“The BEST grandma pizza pie around!! Living on the EB/ Milltown border I drive though two towns (EB& South River)& over the bridge into Sayreville past at least a dozen pizza joints. I even bought a Pizza Hut delivery insulated bag just to keep the pizza hot on the long drive back home.It’s worth it! The staff &owner are super nice & friendly (not fake) & know me by name. Then again, I’m the only dork walking in there with a Pizza Hut bag.?We used to dine in too & the food was always excellent.easy 5 star“
“Stopped here for dinner before a show at the Starland Ballroom. Plenty of parking and a ton of tables. Has an old-school Italian feel to it. Huge menu with a lot of classic dishes. Served warm bread before the meal with the option of olive oil and butter. They had a peach sangria special that was excellent. I tried the lobster raviolis and was pleasantly surprised. These weren’t your typical store bought pre-frozen raviolis. No sir. Fresh made and stuffed with lobster. The chicken Murphy was enough for two people! Amazing. Rest assured, next time I’m at the Starland I will be stopping back here before the show.“
“I live in the general area and drive by here all the time and when it pops up in GrubHub, I always want to try it but are usually ordering another kind of cuisine. However, this evening we finally did try it...and the only thing we are upset about is that we didn't try this place much sooner! ? We ordered a plain pie with extra cheese...big hot! Hot, fresh, and delicious with a lovely sauce. The buffalo wings were very tasty! We also ordered the grilled steak salad, which was fresh and flavorful, and the shrimp alla vodka...awesome vodka sauce! We will definitely be ordering again!“
“We ordered delivery, and if I had an Italian grandmother, she just sent me her best food. Everything we ordered was delicious- pizza, spaghetti, salad, bread. They even included some paper plates and utensils (since we didn’t have any at our location), though we didn’t think to ask for them. The portions were so large that we barely made a dent in them. I’ll gladly be eating spaghetti for the rest of the week!“
“REAL Amazing Italian Food. The owner sal is great and a good guy. He cares about his customers. Any time i’ve had a delivery it arrives hot and fresh. Sometimes i stop in for a chicken parm sub. Couldn’t say enough good things about Angelos. A good family environment too. my kids loved looking at the fish tank. The young girl Alexis who works there is awesome. Always nice to everyone. i highly recommend Angelos Pizza food and service.“
“I honestly walked 4.6 miles one way then back from where my semi was parked,but the place which i walked for was closed,so I went here since it was 2 doors down and I am happy that I did,Food was great,I was kind of in rush because I had to walk almost 5 miles back but I will def go back when I am around.I had a slice which was 10/10 in my opinion and a shrimp California sub.“
“Tavern pie is outstanding!Edit: I came back years later to update this review because I believe this information shouldn't be squandered by residents of the area. Seriously, the Tavern Pie is the best pizza I've ever had. Full stop. The garlic knot sliders are, also top-tier. However, the most important takeaway here is the Taven Pie is quite possibly the best pizza ever made on the planet. Thank you.“
“I'm going to be honest ... for many years I've seen this place but I never gone there until my mom told me about how amazing the food is ,so I tried the food and I agree it's simply amazing I just wish I tried them sooner !!! Anyway I highly recommend Santino 's pizza !!“
“Eggplant parm is excellent. I’m very picky when it comes to eggplant. Many times it’s tough or stringy when I’ve ordered it elsewhere, but it has always been excellent here. The dining room is decorated very nicely. Service was great. Very satisfied.“
“Celebrated my daughter's birthday with 15 of her friends. The staff were so nice, they helped us pick a few items that were served family style. They even made a Nutella pizza for her so we could sing happy birthday. What a wonderful place. The food was delicious. We will definitely return.“