“I really don’t understand a bad review for Jersey Mike’s. Sure, it’s a little pricier than some but the quality is very high - and consistent! I’ve been to a lot of them from Point Pleasant to Pennsylvania. Hackettstown is no different. And they’re usually super-friendly. My “go-to” sandwich is the Stickball Special. It’s an Italian ham & cheese plus salami. Yum.“
“I ordered the large Italian sandwich platter from Primo Hoagies for my New Year's Day party.The sandwiches were neatly cut and stacked.We had the roast beef and cheese, turkey and cheese. The stand out sandwich, for me, was Nonna's veggie sandwich! It was so delicious with the breaded eggplant, sharp provolone,broccoli rabe and the winning layer of roasted pepper on top! Along with the sandwiches, I was given some small squeeze bottles of oil and vinegar, and a bowl of various peppers and onions for my guests to flavor their sandwiches to their liking. I highly recommend this business for your catering needs!“
“I just love this place! I always get my bacon egg and cheeses from there and they always make it so special. The older couple inside are super sweet and nice, it feels like walking into grandmas house! 10/10 recommend this place and make sure you bring cash!“
“This was definitely the best jersey mikes I have been to. Friendly people, the manager was very nice and I didn't have to wait for my food. I ordered it less than 15mins before walking in. I expected to have to wait for it but they were just finishing it up as I walked in. Not only that, the biggest thing to me is store cleanliness. There store looked very clean and well takes care of. I highly recommend this particular location.“
“Though I'm a Jersey Shore resident, I grew up in the Long Valley/Chester area and have visited The Sub Pub for years. Their venue is clean and they never fail to provide good sandwiches and service. Always an enjoyable stop on my journeys back home. Highly recommended!“
“Great Jersey Mikes , subs are fantastic always hits the spot!But not only that I would like to thank Tim and staff for being so welcoming and accommodating. to my 16 year old special needs son Nathaniel , he goes there often lately in the afternoon after school , his experience is nothing but wonderful , not to mention all there subs are delicious ,Thank you so muchJohn Grasso“
“I finally stopped in after passing this place about a million times. I got the Hill Climber and it was awesome. I love the Russian Dressing, it was the perfect balance of creamy and tangy. The bread was fresh old-school style Italian bread, exactly what a good sub needs. Service was fast and friendly. Will definitely be back.“