorful. Caesar salad was okay. Will
Restaurantji Recommends
A great place to eat, good food, good service...
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Philly Cheesesteak, Meat Feast, Spaghetti
This was the most awesome food service and employees were great. Also my husband lost $300 cash at our table he realized it after we left. Our waitress found it turned it in to her manager they got my name from my receipt I paid with my card looked me up on Facebook and informed me that they had our cash. We went and picked it up and we're so very grateful and very impressed with the honesty. The food was fantastic as well. Go there you won't regret it honestly!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mia was a great waitress, knows the menu very well .my wife had lasagne w/roll bites and I had a garden salad, wth walnuts and cranberry s added w/ ranch. This is a must stop if you like Italian food, and yes they have pizza! The bar section always enjoys a good LSU baseball game. Conventlely located on St. Charles stKid-friendliness: Good options for all ages (even for the kid inside us)Parking: Parking is amble shared with the other shops located thereWheelchair accessibility: They are compliment with accessiblity
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always a solid place to visit with great food. Anytime day or night is good time for one of their pies especially the non-traditional selection. And the Ricotta dip is amazing
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
meatballs appetizer is great! Pizza was delicious and crispy. Beer was cold!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5