“Excellent Vegetarian Pizza ExperienceI recently enjoyed a delightful visit to this pizza restaurant, and it exceeded my expectations. The vegetarian pizza was incredibly delicious, meeting every craving I had. The customer service was exceptional, going above and beyond to ensure a pleasant dining experience. Timing was spot-on, with prompt service that didn't compromise quality.My only wish is that the restaurant had tables for a more comfortable dine-in experience. Nevertheless, the outstanding pizza and top-notch service make it a place I'd happily return to for another fantastic meal.“
“" You get what you work for and you work hard to get better. Not for the people but for the self satisfaction" . I just had a convo with a worker and this dude blew my fricken mind away with his intelligence!! My new friend better be working when I get there cause thats my mans now !!“
“I went almost at closing time. The employee were friendly and joking around. The pizza is what you would expect; nothing more nothing less. The atmosphere is okay at best. It's a take out shop and it feels like one, nothing there is telling you stay and eat.“
“There's nowhere to sit and no tables not even to wait for your order. I was told to pick it up at a certain time and when I got there which was 10 minutes before that time I was told that I have to wait 30 minutes so I had to stand in the store waiting for my order when the pickup time was supposed to be 10 minutes from the time that I arrived. The lines can get pretty long thank goodness I arrived before the line was to the door. I really wish they had chairs ?????. The parmesan boneless wings and garlic knots were delicious ?? I didn't purposely get that ? I meant to get bone in wings but woo child both was so good so it didn't even matter ?. I was eating as I was walking home so I wasn't able to take pictures LOL but I do highly recommend those two, the pizzas, and desserts ?. Great prices and delicious ?.“
“No idea why there are so many negative reviews. Some people are stating they can get better pizza elsewhere. So if you can go for it...there are other local pizzerias in the area however I think Papa Johns is the one that. Will always offer better deals for a larger party. It's usually fast and cheaper if I were to add half a topping, rather than an average pizza shop. Besides these prices are worth it. Everything else around is increasing. Who wouldn't prefer this menu? And their garlic bread is so delish.“
“When you want good pizza fast (and late at night) this Papa John's delivers in every sense of the word. The only reason it's 4 stars and not 5 stars is because I prefer mom & pop pizzerias (as opposed to chain restaurants). But you can't go wrong with their pizza and their reliable delivery.“
“Believe it or not, this is already one of the best pizza place in the neighborhoods, if you compare their prize to quality. Also believer or not, this is one of the pizzeria you will visit frequently for anyone lives in Sunset Park. Their specialty pizza is really not that bad. Don't waste your money on other nearby lousy pizzeria where you'll have to spend $25+ for a large average pizza anyway. Always order on their moblie app. It's just another dollars saving day at Papa John's, that's about it.“
“Love this neighborhood papa John’s place is fast with takeout or delivery. I usually call and order for takeout and within 10 mins or less, the food be ready ? the “Shaq-A-Roni” pizza is our favorite pizza and it’s always fresh and delicious. Love the service, as soon as you get off the phone you get a text notification that your food is in the oven and you get real time updates until your food is ready to be picked up??. If you live close by or if you’re ever in the area make sure to check them out. This location is on Nostrand Ave, between Foster Ave and Newkirk Ave. Staff is always nice and easy going big ups to them hope they keep this up. The area is usually busy as this location is on the same block as 2 different supermarket and a beauty supply store but you can always double park to run in, grab your food and go.“
“I don’t know about all delivery situation to be honest but when you choose pick up option, pick the date when asian guy with glasses working at the counter. He is so helpful and very professional to handle everything even busy situation. Pizza is always great, and this epic crust is game changer.. ??“
“Man, rough reviews below, but I’m sticking to my honest opinion anyway. My order via the Pappa Johns app was ready by the time I was done getting dressed to go pick it up. The person who interacted with me had some minor language challenges, but other than that it was a smooth transaction. The best part was that the extra large Hawaiian pizza was perfectly made, so I had a 5 star experience. This was my first time ordering from this Pappa John’s.“
“Take out/delivery option. Limited to no indoor seating. Order for a Papadilla took a while, but staff was friendly and willing to help. In NYC, with millions of options, sometimes you just want BBQ chicken pizza. Papa Johns is here for that need.“
“The young woman at the register was so kind and patient. It’s so rare to get great customer service with a smile. I wish I got her name because her employer needs to know her value. The pizza was also the best I’ve had from papa John’s in a long time.“
“I have been a customer for many years at their old location. The staff is different at the new location but they’re respectful and customer friendly. The store is clean and it’s nice visiting there. Sometimes the wait can be a bit long but the prices are good that’s why I keep going back?. There was an issue with my order and upon getting home that’s when I realized it. I called the store and being that I was unable to go back to the store to rectify the issue, AMAZING Papa Johns sent out a delivery guy to bring me a replacement order. I was so blown away and happy about that, my kids got their dinner?They got me as a customer for life. Good work Papa Johns.“
“I don't understand all the negative reviews of this place. When I order take out it's ready in 10 minutes and perfect. They haven't once mess up my order. When I order delivery the drivers are super friendly. The driver accidentally forgot part of my order and apologized several times and went back and got it to me ASAP. Great service!“
“I had a good experience here picking up pizza for a couple of times during a trip.Pizza was fresh and hot. Ingredients were also fresh.Unfortunately they don’t have no seating area here so it’s only for pick up or delivery, so that’s a 4 star experience for me.“
“The food is on point . It really is good . Safe to say , they are slow as heck though for delivering , and also slow as heck when you carryout . Only thing you should do is call ahead of time before you want your order . Other than that , they are the best papa johns hands down in brooklyn“
“A few days ago I bought a pizza and it came like this. I called the store and they made it right. They resent a pizza and waited outside for me to retrieve it. Thank you Papa johns for making this right. ???I only took off one star for the initial delivery inconvenience.“
“We have ordered the gluten free pizza from here several times and it has been good. Today, they got our order messed up so I called in to let them know. The manager was super apologetic and immediately sent out the correct order. Very good service :)“