8 Best Italian Restaurants near Middletown

Toscanella Village Cafe Pizza • $$
102 Kings Hwy, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

WH Specias Cheese Steak
Penne Bolognese
Chicken Marsala
Sicilian Pizza
Eggplant Parm
Penne Vodka
Greek Salad

“This place is really one of the best around. I’ve had a few different dinners here and everything has been delicious. The service is always excellent; they’re consistently one of the best. If you haven’t been, it’s worth checking out. We’ve become regulars.“

4.6 Superb60 Reviews
Zoni's Brooklyn Brick Coal Oven Pizzeria Pizza • $
287 NJ-35, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Margherita Pizza
Coal Fired Wings
Pizza Margarita
Fried Calamari
Chicken Wings
Americana
Meatball
Personal
Sausage
Stefano

“This was our second time at Zoni’s and everything was delicious. We had the coal fired wings which come with a delicious homemade Gorgonzola cheese sauce and the Camilla pizza. The first time we had the Stefano pizza. The staff is so kind, the owner personally came to our table and insisted we try the Margherita pie, he gave us one on the house. Thank you guys! We know we will be coming back soon!“

4.6 Superb55 Reviews
Lubranos 36 Italian • $$
26 NJ-36, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Raspberry Field Green Salad
Eggplant Parmigiana
Shrimp Franchese
Margherita Pizza
Veal Saltimbocca
Fried Calamari

“This was our first time there. The place is nice and so was the staff. Our waitress was very good. They give you hot bread when you sit down. I had spaghetti and meatballs. It was good and I loved the meatballs. You get 2 good size ones. My boyfriend had the linguine with white clam sauce. He enjoyed it! We will definitely be going back there again!! Thanks!! Cathy“

4.6 Superb40 Reviews
Nana's Kitchen Italian • $$$
1686 NJ-35, Fountain Ridge Plaza, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Seared Sea Scallops Pancetta Cannellini Beans
Fresh Pappardelle Braised Short Rib Ragu
Veal Chop Milanese
Stuffed Mushrooms
Linguine & Clams
Grilled Octopus

“Beautiful room and attentive service. Food was delicious, but my only complaint would be that the Zuppa I ordered was supposed to include scallops. They apparently didn't have them or had run out that night (although it wasn't extremely busy) and without informing me, they just substituted some salmon- not exactly an even swap! I should have been told they didn't have a key component of the dish, so I could opt for another entree. It was good, but the idea it was advertised as containing scallops was a deciding factor in choosing that particular dish.“

4.3 Superb50 Reviews
Aleo Italian Specialties Caterers • $$
642C Newman Springs Rd, Lincroft

“I experienced Aleos when they catered my company's holiday party a few weeks ago...... and I was hooked! And I am VERY picky with my Italian food. I just had to try it again, and decided for the first time in 20 years, to have someone else (Aleos) cater for my family on Christmas Day. They did not disappoint. Not only was their pick-up on Christmas Eve completely seamless, during the drive up, I encountered someone named Christine who was just so kind and outgoing. Her customer service, along with the great tasting food, went beyond anything I could ever imagine. THANK YOU Aleos for making my 2023 Christmas stress-free, and THANK YOU Christine for being so awesome!“

4 Good33 Reviews
Naples Pizzeria Pizza • $
872 Main St, Belford

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmigiana over Spaghetti
Grille Asparagus Salad Special
Stuffed Flounder
Buffalo Chicken
Coconut Shrimp
Vegetable Wrap
Grandma Pie

“Best pizza shop in Middletown. The pizza is very good. Been going there since I was a kid. The prices are also very affordable. It's BYOB for dine in. The staff is always friendly. Highly recommend.Wheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair accessible“

3.9 Good35 Reviews
Attilio's Villagio Restaurant & Pizzeria Pizza • $$
608 Newman Springs Rd, Lincroft

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmigiana
Seafood Risotto
Pepperoni Pizza
White Pizza
Subs

“The pizza is par for the shore. The people are all locals, which I appreciate. Keeping the business local is important. The decor is fully Italian, old country. Small place, good atmosphere whether you're looking for quick pizza by the slice or in the back for a sit-down restaurant meal. Not the cheapest prices, but also not cheapest made.“

3.8 Good48 Reviews
Pasquale's Pizzeria III Pizza • $
147 Cherry Tree Farm Rd, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Knots
Vegan Pizza

“We’ve been ordering take out and delivery from Pasquale’s for years. They have a vast and delicious vegan menu, ranging from pizzas to apps to dinners. Everything we’ve had from here, both vegan and not, is a winner. Easy to order online through the Toast app. Pick up is quick, although sometimes their quoted pick up times have been 15-20 min off. Delivery is always speedy!“

3.6 Good21 Reviews
Loading...
map Map