My wife and I stopped in for the first time this past Saturday and smiled when we saw the sign for Fin Your Fishmonger! Had to go in and look. Left for a few and came back and ordered the smoked bay scallops, smoked salmon and smoked bluefish because we didn't have a cold bag to bring fish back to the house 45 minutes away.The scallops, salmon and bluefish were absolutely delicious and will be a regular order for us. The store was clean and charming and didn't have any objectionable odors. The young lady who helped us was sweet as can be and engaging! Very rare these days with the younger folks.Nice selection of fish and it looked fresh. We also noted they were bringing in some fresh cases of product. Next visit we will be prepared with a cold bag or 2 and some ice packs.Going to try the fish tacos next visit.
John Mcmullen
Pricey but best seafood around. Always fresh and delicious
matt schreiner
Excellent fish, oysters and salads.
Ingvor van Zuuk
Have tried 3x now and I'm done. Fish is never great quality in terms of freshness. I've been a Chef 40 yrs and my guess is they purchase once a week and have poor refrigeration. Coupled with unfriendly owners and staff it was a big disappointment. Three strikes your out !
Shucker Paddy
Super friendly and Knowledgeable crew and fab-fresh-fish!
Lee K.
I was curious about their fish selection, so I stopped in around lunchtime. They have an extensive selection of fish, considering their tiny size. Numerous types of salmon are available. Today's special taco was Mahi Mahi, which is one of my favorite fish. I'm unable to eat anything that needs chewing (dental surgery), but went with a 1/4 lb container of the whitefish salad. I'm Jewish, grew up on the stuff. This was the BEST whitefish salad I have ever had in my life! Not weak, not too strong, it the baby bear of whitefish salads imo.
Ilyssa K.
Fresh fish good prices! Fish and chips and fried clams were outstanding! Teds was closed so we found this gem
Royal Kennedy
Fin is an excellent source for fresh and cooked seafood . We recently got some 8 oz lobster tails and some jumbo sea scallops . Everything g including their New England clam chowder was great !
Judith M.
I have been looking for a fish monger since I moved here in 2017. Tried a place or two.Meh. I am in love with Fin. The assortment was great even though it was noon on New Years Eve day. They were to close at two. The staff are knowledgeable and when I asked a dumb question they just answered. Then gave me the info I needed to know.We got scallops (most awesome) Haddock, Little Neck clams. Just amazing. Go there.
Best salmon I've ever had at any restaurant. They do a mean shrimp or oyster po'boy too.
Laura Leguia
Oh my god this store is beautiful, and the fish is amazing. The texture is just like I remember from my childhood. Very high quality fish, expertly chosen and artfully cleaned.
Jennifer Wick
Great local fishmonger. Reminds me of the variety I could get shopping down in Queens, but the quality is even better here. Love to get the take and bake meals. Also fun to try different seafood out and ask the friendly and helpful staff for suggestions on meal plans and recipes related to what I buy. Highly recommend to anyone who wants quality seafood or to just get out of the supermarket fish counter environment and try something different.
Willie McMichael
Great customer service, the fish and chips were Great!
James D.
It's sad to see how few fish markets exist in Central New York these days. I'm from Schoharie Village and travel to fin - your fishmonger because I think their fish and other seafood products are worth it. I love the tuna poke and think it is worth every cent! Looking forward to trying the oysters this summer! You will not be disappointed with any of the fresh fish offerings!
Great Fish Fry!
My wife and I stopped in for the first time this past Saturday and smiled when we saw the sign for Fin Your Fishmonger! Had to go in and look. Left for a few and came back and ordered the smoked bay scallops, smoked salmon and smoked bluefish because we didn't have a cold bag to bring fish back to the house 45 minutes away.The scallops, salmon and bluefish were absolutely delicious and will be a regular order for us. The store was clean and charming and didn't have any objectionable odors. The young lady who helped us was sweet as can be and engaging! Very rare these days with the younger folks.Nice selection of fish and it looked fresh. We also noted they were bringing in some fresh cases of product. Next visit we will be prepared with a cold bag or 2 and some ice packs.Going to try the fish tacos next visit.
Pricey but best seafood around. Always fresh and delicious
Excellent fish, oysters and salads.
Have tried 3x now and I'm done. Fish is never great quality in terms of freshness. I've been a Chef 40 yrs and my guess is they purchase once a week and have poor refrigeration. Coupled with unfriendly owners and staff it was a big disappointment. Three strikes your out !
Super friendly and Knowledgeable crew and fab-fresh-fish!
I was curious about their fish selection, so I stopped in around lunchtime. They have an extensive selection of fish, considering their tiny size. Numerous types of salmon are available. Today's special taco was Mahi Mahi, which is one of my favorite fish. I'm unable to eat anything that needs chewing (dental surgery), but went with a 1/4 lb container of the whitefish salad. I'm Jewish, grew up on the stuff. This was the BEST whitefish salad I have ever had in my life! Not weak, not too strong, it the baby bear of whitefish salads imo.
Fresh fish good prices! Fish and chips and fried clams were outstanding! Teds was closed so we found this gem
Fin is an excellent source for fresh and cooked seafood . We recently got some 8 oz lobster tails and some jumbo sea scallops . Everything g including their New England clam chowder was great !
I have been looking for a fish monger since I moved here in 2017. Tried a place or two.Meh. I am in love with Fin. The assortment was great even though it was noon on New Years Eve day. They were to close at two. The staff are knowledgeable and when I asked a dumb question they just answered. Then gave me the info I needed to know.We got scallops (most awesome) Haddock, Little Neck clams. Just amazing. Go there.
Restaurantji Recommends
Best salmon I've ever had at any restaurant. They do a mean shrimp or oyster po'boy too.
Oh my god this store is beautiful, and the fish is amazing. The texture is just like I remember from my childhood. Very high quality fish, expertly chosen and artfully cleaned.
Great local fishmonger. Reminds me of the variety I could get shopping down in Queens, but the quality is even better here. Love to get the take and bake meals. Also fun to try different seafood out and ask the friendly and helpful staff for suggestions on meal plans and recipes related to what I buy. Highly recommend to anyone who wants quality seafood or to just get out of the supermarket fish counter environment and try something different.
Great customer service, the fish and chips were Great!
It's sad to see how few fish markets exist in Central New York these days. I'm from Schoharie Village and travel to fin - your fishmonger because I think their fish and other seafood products are worth it. I love the tuna poke and think it is worth every cent! Looking forward to trying the oysters this summer! You will not be disappointed with any of the fresh fish offerings!