16 Best Mexican Restaurants in Toms River

Uncover Toms River's Mexican dining scene with Restaurantji's insights.

El Familiar Mexican • $$
1246 NJ-166, Toms River

Customers` Favorites

Steak Poblano Bistec A la Tampiqueña
Country Platter Bandeja Paisa
Three Ground Beef Tacos
Pastel de Tres Leches
Chicken Fajitas
Chicken Burrito
Salsa and Chips
Chimichangas
Guacamole
Burritos

“I've eaten here with my family many times but this is my first time posting about it. The food is phenomenal. For reference, I'm used to the cuisine from the San Diego area where I'm from and this is definitely a close competitor to the authenticity. We will be coming back here for the foreseeable future.“

4.4 Superb68 Reviews
Margaritas Mexican Restaurant Mexican • $$
270 NJ-37, Toms River

Customers` Favorites

Roasted Vegetable Zarape
Guadalajara Steak Fajita
Quesadilla Extravaganza
Loaded Skillet Nachos
Enchiladas Rancheras
Mexican Street Corn
Chicken Baby Chimis
Fresh Made Guacamole
Chicken Chimichanga
Chocolate Lava Cake

“Nice place for Mexican food. Nice large bar. Not really a traditional Mexican restaurant. Free chips are good at first but eventually have a weird metallic aftertaste, in my personal opinion. I was told it gets crowded on the weekends, but I can't confirm this. Not a bad place. Give it a try.“

4.2 Good121 Reviews
Ortega's Mexican Bakery & Restaurant Mexican • $
1822 Hooper Ave, Toms River

“West coast in the east coast, food had great authentic flavor and same goes for the salsas. Had an Agua de Jamaica and it was real flor de Jamaica, not the fake powder kind. TV was playing music videos, too loud for the size of space but , didn't bother me, I like Corridos. Def will come back to this place. They also make fresh pan dulce.“

4.5 Superb33 Reviews
Mark's Deli Deli • $
505 Coolidge Ave, Toms River

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Fingers
Cheese Burger
Al Pastor
Gyro

“I always get their cheese steaks with peppers and onions. Soo good! My only complaints, they close so early! They close at 3:00 and i would love to order dinner for my family at times. I went there 3/10/24 @4:15 pm and they were already closed. They would make a killing if open for dinner until at least 5:30 -6:00 pm. Also, would be fantastic if they delivered, such as via Grub Hub or Uber Eats etc.. Other than those 2 complaints, I LOVE the food and the staff!! Highly recommend ?“

4.5 Superb31 Reviews
Guadalupana Mexican Restaurant Mexican • $
1012 Cox Cro Rd, Toms River

Customers` Favorites

Pollo Asado Tacos
Torta de Jamon
Steak Fajita
Or Steak
Nachos

“Guadalupana Mexican Restaurant in New York is a true hidden gem that left me utterly enchanted with their flavorful caldos! Nestled in a vibrant neighborhood, this restaurant boasts an ambiance that embraces the spirit of Mexico.Now, let's talk about the caldos; they are an absolute delight! Guadalupana Mexican Restaurant offers a tantalizing variety of these soul-warming soups, each simmered to perfection with a delightful blend of spices and fresh ingredients. From the hearty Pozole to the savory Menudo, every caldo was a celebration of authentic Mexican flavors that warmed my heart and satisfied my cravings.But what made my dining experience truly memorable was our waitress, Maria. Her warm and friendly demeanor instantly made us feel like cherished guests. Maria's knowledge of the menu was commendable, and she guided us through the caldo options, recommending some hidden gems that quickly became our favorites.As we savored our caldos, it became evident that Guadalupana Mexican Restaurant was not just another Mexican eatery; it was a culinary haven that celebrated the rich traditions of Mexican cooking. The dedication of the kitchen to deliver authentic flavors was evident in every spoonful.The interior of the restaurant exuded a charming Mexican vibe, with colorful decor and cozy seating creating an inviting atmosphere. It felt like a place where families gathered to share heartwarming meals and create cherished memories.For anyone seeking an authentic Mexican dining experience in New York, Guadalupana Mexican Restaurant is a must-visit. The flavorful caldos, the exceptional service from waitresses like Maria, and the warm ambiance make it a dining destination that stands out from the rest. Whether you're a Mexican food enthusiast or simply someone in search of a delightful culinary adventure, Guadalupana Mexican Restaurant will leave you with a satisfied palate and a longing to return for more.“

4.5 Superb24 Reviews
Tacoholics Mexican • $
1922 Hooper Ave, Toms River

Customers` Favorites

Kids Quesadilla with Chips & Juice
Honey Chipotle Chicken
Coconut Shrimp Tacos
Bang Shrimp Tacos
Tacos Includes
Chicken Tacos
Corn Salsa
Guacamole
Burrito
Nachos

“I brought my 12yo here. Each of us being on the Autism Spectrum, we were SO excited that there's minimal human interaction lol They have 2 wide tablets where you can see pictures and places your order. There are menu screens over head as well. A young man came out to greet us and to let us know that if we have any questions or concerns that he's just right on the other side of the wall. Freakin Perfect.I obsessed over the wicked resin flooring. So cool!! Ok the food. We each got a trio of different tacos as well as the jalapeno poppers. I am SOOOOOO selective when it comes to tacos. I love both authentic Mexican style as well as crunchy American style. I found Tacoholics to be a fusion. Me and my kid enjoyed our food. We also enjoyed not having to do awkward small talk with a server.We will most definitely be back!!“

4.2 Good54 Reviews
Taco-Tastic Mexican • $$
793 Fischer Blvd, Toms River

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Tostadas
Chips and Salsa
Chicken Burrito
Chicken Tacos
Mexican Tacos
Birria Tacos
Chorizo Bowl
Burrito Bowl
Shrimp Tacos
Al Pastor

“Taco Tastic isn't just a name, it is the truth. The food is superb Mexican style take out and easily accessible on the road, parking can be right on busy nights but well worth it. Best in The area so far and way above the chain stores or boardwalk prices.“

4.1 Good59 Reviews
La Cazuela de Doña Mary Mexican • $
815 Hooper Ave, Toms River

Customers` Favorites

Bistec Ala Mexicana
Tacos Al Pastor
Guacamole
Fajita
Salsa
Taco

“Talk about kicking ourselves! My husband and I live right by La Cazuela de Doña Mary and drive past it all the time. Finally decided to try it, and let me tell you, HUGE mistake waiting so long!We have been craving authentic Mexican after our recent trip, and everything we ordered absolutely hit the spot. The chilaquiles brought back memories of delicious breakfasts south of the border. The friendly service was the icing on the cake – attentive and helpful, they made us feel right at home. We can't wait to return and explore more of their menu!“

4.1 Good48 Reviews
Bubbakoo's Burritos Mexican • $
888 Fischer Blvd, Toms River

Customers` Favorites

Chipotle Crema Burrito Crema Get the Money
Sweet Chili Shrimp Tacos
Grilled Chicken Bowl
Tacos with Chips
Nachos the Works
Jalapeño Popper
Bone in Wings
Burritodilla
Burrito Bowl
Tator Tots

“I cannot describe in words how great of a place Bubbakoo’s Burritos is. I would say I average Bubbakoo’s for dinner at least twice a week, and I have never been disappointed in my life. I get a variety of items off their menu, and each item has been served hot and fresh. The place is very clean and the employment is top notch. I get greeted with a “hello” and as I exit they say “have a nice day”“

4.1 Good29 Reviews
Bubbakoo's Burritos Mexican • $
1311 NJ-37, Toms River

Customers` Favorites

Chi-Wawa with Grilled Chicken and Veg
Tacos Soft or Hard Shell
Cheese Quesadilla
Nachos the Works
Burrito Bowl
Taco Salad
Steak
Bean

“It was an online order that was ready when I got there. Food was warm when I got home, container was filled to the brim and it was delicious. I walked in the store to pick it up, the place was clean and had nice music playing and I was greeted with a friendly hello.“

3.8 Good49 Reviews
El ranchero Mexican Restaurant Mexican • $
950 Hooper Ave, Toms River

Customers` Favorites

Churros with Ice Cream
Chicken Quesadilla
Super Nachos
Al Pastor
Tortillas
Tostadas
Salsas
Chips
Tacos

“Their food is really great and the portion sizes are also really good. The mangonada is very good as well as the agua de jamaica it’s a must every time I come. You can tell they always want everyone to have a good experience they are very friendly. Would recommend!!“

3.8 Good32 Reviews
El Campesino Mexican • $
970 NJ-166, Toms River

“Finally stop in here usually go to another local Mexican place. I bought some hard shell tacos a Horchata. Both were excellent really enjoyed their sauces will definitely put this in my stops when in town. It's looks a little run down but food made up for it.“

3.9 Good10 Reviews

13
Tenampa

Tenampa Mexican • $
1341 US-9, Toms River

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Chimichanga Smothered
Burrito & Chile Relleno
Enchiladas Marinas
Chips and Salsa
Rice and Beans
Rice & Beans
Carne Asada
Enchiladas

“Our delivery order was great - generous portions, hot, authentic flavors, and awesome chips and salsa. The chicken quesadillas are incredible - packed full of juicy chicken. Nobody in the area makes them quite this fat or tender; I'm so happy I found my new quesadilla spot! We'll definitely be ordering from here again. Thanks!“

3.7 Good26 Reviews
Azteca Mexican Restaurant and Bakery Mexican • $
1580 US-9, Toms River

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Fajitas
Birria Tacos
Chimichanga
Enchiladas

“Just got my order from Uber Eats a little while ago and there aren't enough good things I can say about this place. First and foremost every single item was absolutely delicious. Everything was fresh vibrant and tasty and oh let me tell you about those churros! This place is my go-to for Mexican hands down I would highly recommend this place if you really want to taste fresh authentic Mexican food!“

3.7 Good26 Reviews
Taco-Tastic ll Mexican • $$
207 Main St, Toms River

Customers` Favorites

Beef and Cheese Empanadas
Mexicano Burrito Bowl
3 Munchies Tacos
Campesinos Tacos
Beef Taco
Al Pastor
Tortillas

“If you love authentic tacos and Mexican food they will bring you back for more! The fish tacos and golden tacos with steak are awesome with fresh cilantro and of course with corn tortillas! They have a menu you just want to order everything on it ! A+ in my book!!!!!“

3.6 Good57 Reviews
Bubbakoo's Burritos Mexican • $
1849 Hooper Ave, Toms River

Customers` Favorites

Burrito

“FINALLY I made it to a Bubbakoos Burrito! I've been waiting to try since my friend told me it was similar to a Chipotle. Well I kinda like it more than Chipotle. Super friendly staff. Two young ladies worked the front of the counter. They were able to explain what was offered on the menu. Both were extremely patient with my large part of pre-teens! Lol I believe one of the girl's name was Annamaria. High recommend. Food was good, staff was friendly, place was clean, bathrooms as well so I would say it was good and would definitely come back“

3.5 Good16 Reviews
Loading...
map Map