7 Best Italian Restaurants in Hackettstown

Mama's Cafe Baci Italian • $$
260 Mountain Ave, Hackettstown

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmigiana with Spaghetti
Mozzarella Sticks Fried Ravioli
Gluten Free Calamari Italiano
Gluten Free Pizza
Vegan Vodka Pizza
Lobster Ravioli
Chicken Marsala
Seafood Misto
Moresca Salad
Vegan Cannoli

“This is the best restaurant I have ever been to in my entire life. They really do treat you like family and are absolutely amazing all around. Then the food. Oh, the food is just to die for! I live in Cincinnati and only get this when I travel here for my grooming show/competition yearly. If I could travel here more or move here for just this place, I would. I got to sit at the bar this last time, and the gentlemen I met and my waitresses treated me wonderfully. I got the 4-seasons pizza which gave me more choices in one pizza. Highly recommend!“

4.7 Superb128 Reviews
Pasta Grill Mansfield Italian • $$
3470 1916, 1916 NJ-57, Hackettstown

Customers` Favorites

Blackened Chicken Alfredo
Steak & Avocado Salad
Eggplant Rollatini
Steak Avocado Salad
Chicken Francese
Blackened Salmon
Chicken Marsala
Pepperoni Pizza
Italian Nachos
Caprese Salad

“I have dined here for many years and thought the food was equal to surrounding places. This past year they have kicked it up a notch by revising the menu and creating special occasion experiences. The specialty cocktails are amazing and specialty menu items unique and delicious.I dined on the Lobster stuffed Agnolotti with champagne blush sauce, Excellent! The Love Potion cocktail was quite yummy as well.Look for those special occasion nights and give it a try, you won’t be disappointed.“

4.8 Superb70 Reviews
Toscana Trattoria Ristorante Italiano Italian • $$
223 Main St, Hackettstown

Customers` Favorites

Branzino with Spinach Tomatoes Artichokes and Capers in a Light White Wine Butter Sauce
Steak of the Day - 16oz Porterhouse
Homemade Angus Beef Meatballs
Lemoncello Marscapone Cake
Crème Brûlée Cheesecake
Eggplant Parmigiano
Pasta Fagioli Soup
Lasagna Bolognese
Chicken Milanese
Homemade Ravioli

“Came here with my family for a goodbye dinner, and I have to say it was quite cozy and cute inside. They are a BYOB restaurant, so we brought our own wine and our waiter opened and poured it for us throughout the visit making sure our glasses were always full. I strongly suggest they type up the specials for people to read and to view prices. The waiter told us the specials from memory; so of course, all three of us had questions to ask and the waiter was getting angry that we couldn’t remember all of what he just said. After we order, we receive these absolutely delicious breadsticks and they were gracious enough to bring out seconds! I ordered the meatballs as an appetizer, I thought they were really tasty and juicy! I ordered the Chicken Milanese as my entree. I thought the chicken was a bit dry and super thin, it definitely looked like a large piece of chicken but was very deceiving. I was very excited for dessert because I was told by the lady that everything was homemade. I also work in the restaurant industry; I recognized 3 of the desserts right away being from a restaurant company. She then told me that the Tiramisu was a family recipe of theirs and let me say this, it is a must try for sure. Tiramisu is a favorite of mine and it did not disappoint! The lady also sold me on ordering her cappuccino because she makes them really good; it was good and extra foamy. Overall, it was a nice experience. However, I don’t think I will be coming back anytime soon due to the prices. If I knew 3 meatballs were going to be $19 I would have skipped it. Same for some of the other dishes, especially on the specials menu. I get they are going for a more upscale feel but having your waiter and waitress sit a table away from you eating and talking with other workers doesn’t really give off that vibe.“

4.7 Superb71 Reviews
Davila's Pizza and Catering Pizza • $
190 Main St, Hackettstown

Customers` Favorites

Mozzarella Sticks
Garlic Knots
Garlic Bread
Plain Cheese
Plain Pizza
Meatball
Roll

“Lived here over 5 years and never checked this place out. My daughter and I went for a quick bite tonight. The pizza was delicious! And everyone was so warm and friendly! I'm from NY and I'm picky about my pizza! Definitely go check them out!!“

4.8 Superb49 Reviews
Frank's Pizza (Mansfield) Pizza • $
1885 NJ-57, Hackettstown

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Salad
Plain Cheese Pizza
Meatball Sandwich
Slice of Pizza
Sausage

“Frank's is our favorite pizza place in the area. We have lived around here for 20+ years and have tried others but Frank's rose to the top and has stayed there. Our kids now live away from the area and whenever they are back one of our meals has to be Frank's! Great pizza! Favorites are the Tammy's Special and their BLT Pizza, but the plain cheese, pepperoni, or sausage are always a hit too. Some of my kids LOVE the Buffalo Chicken Pizza. Service has always been good... great for sit down/dine in or take out. One of my sons just tried the gluten free pizza and thought it was really good too. Their sandwiches (chicken parm, meatball, california chicken) are great too.Dietary restrictions: Son just tried their gluten free pizza and thought it was really good.“

4 Good46 Reviews
Frank's Pizza (Mt. Olive) Pizza • $
7 Naughright Rd, Hackettstown

Customers` Favorites

Antipasto
Zeppoles

“I ? their pizza, always perfect. Garlic knots, Zeppoles, meatballs are fresh and service with a smile. It's always clean. ????Vegetarian options: Although I am not a Vegetarian there are plenty of suitable options on the menu to accommodate.Kid-friendliness: Frank's has always been kid friendly. High chairs if needed and employees ? to see them as well.Parking: Definitely plenty. Easily accessible.Wheelchair accessibility: There's a good sized lip in sidewalk for any wheelchair. It appears to be very safe access for anyone.“

4 Good25 Reviews
Sonny's Pizza II Pizza • $
915 County Rd 517, Hackettstown

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmigiana
Pepperoni Pizza
Cinnabon Pizza
Sicilian Pizza
Slice of Pizza
Nutella Bites
Stuffed Pizza
French Fries
Garlic Knots
Cheese Pizza

“This was the best meal of our lives. Picture this - three starving girls. We haven’t eaten in approximately 5 hours. So we were HANGRY. We ordered a large plain pie, buffalo wings, and the delectable garlic bread. Words cannot describe how absolutely delicious this meal was. We were RAVENOUS. We inhaled the food within 10 minutes and left three slices for later. The wings were juicy, the sauce was FANTASTIC - the perfect amount of spice. Do NOT get me started on the garlic bread. I swear i entered heaven with my first bite. The pizza left me SPEECHLESS, i haven’t felt this happy in so long. We literally could not speak as we devoured the food like starving street rats. All we could do was nod our heads, say “mmmhmm” and “yup”. This was a religious experience, especially during this holy time of the year. I would recommend this fine establishment to anyone. I would more than reccomend. I want to go outside, and get on the roof, and scream “GO TO SONNYS” to the surrounding area. Thank you to our kind delivery man who told us to enjoy - we enjoyed it more than they could ever know.“

3.9 Good24 Reviews
Loading...
map Map