10 Best Italian Restaurants in Rutherford

Suprema Italian • $$
92 Park Ave, Rutherford

Customers` Favorites

Vodka Chicken Parm
Arancini Rice Balls
Chicken Parmigiana
Chicken Milanese
Milano Sandwich
Veal Parmigiana
Artichoke Salad
Caprese
Tiramisu

“Hello my Foodies! So I was at this place for my friends Birthday. They have real food meaning made fresh and organic. I could tell it tasted so Different from the processed food I am used to I guess. Everything tasted fresh, and it did take me a minute to get into this food, but after a bit, I really did like my pasta. The chocolate dessert we got after was absolutely delicious. The pasta I had tasted great the next day. Also, that Steaz drink was delicious! Order it! Our server was excellent and took great care of our party. I did hear another server tell a young couple who came in around 8pm that they couldn't seat them because the kitchen closed at 730pm. I thought that was kinda early, especially since their operating hours say until 9 pm. But maybe because it was a Wednesday? I'm not sure. They don't have parking so you need to find parking in the street, but it was really good food. I recommend checking this place out.“

4.6 Superb266 Reviews
Fiorentini Restaurant Italian • $$
98 Park Ave, Rutherford

Customers` Favorites

Handmade Short Ribs Agnolotti
Cacio E Pepe with Mussels
Octopus Appetizer
Gnocchi Stuffed
Grilled Octopus
Salami Board
Risotto
Truffle
Tiramisu

“We experienced great service at this farm to table brunch spot. Everything we ordered was delicious. We will certainly be back for dinner. We loved the classy garden interior decor. This restaurant takes reservations. Parking is street parking, thus it is sometimes hard to find.“

4.5 Superb102 Reviews
Ferazzoli's italian kitchen Pizza • $$
317 Union Ave, Rutherford

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Slice of Pizza
Garlic Knots
Buffalo Wings
Cheese Pizza
Grandma Pie
Sandwiches
Italian
Salad
Sauce

“We're in town for a short trip with our son on his school break. Our hotel recommended this place for delivery, and I checked reviews myself. The reviews looked pretty good, so I had high hopes. My husband got a Calzone which he said was delicious. My son & I had their pizza which I felt had way too many toppings. In their defense they don't offer a "Supreme" style pizza on their menu. So when I asked for one the guy on the phone said they'd make a veggie pizza but add meats. The abundance of toppings made the pizza a bit soggy and heavy. However I'm still giving 4 stars because you could tell these guys do know how to make pizza. The crust and sauce were delicious. If we're ever back in the area and want pizza I'd give them another shot but with way less toppings. I think it would be delicious. Hard to give a solid rating as it was my 1st and only experience. But worth a try for sure!“

4.7 Superb73 Reviews
Volares Italian • $$
7 Station Square, Rutherford

Customers` Favorites

Carpaccio Di Manzo with Arugula Capers Sliced Provolone Lemon Evvo with a Touch of Truffle
Breaded Veal with Truffle Cream Sauce
Tortellini in a White Vodka Sauce
Mussels in Garlic Wine Sauce
Spaghetti Ai Frutti Di Mare
Hot Antipasto Misto for Two
Mussels Bianco O Rosso
Chocolate Mousse Cake
Mussels in White Sauce
Linguine with Clams

“I don’t write reviews but I had to take the time and write how amazing Volares restaurant is! love this place so much. Every food item I have tried has exceeded my expectations greatly. The food is amazing, and even the place itself. It’s very clean, it’s super authentic and very pleasant staff.I will be returning for sure!“

4.2 Good51 Reviews
Steven's Cafe Cafe •
106 Park Ave, Rutherford

Customers` Favorites

Ham Cheese Croissant
Almond Croissant
Garden Omelette
Avocado Toast
Rutherford
New Yorker
Avocado

“I've gotten pastries many times from Steven's and they are always great. Bagels are pretty good too. The coffee is the only reason for not giving five stars; it's fine but not why I go there. Service is always really good and the staff very nice.“

4.2 Good92 Reviews
Song E Napule - Rutherford Pizza • $$
106 Park Ave, Rutherford

Customers` Favorites

Polpo Alla Luciana
Margherita Pizza
Polpette Al Sugo
Delizia Al Limone
Calamari Fritti
Fried Calzone
Italian Bread
Napoletana
Tiramisu
Bufalina

“Great place right on Park Ave. Pizza is amazing but I would recommend you also try the salads. During summer you can also seat outside. Remember that like most places in Rutherford this is BYOB (there is a liquor store store right across the street).“

4.2 Good168 Reviews
Mama Rosa Pizza and Pasta Pizza • $
332 Union Ave, Rutherford

Customers` Favorites

Personal Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Sauce

“Great food great soups great prices specially for the Rutherford area.... highly recommendI ordered a gluten-free pizza a little extra cheese a little extra sauce... Best gluten-free pizza I ever had... And again I highly recommend Mama Rosa pizzaA great chicken salad with so much chicken you could've made 2 dinners out of it...10 stars....“

3.9 Good42 Reviews
The Risotto House Italian • $$
88 Park Ave, Rutherford

Customers` Favorites

Mushroom Asparagus Risotto
Risotto Primavera
Stuffed Mushrooms
Chicken Francese
Fried Calamari
Burrata Salad
Seafood Salad
Chicken Parm
Cesar Salad
Bruschetta

“Hello my foodies. I went here with my coworkers to celebrate our company Xmas dinner in Jan! Better late than never. My friend recommended this place and it was a good place. It's small, but well lit and very friendly atmosphere. The owners daughter was our host and server along with some other very nice staff. It was a Wednesday so it was very quiet in the restaurant. Probably one of their slower days, but we were fine without the crowds. Everything we ordered was great, except the pasta fagoli soup I had. It wasn't terrible, but the broth had no flavor. I still ate it, though, because my Dr. says to cut back on the salt anyway. It was still passable! Everything else was great, and they even let you BYOB, and they let us bring in a small cake. My friends wanted to re-do my birthday cake since the last place I went to was awful! I'll update you on that place in a moment! I had the penne vodka with chicken. I love penne vodka, but I find it hard to find a place that makes it good. This place made it very well. Delicious! I recommend this place as they have a great variety of items to choose from, true Italian style dishes. We had a wonderful time here. And it's not bad on your pocketbook either. If you're in the area, stop by and check it out. Parking is on the street. Meters are done by 7pm.“

4 Good180 Reviews
Chris' Pizza & Family Restaurant (Rutherford, NJ) Family • $
200 Park Ave, Rutherford

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Gluten Free Pizza
Garlic Fries
Garlic Bread
Garlic Knots
Veggie Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Italian Sub
Wrap

“I ordered the Grandma Pizza, which they can make square or round. I got the square one. It was tasty, and the service was friendly.Parking: There is street parking with meters, and a Walgreens lot next door in a pinch if you are taking out.Wheelchair accessibility: It is street level, so it's accessible.“

3.9 Good139 Reviews
Paisano's Italian • $$
132 Park Ave, Rutherford

Customers` Favorites

Oxtail Ragu & Burrata
Pappardelle Bolognese
Braised Beef Ravioli
Chocolate Lava Cake
Spaghetti Carbonara
Pappadelle Paisano
Seafood Malafemina
Stuffed Pork Chop
Ricotta Gnocchi
Lobster Ravioli

“Amazing night at Paisano’s for my wife’s birthday. Steve was our server and was attentive and accommodating, especially with menu selection and food allergies. Food was excellent, probably best dinner we have ever had out. Highly recommend this restaurant to anyone in the East Rutherford area! Thank you to entire staff, job WELL done!Dietary restrictions: Extremely accommodating and confident my allergies were prioritized.“

3.8 Good109 Reviews
Loading...

Discover More Cuisines In Rutherford

map Map