11 Best American Restaurants in Hackettstown

James on Main New American • $$$
105 Main St, Hackettstown

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Cake
Tuna Poke
Calamari

“Best dining experience since we moved from Philadelphia to Sussex County 4 years ago, and we've had a number of fantastic ones in this region - but James on Main was the best all around by far. Their cuisine choices and their execution were top notch quality and consistency. The team is small and tight, it's like watching a ballet. Shawn (sp?) has mastered the wood fired oven like my German mother-in-law, John I think was the sauté station, Kelly operated a cold station and expedited, she appeared to be the glue holding the timing together, and Kat (or Cat?) was our delightful and professional (and very knowledgeable) server. The menu changes with various numbers of Pre Fixe courses - we went with 3 and added a share, a dessert, and a bottle of wine. The pictures will have to tell the story because it would be too much to write about... suffice to say, you won't find better around here.“

4.6 Superb63 Reviews
Panther Pub Pubs • $$
1591 County Rd 517, Hackettstown

Customers` Favorites

Beer Battered Fish and Chips
The Adult Happy Meal
Angus Burger
French Dip

“The clams in wine sauce were so salty it was insane. They hurt mine and my partners tongues. Otherwise the food was good. The teriyaki salmon was amazing!!!! We also had their winterberry sangria which tastes exactly how you think it would--the mulled cider was the standout of that drink. The pub is very small town Irish pub style. It was cute.“

4.4 Superb88 Reviews
BlackStone Bar & Grill Pizza • $$
86 US-46, Hackettstown

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Saltimbocca
Pumpkin Cheesecake
Mozzarella Sticks
Burger and Fries
Ribs
Steak
Wings

“This is the first time I've visited there and I was so pleasantly surprised at how very cozy and cute this beautiful restaurant is. You automatically feel comfortable just walking through the door. Quaintly decorated. Old school comfortable ? I love that feel!The food?? 10 Stars Excellent!!The drinks? Big and Excellent as well. Bathroom has a very comfortable charm.Very clean and a place you want to hang out in with friends or family all night. They do catering as well!I highly recommend this Awesome Restaurant!!“

4.5 Superb51 Reviews
Taphouse Grille Bar & Grill • $$
1930 NJ-57, Hackettstown

Customers` Favorites

Parmesan Truffle Fries
Pan Seared Swordfish
French Onion Burger
Mussels in Red Sauce
French Onion Soup
Bang Bang Shrimp
Taphouse Wings
Loaded Nachos
TG Burger
Beer Menu

“Our entrees were very good and the portions were just right. Our waiter was excellent and didn't check on us very 2 minutes., but was there for drink replenishment when required. My only complaint was the drink prices, thought $5.00 for Miller Lite was a little steep and will keep my future refills to a minimum.“

4.1 Good110 Reviews
Applebee's Grill + Bar American • $
225 Mountain Ave, Hackettstown

Customers` Favorites

Bourbon Street Chicken and Shrimp
Baby Back Ribs Ralf Rack
Whiskey Bacon Burger
BBQ Boneless Wings
Mozzarella Sticks
Steamed Broccoli
Chicken Tacos
Menu

“Loved the meal and environmentUnfortunately my meal was cut short when someone walked in with latex balloons.I am severely allergic to latex and had to vacate immediately. Left half meal andbucket beverage on the table.Please encourage patrons to celebrate with mylar balloons. I am not the only individual with a latex allergy.Thank you“

4.1 Good52 Reviews
Stella G's Brunch • $$
186 Main St, Hackettstown

Customers` Favorites

Avocado Toast and Soft Boiled Eggs
Eggs Benedict with Green Tomatoes
Breakfast Tacos

“Went with 4 people - not too many 4-tops. I’m guessing it’s mostly 1-2 tops on purpose. Short wait for a table but VERY much worth it. Food was delicious. I had a basic Bacon & Cheese but my friend had the breakfast tacos and said they were also delicious :)“

4.1 Good42 Reviews
River Star Diner Diner • $
14 NJ-57, Hackettstown

Customers` Favorites

Fried Onion Rings
Grilled Cheese
Eggs Benedict
Gyro Platter
French Fries
Turkey Club
French Toast
Home Fries
Disco Fries
Pancakes

“My family came for the grand opening ! The new owners cook amazing! You can get Mexican like nothing I have ever had , right down to diner classics like melts , burgers and eggs . I tried something I’ve never had . It was Stir fried veggies with orange chicken and I’m so excited I have enough for lunch tomorrow lol thank you for bringing something great to this town ☺️“

4 Good66 Reviews
Marley's Gotham Grill Bar • $$
169 Main St, Hackettstown

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Parmesan Wings
French Onion Soup
Wednesday Night
Burger and Fries
Fried Pickles
Honey Mustard
Texas Burger
Chicken Wing
Burgers
Marley

“Had the wings and only 2 flavors, so I'll need to go back another 298 more time to try the rest of the flavors. The wings were great and huge(lots of meat) , the service was even better... Always checking if we needed anything and bringing more napkins and beers. I could not be any happier.“

3.9 Good329 Reviews
Friendly's American • $
304 Mountain Ave, Hackettstown

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Fingers with Fries
Quarter Pound Cheeseburger
Mini Mozzarella Sticks
Crispy Chicken Salad
Bacon Cheeseburger
Ice Cream Sundaes
Fish and Fries
Hamburger
Sandwich

“Friendly's used to always be packed. Nowadays the parking lot is always empty. I wanted their ice cream so we stopped there and had dinner too. The service was great. There were about 20 people there. Service was fast. The food was great and hot.“

3.7 Good55 Reviews
Marley's Wings and Things Bar • $$
171 Main St, Hackettstown

“After a morning out and after adventuring, I was all the way out in Hackettstown and in need of some solid bar food. I found Marley's via my trusty fellow yelpers and was so glad that I made the effort to pop in. I was immediately sat at a high-top close to the bar, and got water quickly. Their menu had an expansive list of your typical bar foods, but I got the potato skins (YUM) and their buffalo chicken salad. That thing was humongous and delicious. Everything about the food here I had was solid and hit the spot. While their customer service could be a bit more attentive, because it was hard to flag people down to extra things as you needed it, everything else was fine from the quality of the food, the speed of service, cleanliness, etc. This place is solid and the portion of the food was stunning. I'd recommend this place to anyone popping in for a quick snack/eat or needing a drink/bar food.“

3.7 Good125 Reviews
Taste of Italy Ristorante & Pizzeria Italian • $$
57 US-46 E, Hackettstown

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmigiana
Plain Pizza
Italian
Sauce
Salad

“My wife and I sampled a variety of dishes to help us determine what to order for an upcoming catering event. Everything we tried was delicious. The Eggplant Rollatini was outstanding, the best we've ever had. The Chicken Marsala, Penne Vodka, Cavatelli with Broccoli, and Sausage and Peppers were equally as delicious, as was their homemade Caesar dressing. The Taste of Italy is probably the best Italian restaurant in the area. My wife and I go there often.“

3.5 Good51 Reviews
Loading...
map Map