facebook instagram facebook instagram

Star Tavern

$ • Pizza, Italian

Hours:
400 High St, City of Orange
(973) 675-3336

Take-Out/Delivery Options

Customers' Favorites

Star Tavern Reviews

4.4 (133)
Been a die hard customer for many years & still am BUT whether it be a long time customer or a new customer you always want your customers to return so when a customer calls and says the fried calamari is not edible and can't even be chewed nor squeezed by a man's hand because it's way overcooked and I also explained it was way to fishy...it's best if you offer your customer a credit for next time especially when eating out these days is not cheap. Instead we got 'Sorry, I'll...read full review

Excellent New Jersey version of thin crust tavern pizza. Very busy, popular and crowded Orange location. Good service, hard working wait staff. Best pies were the plain and meatball, sausage and pepperoni were okay but sausage was a bit bland. I would give a slight nod to Kinchleys, there rival to the North for their better sauce and spicier sausage and pepperoni. All in all as a pizza lover you won’t go wrong here.

They've been there for many many years. And I've been there many many times...my favorite dish is the broccoli cavatelli and of course, the pizza it's classic New York style. I've been going there for about 20 years. So come on down. Nice friendly staff and bring the family.

More Reviews(429)

Ratings

View all photos

Hours

Monday 11AM - 9PM
Tuesday 11AM - 10PM
Wednesday 11AM - 10PM
Thursday 11AM - 10PM
Friday 11AM - 10PM
Saturday 11AM - 10PM
Sunday 12 - 9PM
Updated on: