Papa John's Pizza

466 Central Ave, East Orange
(973) 678-7272

Recent Reviews


HORRIBLE! This place always sends my orders 2hours later I live 4 blocks away! They NEVER send special garlic with the pizza or sauce with the wings! I tried to order from West Orange and they send my order to this location! WORST STORE EVER!! They NEVERRRRRR get your order right or send it on time! Save yourself a headache


Ordered with a 27 min ETA. 1 hour 30min later delivery driver apparently hasn't even left the store.

Cassandra Harris

Good food... the chicken chipolet wings are on point & cheese sticks

Francine Finley

The service is TERRIBLE I've been there twice and it was HORRIBLE EACH TIME. There were at least 7 people working I phoned in an order and still had to wait at least 20 minutes I left with NO FOOD. One of the guys had a wine bottle in his back pocket and took a drink while I was there. I'M NEVER GOING THERE AGAIN!!!!

Fatyheera Bishop

PIZZA COLD & Nasty customer service is horrible. I will never order from them again.

#DjOyea Tv

There deals are good and pizza was delicuse.

Pluv M

They took my order, had me wait 2 hours for it, turns out they closed and went home without telling me anything. They also took the money from my card which i’ll have to dispute. The man taking my order was extremely rude as well. Avoid at all costs!!!


Delivers to wrong address and delay all the time

shawn powell

Delivery okay nice an hot fast delivery

Meghan Jean-Baptiste

Never ordering from here again. Received my pizza after a long wait and it was cold and stale. Unacceptable.

Monster 696

YOU CAN GET A BETTER PIZZA AND SERVES AT $1 PIZZA STORE!!!!! I made an order that said it would take 45 min to arrive. 1hr 15min later the tracking status changed to delivered. I contacted the store were they hung up on me the first time. I called again and a gentleman answered the phone who happened to be Next to the delivery driver who stated they rang my doorbell and no one answered. I proceeded to explain to him I have a ring camera and Iv been sitting by my window for the whole duration. The driver and the store worker then proceeded to call me a lier and pass the blame onto me. The store worker the way he began to speak to me is one of the most unprofessional manners Iv seen in my life. I am truly disappointed to be writing this review and will never be using the papa Johns service again.

Leo B

12 dollar pizza ends up being 17 and some change.. Y r they charging 4 dollars to deliver a pizza 2 blocks away.. And when i call i dont speak w someone onsight.

Jose Reyes

Don’t order from here. Always something wrong with the pizza. Whether it always comes cold. When you always order sauces and they never bring them. You call them and they always give you a nasty attitude. The toppings taste old and cold. It took a lot out of me to even write a review for papa johns and if I could I would rate them zero stars. Because that’s exactly what you are a zero establishment.

RIRI69 All Day

I've always received great service before and during this unfortunate time of the Covid Crisis.Thanks Papa John's for being essential to me and in my opinion The Community!

Michelle Quick

Worst manager & customer service ever at this location!! Rude!

Load More