facebook instagram facebook instagram

Mister Pizza Elmwood

$ • Pizza, Chicken Wings

Hours:
1065 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo
(716) 882-6500

Take-Out/Delivery Options

Customers' Favorites

Mister Pizza Elmwood Reviews

3 (85)

Love-hate relationship with Mr Pizza. The food is mostly good, and the service is gruff but good. The sauce is top-notch, but not always (consistency issues). And good mozzarella.They need a dedicated phone person so you don't get the "Mr Pizza Elmwood, please hold - click".... I feel bad for the front-end staff.Dietary restrictions: Gluten free crust

BEWARE!! I witnessed an older lady making pizza with her bare hands. She stopped to cash a customer out. Then, she went right back to putting her nasty bare hands back into the box of cheese and continued to make the pizza without washing her hands. A few seconds later, she was on her phone and then again back to making the pizza. Once she was done, she wiped her hands on her butt and grabbed her phone. NEVER NEVER GOING BACK. PLEASE BEWARE!

Ordered a sheet pizza and 50 wings pack. They told me 50 minutes, I got there at the hour mark and waited an extra 30 minutes because they said there was two people with the same name but for some reason couldn’t differentiate the orders? Didn’t come back and ten minutes after that I eventually got my cold food. Pissed and a waste of $90. No apology or anything to make up for it either.

More Reviews(291)

Ratings

View all photos

Hours

Monday 9AM - 12AM
Tuesday 9AM - 12AM
Wednesday 9AM - 12AM
Thursday 9AM - 12AM
Friday 9AM - 1AM
Saturday 9AM - 1AM
Sunday 9AM - 12AM
Updated on: