facebook instagram facebook instagram

Pizza Supreme

$ • Pizza

Hours:
678 Stewart Ave, Garden City
(516) 228-4300

Take-Out/Delivery Options

Customers' Favorites

Pizza Supreme Reviews

4.4 (43)

Pizza Supreme used to be located in Roosevelt Field near the Time Out Arcade. The square pie was always amazing. There is nothing better than a piping hot square slice with that incredible mozzarella on top, that delicious sauce and a nice crisp crust. Brings you back. Pizza Supreme is a gem.

For years, Pizza Supreme has consistently delivered a delicious mouthful of Italy. Famous for their square pizzas, always add their garlic knots to your order. These gems are a perfect combo of taste, size, and texture. Five stars on all levels. I particularly enjoy their meatball Parmigiano heros. Crusty Italian bread comfortably holds well seasoned moist meatballs, gooey cheese, and flavorful sauce. Lucky are those who also work nearby as it is a convenient spot to get lunch...read full review

Joe and his team are so nice! I’ve never had a bad experience. Food is delicious and fresh. And, you MUST order a square pie - - my family’s all time favorite and yummy! Great portions too! Highly recommend Pizza Supreme! A++++Parking: Parking is conveniently right outside of the restaurant

More Reviews(165)

Ratings

View all photos

Hours

Monday 11AM - 9PM
Tuesday 11AM - 9PM
Wednesday 11AM - 9PM
Thursday 11AM - 9PM
Friday 11AM - 9PM
Saturday 11AM - 9PM
Sunday 12 - 7PM
Updated on: