facebook instagram facebook instagram

Jersey Mike's Subs

$ • Sandwich Shops, Fast Food

Hours:
1260 Springfield Ave, New Providence
(908) 665-0610

Take-Out/Delivery Options

Customers' Favorites

Jersey Mike's Subs Reviews

2.6 (25)

Absolute rockstar team under pressure! The customer service team today was efficient and courteous regardless of some of the hangry customers.I ordered on the mobile app ahead of time, and even if it's 20 minutes over the expected time this visit, I don't mind--their quality is excellent. Plus, it's the lunch rush, it's what you expect from a place in high demand.We've been coming here for the last few months for my dad's favorite giant sub--it's worth the wait.

Everytime I go there’s at least 5 orders being prepped or waiting. The one guy who is running the show and making sandwiches always seems overwhelmed. Everytime he makes mistakes on my sandwiches. Wrong cheese. Wrong bread. But honestly it’s hardly his fault. They need more staff. But also they need more accuracy because with legit Italian subs just a few doors down, I’m about ready to give up on this branch after this 4th time I’ve had an issue with my order.

I'm a big fan of the franchise, especially in N. California where they just can't seem to get an east coast sub right. I always know I can get a consistent sandwich that reminds me of NJ (where I grew up). However, in New Providence, where most delis get it right, Jersey Mikes is "just another" sandwich joint. My complaint is the lack of meat and the price. A one minute walk to Avenue Deli gets you the same quality sandwich with double the meat and way cheaper price. For this...read full review

More Reviews(102)

Ratings

View all photos

Hours

Monday 10AM - 8PM
Tuesday 10AM - 8PM
Wednesday 10AM - 8PM
Thursday 10AM - 8PM
Friday 10AM - 8PM
Saturday 10AM - 8PM
Sunday 10AM - 8PM
Updated on: