facebook instagram facebook instagram

The Penny Pub

$$ • Pubs

Hours:
79 W Main St, Bay Shore
(631) 969-4061

Take-Out/Delivery Options

Customers' Favorites

The Penny Pub Reviews

4 (56)
Always come for the food was here on 2/20 and my id was scanned but a few weeks ago was not, so my issue was that people walked in and did not have to scan the id but my id was then my fiancé drinks cognac and they so not serve that so we asked what they have on the menu the bartender did not offer they margarita Monday special at all n charged us for a double if casamigo but we surely never asked for a double I was unleashed with how we were treated by the bartender he wasn’t...read full review

Got a burger with bacon and cheese, and order of fish and chips, and an order of friesEverything came out amazing but if I am paying $8 for fries I expect a separate container with fries, not 10 fries thrown into the same container as the burgerTarter sauce for the fish was amazing ?

The Penny Pub is our most favorite bar in town! Awesome food & well made drinks. Great manager & staff! Such a very hard working group & it can be very crazy & packed pub at times but the staff always handles it amazingly well! When we go there we look forward to seeing them all! They like my family when I go there. Last night when we went to the pub we didn’t see one of our favorite bartender Jake . I asked where is Jake tonight & was told he was let go because he can’t...read full review

More Reviews(184)

Ratings

View all photos

Hours

Monday 12PM - 4AM
Tuesday 12PM - 4AM
Wednesday 12PM - 4AM
Thursday 12PM - 4AM
Friday 12PM - 4AM
Saturday 12PM - 4AM
Sunday 12PM - 4AM
Updated on: